How much is enough?
#21
How would you fund the "sensible solution"? How would you fund the "sensible solution" for every other public sector worker who'd then come knocking feeling that their pay has fallen in real terms in the last 15 years?

It's tough when reality collides with the chattering classes' "sensible solutions". It always was. Except these days it's Labour holding the baby.
Reply
#22
They don’t “feel” that their pay has fallen Proth. Let’s keep the narrative sensible and move from there.
Reply
#23
Is the answer three shillings and sixpence?
Reply
#24
(05-30-2025, 01:56 PM)Protheroe Wrote: How would you fund the "sensible solution"? How would you fund the "sensible solution" for every other public sector worker who'd then come knocking feeling that their pay has fallen in real terms in the last 15 years?

It's tough when reality collides with the chattering classes' "sensible solutions". It always was. Except these days it's Labour holding the baby.

Make those who think paying as little tax as possible is just a game pay their fair share, even if it knocks their glidepath out by a few years.
Reply
#25
(05-30-2025, 02:23 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: They don’t “feel” that their pay has fallen Proth. Let’s keep the narrative sensible and move from there.

Well the BMA are using RPI as their preferred a measure of inflation when it hasn't been in official use for over a decade, so that's not a fact - it is a narrative.

(05-30-2025, 02:53 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Make those who think paying as little tax as possible is just a game pay their fair share, even if it knocks their glidepath out by a few years.

Like most people I pay what is legally due. Does anyone on here pay more tax than is legally due? 

They're clearly even more deranged than I thought if they do.
Reply
#26
MAN WORRIES ABOUT STATE OF UK FINANCES AFTER CAMPAIGNING FOR BREXIT

High horse and pedestal for sale - see Wastelands
Reply
#27
There is absolutely no doubt that I could minimise my tax bill with all sorts of tax write offs and be far better off for it. But then I would be a hypocrite, pearl clutching with guilt. So yes I'm deranged. But then I have different world view and different view of human nature.

My brother bought a new £100k camper van thing last year as a means of reducing his tax bill. Totally legal. He's used it about twice and it sits on the driveway as an ornament rather than the money that bought it being paid to improve society. Scale that up across society.

Of course, you plead rentier poverty and say that it doesn't go on, so poor is the private sector with the spiteful Trot's squeeze on NI and private school fees etc.
I know that it's rife and standard practice.

Let's take your poor old farmers and I have literally dozens of farmer mates....how much new and unrequired plant do you think they buy, not because they need it (or even will use it much) but they'd rather buy it than hand tax over....cherry pickers, mini diggers, brand new New Hollands... When there's nothing wrong with the model theyve got from last year. Reeves was right to go after the farmers.

Suits me, I can borrow a cherry picker or mini digger gratis as they are hardly using em.
Reply
#28
(05-30-2025, 03:43 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: MAN WORRIES ABOUT STATE OF UK FINANCES AFTER CAMPAIGNING FOR BREXIT

High horse and pedestal for sale - see Wastelands

You're as bad as Dekka when it comes to avoiding the question.

(05-30-2025, 03:48 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: There is absolutely no doubt that I could minimise my tax bill with all sorts of tax write offs and be far better off for it. But then I would be a hypocrite, pearl clutching with guilt. So yes I'm deranged. But then I have different world view and different view of human nature.

My brother bought a new £100k camper van thing last year as a means of reducing his tax bill. Totally legal. He's used it about twice and it sits on the driveway as an ornament rather than the money that bought it being paid to improve society. Scale that up across society.

Of course, you plead rentier poverty and say that it doesn't go on, so poor is the private sector with the spiteful Trot's squeeze on NI and private school fees etc.
I know that it's rife and standard practice.

Let's take your poor old farmers and I have literally dozens of farmer mates....how much new and unrequired plant do you think they buy, not because they need it (or even will use it much) but they'd rather buy it than hand tax over....cherry pickers, mini diggers, brand new New Hollands... When there's nothing wrong with the model theyve got from last year. Reeves was right to go after the farmers.

Suits me, I can borrow a cherry picker or mini digger gratis as they are hardly using em.

All you're illustrating is the incompetence of politicians in creating a tax code so complex that it creates the perverse incentives you describe. Reeves has simply made it worse.

Here's another example which is directly related to the question at hand:

11 years ago I bought a property and rented it out to a tenant. I covered the service charge and maintenance over that time, but have now decided to sell it.

The value has increased by about £150,000 - in nominal terms and so I’m faced with a CGT charge on that gain of 24%.

But here’s the thing – adjusted for inflation the property has just about held its own. There’s been no increase in real terms.

We pay tax on nominal gains, not real gains.

Same applies to all investments subject to CGT.

There used to be an indexation allowance which factored RPI into the calculation and tapered down the tax if you held the asset for a longer period.

That makes more sense as it encourages long-term investing.



So is it "fair" that the doctors can get compensation for a "real" reduction in wages, paid for - in part - by CGT receipts based on nominal gains? And when my CGT allowance has been slashed from £12,000 to £3,000?
Reply
#29
I think we may finally be getting to the titty babby nub of the question
Reply
#30
I like to think that someone at HMRC sits there every January 31st and vires Proth's tax directly into a Junior Doctor's DB pension
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: