Things you’ve changed your mind on late in life
(06-11-2025, 03:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-11-2025, 02:59 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: I've just looked this up, and again, it comes back to greed and excess. Whilst that philosophy sounds good in principle, too many people don't care about others and actively position themselves in opposition of this. As an exaggerated example, there would be no need for tax specialists if people were acting in "enlightened self interest" as they'd be happy to pay taxes as prescribed. But many do their best to avoid it as much as possible.

OK. Then I'll move all my business interests overseas, sack all my contractors and use South Africans at half the price instead and move as many assets as I can too and sell the houses.

Let's see how many people that helps in the UK. I suspect it'll be none of them.

I pay whatever tax is legally due currently. But I shall be quietly quitting over the next few years as so many others are, because there are so few incentives to earn more, work longer hours, invest in property or start a business. When we've all quit, and possibly moved away. What's left?

It sounds like you've managed to do just fine. I can't see your problem with paying taxes?
Reply
(06-11-2025, 04:34 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: It sounds like you've managed to do just fine. I can't see your problem with paying taxes?

I don't have a problem with paying taxes up to the point where I'm working for virtually nothing or actively against my own interests. Which I've reached. 

Please tell me the logic in creating a system of taxation that actively encourages people to do less work?

Please tell me the logic in creating a system of taxation that actively encourages people to move their business abroad before they sell it?

Please tell me the logic in creating a system of taxation that actively discourages people to save for their own retirement?

That's the problem I have with paying taxes.

(06-11-2025, 04:03 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: Here it comes. The threat of the rich person to move away and disadvantage the country. No, you won't.

But if you do, look at all that property that will be spread out to others. Helping others. 

And again, you talk of salaries like 50k and 100k as if they're commonplace, just shows how out of touch you are. It always comes back to wealth inequality, greed and excess. 

You've proven to be the person who can't see the viewpoint of the people at the bottom. Shame on you.

You're priceless Dear.

If you earn £100,000 in London these days - which IS commonplace - it's not even enough to buy a flat. Greed and excess? Oh my days.

WEALTH inequality is completely different to income inequality. What our taxation system (and awful housing policy) does is make it impossible for anyone under 40 to accumulate wealth, even if they're on a big salary.
Reply
Your mindset is the issue. I’d pay more tax and I have very little. Why?
Because there’s millions more desperate than me. One day I might be that desperate bloke.
I’m not pleading poverty by any means but I earn 25k and can give to charity every week. Buy someone on the street a sandwich or two and a drink. My kid works. He’ll be the first one in mine or my missus’s family to hopefully be left a house when we go.
I love him and my missus to bits and they have a roof over their heads, and eat well. We can afford to go out to football and for birthdays and Father’s/Mothers Day. We socialise with friends occasionally. We’re content.
I’m also content to give to those who need who aren’t family. It’s what I believe in.
If I have 10 pounds in my bank and give a bloke with fuck all a fiver. We’re equally as rich. It’s such a fine line. It might be me needing the help to be someone’s equal
Reply
Rolling my shirt sleeves up in hospital
Reply
(06-11-2025, 05:07 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-11-2025, 04:34 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: It sounds like you've managed to do just fine. I can't see your problem with paying taxes?

I don't have a problem with paying taxes up to the point where I'm working for virtually nothing or actively against my own interests. Which I've reached. 

Please tell me the logic in creating a system of taxation that actively encourages people to do less work?

Please tell me the logic in creating a system of taxation that actively encourages people to move their business abroad before they sell it?

Please tell me the logic in creating a system of taxation that actively discourages people to save for their own retirement?

That's the problem I have with paying taxes.

(06-11-2025, 04:03 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: Here it comes. The threat of the rich person to move away and disadvantage the country. No, you won't.

But if you do, look at all that property that will be spread out to others. Helping others. 

And again, you talk of salaries like 50k and 100k as if they're commonplace, just shows how out of touch you are. It always comes back to wealth inequality, greed and excess. 

You've proven to be the person who can't see the viewpoint of the people at the bottom. Shame on you.

You're priceless Dear.

If you earn £100,000 in London these days - which IS commonplace - it's not even enough to buy a flat. Greed and excess? Oh my days.

WEALTH inequality is completely different to income inequality. What our taxation system (and awful housing policy) does is make it impossible for anyone under 40 to accumulate wealth, even if they're on a big salary.
This says you can buy an average house in London
https://www.newsontheblock.com/news-opin...the-ladder
Commuting is also commonplace.
And could prices be so high because of how many properties are owned by the same individuals ?
Reply
(06-11-2025, 09:10 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-10-2025, 09:17 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: Simple. Tax the super rich and rich, properly. Spread wealth more, by using that tax to improve the infrastructure of the country properly, improving services, bringing down the cost of living substantially so everyone's money goes further. I'm perfectly happy being taxed at the level we are, providing everyone is taxed properly at the same, defined rates.

Fix the fucking property market by putting a cap on the number of houses people can own, especially the buy to let bullshit. Nobody, at all, needs to own more than 5 houses, especially when they can just get a new mortgage based on the income of their current "portfolio", and then get tenants to fork out to pay the mortgage. Realistically, no-one needs more than 1, but no chance we're putting that rabbit back in the hat.

Obviously, none of this will happen because the majority of the people in power ARE these rich people, who won't act against their self interest. Greed upon greed has lead us to this rampant wealth inequality, which is the single biggest problem and reason this country is mostly fucked.

If I carry on from here, I'd need to move to the politics board, so I'll leave it there.

Ah, so attack the rule of law, property rights and markets - the three things that have contributed the most to a general rise in living standards globally. 

What you're proposing is the only thing guaranteed to do the opposite.

If people were only allowed to own one home, how would I have been able to rent 6 during my adult life? What would that have meant for my labour mobility? As a tenant then and as a landlord now I recognise the vital social service the private rental sector provides...

First point, poor logic. The second point, complete bollocks.
Reply
(06-11-2025, 05:18 PM)KRO Wrote: Your mindset is the issue. I’d pay more tax and I have very little. Why?
Because there’s millions more desperate than me. One day I might be that desperate bloke.
I’m not pleading poverty by any means but I earn 25k and can give to charity every week. Buy someone on the street a sandwich or two and a drink. My kid works. He’ll be the first one in mine or my missus’s family to hopefully be left a house when we go.
I love him and my missus to bits and they have a roof over their heads, and eat well. We can afford to go out to football and for birthdays and Father’s/Mothers Day. We socialise with friends occasionally. We’re content.
I’m also content to give to those who need who aren’t family. It’s what I believe in.
If I have 10 pounds in my bank and give a bloke with fuck all a fiver. We’re equally as rich. It’s such a fine line. It might be me needing the help to be someone’s equal

This.
Reply
Mindset is a difference, you’re right. I grew up with fuck all in East Birmingham. It wasn’t fun. It wasn’t noble. It was shit. I’ve never really fancied the idea of going back there.
Reply
Proth, I’ve looked up enlightened self-interest and it is defined as “Serving the interest of others ultimately serves one’s own interests”. Which doesn’t match at all the idea that you say it does, I.e. placing one’s family first. Or am I missing something, er … that your family are “others”?
Reply
(06-11-2025, 08:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Mindset is a difference, you’re right. I grew up with fuck all in East Birmingham. It wasn’t fun. It wasn’t noble. It was shit. I’ve never really fancied the idea of going back there.

Funny enough I grew up with fuck all too. But rather than take an inherently selfish Hayekian approach,  my world view was developed in a more enlightened way that is sympathetic to a positive view of human nature. 

There is such a thing as society, not just families. People are not selfish bastards by default. Hayek , Thatcher (still dead) appeal to the most base human nature of selfishness. They and their cultist true believers propagate that rigid, pickled dogma, aided by cunts such as most of the British media. 
It is a million miles away from how I see the world, human nature or our responsibilities to care for one another.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)