How much is enough?
#41
To summarise- you looked after yourself well whilst you could take the piss and are legging it asap now that’s no longer as easy?

Amarite?

Sound like the policies are working well to me.
Reply
#42
(05-30-2025, 09:08 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: £3.4m

 3 shillings and sixpence

(05-30-2025, 09:19 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Ask yourself why I selling so much now, why I’m not the only one, why I’m planning to go down to a couple of days a week over the next five years, why I’m planning to clear out my pension funds as quickly as I can.

It’s because the tax system has made it pretty pointless to bother carrying on. There’s no point in earning a £1 more to see less than 40p of it. There’s no point growing a pension fund knowing that the state will take 40% of it on your death and maybe more if drawings continue to be made from it.

Don’t get me wrong, it’s not just Reeves far from it. But far from there being any light at the end of a very long tunnel for people like me I’m choosing to chuck the towel in before it gets any worse. And I’m far from alone.

I see your point.

I would also urge anyone who can afford to cut down on work and free some leisure time to do just that. Life is very short. 

The other thing we should all consider is part of the original question - how much is enough?
Reply
#43
(05-30-2025, 09:34 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: To summarise- you looked after yourself well whilst you could take the piss and are legging it asap now that’s no longer as easy?

Amarite?

Sound like the policies are working well to me.

Take the piss as much as you like. If you alter the incentives to work and to invest so much, don’t be surprised when people stop working and stop investing.

In the last few months I’ve lost count of the number of people I’ve met who’ve pulled oars in on their hours to avoid ridiculous income tax cliff edges, others who refuse to take work on for the last 3 months of the year to avoid being dragged into VAT (and as a consequence making all their work 20% more expensive to customers). The alterations to CGT and IHT are the final straw for me.

If the government’s aim (and not just the Labour government) was to make business a futile endeavour then they’ve succeeded in my case. One last hurrah for them in tax receipts from me this year then fuck all going forward. 

And the junior doctors want 30% more?

Proth Major is off to do economics A level in September. She’ll have a real life case study to discuss.
Reply
#44
It’s a shit sandwich Proth. We’ve all been left a horrendous 14 year mess with no easy solution to fixing it. Labour are picking up the Tory mess (society) as they did in 1997. Some folk will get agitated that it costs money to fix. That’s about all there is to it.

If you’re in a position to work less, begin the glidepath, whatever good luck to you.

Go and get a pair of hiking boots, slow down and enjoy all the shit that really matters. It’s great.
Reply
#45
I don't disagree about the legacy they've received. I carped on about it enough since 2008. The Tories didn't fix Brown's mess, they spent 10 of the 14 years kicking the can down the road and the last 4 having a collective fiscal and monetary nervous breakdown.

In 1997 Labour inherited a growing economy, benefitted massively from the opening up of China and the beneficial cap on inflation that created.

Today we're in an entirely different paradigm. The road the can's been kicked down has eventually turned into e a cul de sac. I know you all get bored about doomongering about the bond market, but the 40 year bull market in bonds is well and truly over. The bond market isn't having a tantrum every time Trump says something or Reeves or whoever in Europe backs down on "iron clad" borrowing limits - it's just returning to equilibrium, higher longer term yields as governments will eventually be forced to inflate away excess debt.

I reckon bonds might even be a good investment if you get in now for a couple of years, but thereafter inflation is just set to rob us all as it always does - and the state will stand by and say it's not our fault guv.

Meanwhile more and more people of my generation will simply throw in the towel. I wish it wasn't this way. I wish I felt motivated to work for another 10-15 years but what's the point when all the signs are that what I earn will be taxed more, the business value I create will be taxed more, the assets I acquire will be taxed more and the inheritance I leave will be taxed more. And whilst the state has just sold its stake in Natwest at a £10.5bn nominal loss (a £16.25bn real loss), I am being taxed at 24% for nominal (not real) gains on all my investments. Do you wonder why I feel the way I do?

And I have a pair of hiking boots, and I feel much better about the money we're raising for charity walking in them than I do about pretty much anything business-wise at the moment. We're truly fucked as a nation if the incentives aren't there to reward risk taking. No one in the public sector will get paid then.
Reply
#46
Do you think everyone that utilises those incentives is a wealth generating risk taker?

Or do you think it’s become the case that some of those incentives have become part of a normalised practice of fairly benign business and individuals have come to utilise them for little risk and plenty of gain
Reply
#47
(05-31-2025, 09:07 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Do you think everyone that utilises those incentives is a wealth generating risk taker?

Or do you think it’s become the case that some of those incentives have become part of a normalised practice of fairly benign business and individuals have come to utilise them for little risk and plenty of gain

I thought the board was against collective punishment?

I have started and run 4 businesses in the last 20 years. I wouldn't suggest that anyone does it now. Successive governments have encouraged investment in real assets rather than investment in wealth / job creation. The former is piss easy, the latter is a lot harder and a lot more risky. 

Successive governments have increasingly nationalised risk in the former, whilst hanging the latter out to dry.

Tell me what was ever wrong with taper relief on the sale of assets, particularly business assets? Why today,  would you spend 20 years building a business when the outlook for taxation on disposal or death is so negative? And when you're going to pay marginal rates of tax upwards of 60% on income that you draw - probably after a year of two of drawing nothing? 

What type of government would expect an economy to grow without new businesses? What type of government would expect productivity to rise without investment in plant, automation, skills etc? This one does. It's even pulled the rug from companies paying the Apprenticeship Levy - again something pooh poohed on here as if it didn't matter, when virtually all of my clients use the money they've already paid to the government to train their Level 7 staff - exactly what the fucking thing was designed for. No they're being asked to pay twice, so the Apprenticeship Levy is just another tax. Another way of screwing businesses.

So fuck them. l'll play the asset game. And offshore where I can. And I'm far from being the only one.

Did you think there wouldn't actually come a point when the State is in every part of your life fishing in your wallet where people wouldn't just start saying no?
Reply
#48
I’ll take that as a “yes”
Reply
#49
(05-31-2025, 10:24 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’ll take that as a “yes”

A yes to what? A fucked up tax code which rewards the rentier class over the entrepreneurial class?

If so, yes. And that's why you'll never achieve the growth you need to get the country back on its feet. It's as stupid and counter-productive as it gets, and it will hurt everyone particularly those who're dependent on the state for a wage or benefits.
Reply
#50
The question was whether the system was open to wide scale abuse. It is/was. I know it and you do.

Agree with you about the asset situation, that’s where all the cash is being stuffed and hoarded, and yes, it’s a growing problem

Anyhoo, you’re winding yourself up about it too much. If you’ve done well for yourself and can now prioritise enjoying life without the hassle, just do that and let it go.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)