Posts: 1,077
Threads: 70
Joined: Oct 2024
Reputation:
6
06-12-2025, 12:23 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2025, 12:31 PM by Old Fart.)
(06-12-2025, 12:01 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Proth,
Can you please tell me when people started getting taxed on rental income and not rental profits. This is a new one on me.
And this one:
Please tell me the logic in creating a system of taxation that actively discourages people to save for their own retirement? I'm going to guess that you and your Mrs both contribute £60k via your companies into personal pensions. In doing so saving £30k of Corporation Tax, which is a reasonable tax planning strategy. Why do you feel discouraged to do this? Potential IHT? It's untaxed money, I think it's fairly reasonable for that to be subject to IHT, more so than cash savings.
Re the rental income. George Osborne introduced a graduated system of taxation so that over a four year period (25% per year) landlords would not be able to deduct their mortgage costs from their income. Known as section 24 tax. The first year it applied was 2016/17 at 25% allowance and by 2021 it was fully imposed at 100%.
So before section 24
rental income £600 per month
Mortgage costs £300 per month - all allowable as a cost.
Other costs insurance repairs etc £100 per moth
Profit £200 per month. Tax due £40 for a 20% tax payer, £80 for a 40% tax payer.
Once section 24 was fully implemented (2021)
Rental income £600 per month
Mortgage costs £300 per month less 20% tax free so only £60 allowable against tax
Other costs £100 per month
Taxable profit now up to £440. so £88 for a 20% tax payer and £176 for a 40% tax payer.
If the house is empty for a month, your costs are still £300 less 20% so £240 after tax relief, plus £100 other costs so you make a loss of £340 per month as 80% of the mortgage can not be claimed as a cost even though the landlord has no income. Therefore you are effectively taxed on income not profit.
Over 400,000 landlords then set themselves us a limited companies so that they could operate like any other business in that tax is due on income less ALL costs including mortgages. So they can draw a wage for work done in the business and pay income tax on that. Any company profit is then subject to Corporation Tax, and any dividend paid to the company directors is taxable too.
Many landlords looked at transferring their houses to the limited company, but HMRC viewed that as the house being sold so the company would have to pay stamp duty on the purchase. If the landlord was staying in the game for the next 20 years, the stamp duty could be amortised over that period. But for older landlords paying say £25,000 stamp duty on a house they already own was not viable
Don't forget that if an individual buys a house and pays say 2% stamp duty, a landlord has to pay 3% on top of that. Various smart arse financial advisers came up with all sorts of clever tricks to get round this, and they are now being investigated aggressively by HMRC.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(06-12-2025, 10:58 AM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: And no, I'm not telling you "what you actually think", quite the opposite in fact. I'm saying you're completely oblivious to how you come across and the implication/meaning behind what you're saying.
Touche. And let's leave it there eh?
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(06-12-2025, 08:41 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I understand Adam Smith's suggestion that Enlightened self-interest refers to the concept that regard for one's own good prompts a person to assist in promoting the good of others.
Have you read Moral Sentiments? Because this reads like you haven't.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(06-12-2025, 12:01 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Proth,
Can you please tell me when people started getting taxed on rental income and not rental profits. This is a new one on me.
And this one:
Please tell me the logic in creating a system of taxation that actively discourages people to save for their own retirement? I'm going to guess that you and your Mrs both contribute £60k via your companies into personal pensions. In doing so saving £30k of Corporation Tax, which is a reasonable tax planning strategy. Why do you feel discouraged to do this? Potential IHT? It's untaxed money, I think it's fairly reasonable for that to be subject to IHT, more so than cash savings.
The other post has dealt with the former. Our properties are in a ltd co so the vindictive rules don't apply.
As for two, you guess wrong. It's not merely the post death IHT / Income Tax position which is nasty enough, but also the constant tinkering and likely reimposition of a lifetime cap. There's so much tied up in DC pensions that they will irresistible to a Chancellor rapidly running out of fiscal headroom. I also wish I had £120K excess profit a year that I could afford to stash away!
Don't even get me started on the state-misrepresentation of auto enrolment for those on lower wages.
Posts: 1,077
Threads: 70
Joined: Oct 2024
Reputation:
6
(06-11-2025, 04:03 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (06-11-2025, 03:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2025, 02:59 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I've just looked this up, and again, it comes back to greed and excess. Whilst that philosophy sounds good in principle, too many people don't care about others and actively position themselves in opposition of this. As an exaggerated example, there would be no need for tax specialists if people were acting in "enlightened self interest" as they'd be happy to pay taxes as prescribed. But many do their best to avoid it as much as possible.
OK. Then I'll move all my business interests overseas, sack all my contractors and use South Africans at half the price instead and move as many assets as I can too and sell the houses.
Let's see how many people that helps in the UK. I suspect it'll be none of them.
I pay whatever tax is legally due currently. But I shall be quietly quitting over the next few years as so many others are, because there are so few incentives to earn more, work longer hours, invest in property or start a business. When we've all quit, and possibly moved away. What's left?
Here it comes. The threat of the rich person to move away and disadvantage the country. No, you won't.
But if you do, look at all that property that will be spread out to others. Helping others.
And again, you talk of salaries like 50k and 100k as if they're commonplace, just shows how out of touch you are. It always comes back to wealth inequality, greed and excess.
You've proven to be the person who can't see the viewpoint of the people at the bottom. Shame on you.
https://order-order.com/2025/06/12/uk-bu...abolished/
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
06-12-2025, 01:39 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2025, 01:52 PM by CA Baggie.)
(06-12-2025, 12:23 PM)Old Fart Wrote: (06-12-2025, 12:01 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Proth,
Can you please tell me when people started getting taxed on rental income and not rental profits. This is a new one on me.
And this one:
Please tell me the logic in creating a system of taxation that actively discourages people to save for their own retirement? I'm going to guess that you and your Mrs both contribute £60k via your companies into personal pensions. In doing so saving £30k of Corporation Tax, which is a reasonable tax planning strategy. Why do you feel discouraged to do this? Potential IHT? It's untaxed money, I think it's fairly reasonable for that to be subject to IHT, more so than cash savings.
Re the rental income. George Osborne introduced a graduated system of taxation so that over a four year period (25% per year) landlords would not be able to deduct their mortgage costs from their income. Known as section 24 tax. The first year it applied was 2016/17 at 25% allowance and by 2021 it was fully imposed at 100%.
So before section 24
rental income £600 per month
Mortgage costs £300 per month - all allowable as a cost.
Other costs insurance repairs etc £100 per moth
Profit £200 per month. Tax due £40 for a 20% tax payer, £80 for a 40% tax payer.
Once section 24 was fully implemented (2021)
Rental income £600 per month
Mortgage costs £300 per month less 20% tax free so only £60 allowable against tax
Other costs £100 per month
Taxable profit now up to £440. so £88 for a 20% tax payer and £176 for a 40% tax payer.
If the house is empty for a month, your costs are still £300 less 20% so £240 after tax relief, plus £100 other costs so you make a loss of £340 per month as 80% of the mortgage can not be claimed as a cost even though the landlord has no income. Therefore you are effectively taxed on income not profit.
Over 400,000 landlords then set themselves us a limited companies so that they could operate like any other business in that tax is due on income less ALL costs including mortgages. So they can draw a wage for work done in the business and pay income tax on that. Any company profit is then subject to Corporation Tax, and any dividend paid to the company directors is taxable too.
Many landlords looked at transferring their houses to the limited company, but HMRC viewed that as the house being sold so the company would have to pay stamp duty on the purchase. If the landlord was staying in the game for the next 20 years, the stamp duty could be amortised over that period. But for older landlords paying say £25,000 stamp duty on a house they already own was not viable
Don't forget that if an individual buys a house and pays say 2% stamp duty, a landlord has to pay 3% on top of that. Various smart arse financial advisers came up with all sorts of clever tricks to get round this, and they are now being investigated aggressively by HMRC.
I'm aware of the mortgage restriction, but landlords do get a 20% tax credit to the value of the mortgage interest. Also all their other costs are allowable, letting agent fees, repairs, mileage, insurance, etc. etc.
So it's simply not true to say any landlord is taxed on their rental income as opposed to their profit.
And as said the simple way round this is a limited company, which so many people have now. If you own properties jointly and qualify as a partnership you can incorporate and lose the CGT hit too.
Proth, if the pension life time allowance isn't enough for any one single person then I'd question their life choices.
(06-12-2025, 01:36 PM)Old Fart Wrote: (06-11-2025, 04:03 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (06-11-2025, 03:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2025, 02:59 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I've just looked this up, and again, it comes back to greed and excess. Whilst that philosophy sounds good in principle, too many people don't care about others and actively position themselves in opposition of this. As an exaggerated example, there would be no need for tax specialists if people were acting in "enlightened self interest" as they'd be happy to pay taxes as prescribed. But many do their best to avoid it as much as possible.
OK. Then I'll move all my business interests overseas, sack all my contractors and use South Africans at half the price instead and move as many assets as I can too and sell the houses.
Let's see how many people that helps in the UK. I suspect it'll be none of them.
I pay whatever tax is legally due currently. But I shall be quietly quitting over the next few years as so many others are, because there are so few incentives to earn more, work longer hours, invest in property or start a business. When we've all quit, and possibly moved away. What's left?
Here it comes. The threat of the rich person to move away and disadvantage the country. No, you won't.
But if you do, look at all that property that will be spread out to others. Helping others.
And again, you talk of salaries like 50k and 100k as if they're commonplace, just shows how out of touch you are. It always comes back to wealth inequality, greed and excess.
You've proven to be the person who can't see the viewpoint of the people at the bottom. Shame on you.
https://order-order.com/2025/06/12/uk-bu...abolished/ RIGHT BIAS
These media sources are moderately to strongly biased toward conservative causes through story selection and/or political affiliation. They may utilize strong loaded words (wording that attempts to influence an audience by using appeal to emotion or stereotypes), publish misleading reports and omit reporting of information that may damage conservative causes. Some sources in this category may be untrustworthy. See all Right Bias sources.- [b]Overall, we rate Guido Fawkes Right Biased due to word choices that favor the Right and Mixed for factual reporting based on poor sourcing.[/b]
Detailed Report
Bias Rating: [b]RIGHT[/b]
Factual Reporting: [b]MIXED
[/b]Country: [b]United Kingdom
[/b]Press Freedom Rating:[b] MOSTLY FREE
[/b]Media Type: [b]Website
[/b]Traffic/Popularity: [b]Medium Traffic[/b]
MBFC Credibility Rating: [b]MEDIUM CREDIBILITY[/b]
From the website: Mediabiasfactcheck.com
One thing I've NOT changed my mind on late ifn life is taking opinion journalism as factual.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(06-12-2025, 01:36 PM)Old Fart Wrote: (06-11-2025, 04:03 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (06-11-2025, 03:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2025, 02:59 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I've just looked this up, and again, it comes back to greed and excess. Whilst that philosophy sounds good in principle, too many people don't care about others and actively position themselves in opposition of this. As an exaggerated example, there would be no need for tax specialists if people were acting in "enlightened self interest" as they'd be happy to pay taxes as prescribed. But many do their best to avoid it as much as possible.
OK. Then I'll move all my business interests overseas, sack all my contractors and use South Africans at half the price instead and move as many assets as I can too and sell the houses.
Let's see how many people that helps in the UK. I suspect it'll be none of them.
I pay whatever tax is legally due currently. But I shall be quietly quitting over the next few years as so many others are, because there are so few incentives to earn more, work longer hours, invest in property or start a business. When we've all quit, and possibly moved away. What's left?
Here it comes. The threat of the rich person to move away and disadvantage the country. No, you won't.
But if you do, look at all that property that will be spread out to others. Helping others.
And again, you talk of salaries like 50k and 100k as if they're commonplace, just shows how out of touch you are. It always comes back to wealth inequality, greed and excess.
You've proven to be the person who can't see the viewpoint of the people at the bottom. Shame on you.
https://order-order.com/2025/06/12/uk-bu...abolished/
https://bylinetimes.com/2025/06/10/the-m...-happened/
Right back atcha buddy (reposted link from KRO earlier in this very thread).
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
06-12-2025, 02:49 PM
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2025, 02:53 PM by Josh1873.)
I wonder if taxes were used efficiently and were somehow traceable to the good they do (impossible, I know) whether people would be more inclined to pay.
But when you (Daily Mail headline alert) hear of numerous scandals such as MP's expenses, the number of contracts handed out to MP's mates etc etc is it any wonder individuals do all they can to legally pay as little tax as possible, when it can seem that the tax payers money isn't being used as effectively as it should and is seemingly going on causes that doesn't really benefit the majority of people in this country that need it.
As a business my company performed excellently last financial year, and all staff are receiving a generous bonus. However, we have been told to not expect any bonus payments next year, already, as the rise in NI contributions will effectively wipe out any profits (it'll cost the company circa 1.3mill). That's a lot of money, isn't it? I wouldn't blame the owners of the company to do all they can to save on tax payments in any way they can in order to negate that excessive increase.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(06-12-2025, 01:36 PM)Old Fart Wrote: (06-11-2025, 04:03 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (06-11-2025, 03:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (06-11-2025, 02:59 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I've just looked this up, and again, it comes back to greed and excess. Whilst that philosophy sounds good in principle, too many people don't care about others and actively position themselves in opposition of this. As an exaggerated example, there would be no need for tax specialists if people were acting in "enlightened self interest" as they'd be happy to pay taxes as prescribed. But many do their best to avoid it as much as possible.
OK. Then I'll move all my business interests overseas, sack all my contractors and use South Africans at half the price instead and move as many assets as I can too and sell the houses.
Let's see how many people that helps in the UK. I suspect it'll be none of them.
I pay whatever tax is legally due currently. But I shall be quietly quitting over the next few years as so many others are, because there are so few incentives to earn more, work longer hours, invest in property or start a business. When we've all quit, and possibly moved away. What's left?
Here it comes. The threat of the rich person to move away and disadvantage the country. No, you won't.
But if you do, look at all that property that will be spread out to others. Helping others.
And again, you talk of salaries like 50k and 100k as if they're commonplace, just shows how out of touch you are. It always comes back to wealth inequality, greed and excess.
You've proven to be the person who can't see the viewpoint of the people at the bottom. Shame on you.
https://order-order.com/2025/06/12/uk-bu...abolished/
(06-12-2025, 02:49 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I wonder if taxes were used efficiently and were somehow traceable to the good they do (impossible, I know) whether people would be more inclined to pay.
But when you (Daily Mail headline alert) hear of numerous scandals such as MP's expenses, the number of contracts handed out to MP's mates etc etc is it any wonder individuals do all they can to legally pay as little tax as possible, when it can seem that the tax payers money isn't being used as effectively as it should and is seemingly going on causes that doesn't really benefit the majority of people in this country that need it.
As a business my company performed excellently last financial year, and all staff are receiving a generous bonus. However, we have been told to not expect any bonus payments next year, already, as the rise in NI contributions will effectively wipe out any profits (it'll cost the company circa 1.3mill). That's a lot of money, isn't it? I wouldn't blame the owners of the company to do all they can to save on tax payments in any way they can in order to negate that excessive increase.
A bonus is simply that, something on top of your agreed salary. Look at the state of the failing water companies over decades pumping (intended) out millions/billions in bonus’s and dividends whilst failing to invest in infrastructure.
Either people want a safety net if they get injured, lose their job, get ill, use the roads, want an an education etc or they don’t. Now some like Proth will argue that it should be up to you who you pay to do that but, when you nod along to that idea ask yourself when privatisation in this country made things cheaper or indeed particularly better? Then ask yourself what if you can’t afford to pay for these basic things?
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
Can I just state I'm not anti-tax or anything like that. But I do understand why individuals would look at legal ways of reducing how much tax they can pay.
However, companies like Amazon and Google etc. who get away with paying small corporation tax despite how much revenue they make in this county, and are effectively robbing hundreds of millions off of the government, is piss boiling.
On the subject of bonuses, I don't rely on them, or factor them into a salary, I agree, it's just that. A nice 'bonus'. What company recently took out a huge loan to be able to afford paying bonuses to their high earning staff that apparently deserve it. Was it Thames Water, or have I made that up?
|