05-11-2025, 03:36 PM
(04-22-2025, 11:32 PM)ghanaian_baggie Wrote: I haven't played the game, and want to avoid spoilers for future episodes, so apologies for not reading the thread.
However, how is the 2nd episode on IMDB rated so high?
There are so many issues with the attack on the town part of the storyline.
In no particular order.
After the initial outbreak, we've only once seen hundreds of infected. Now we have what hundreds and hundreds, if not thousands. And judging by the lack of fungus growth, most were recently infected - and most came came out of a relatively small frozen lake at the bottom of a hill? How is it possible that so many were laying domant in such a rural area? How is it possible so many were underground?
Where do mushrooms come from? You've answered your own question i think.
There was a group of 50-100 in the last episode who were ambling about - how was there enough to sustain that group? That felt a bit out of place, we've generally not seen so many previously (with the exception of the first outbreak, and once when they came out of a tunnel). There was a comment about one (or was it a few) coming out, but zero to indicate that hundreds and hundreds.
The mushrooms gathered a hoard / big army (over about 7 / 8 years) which is what the perimeter scouting was about, to see if they would.
How can fungus-based life-forms survive in freezing conditions?
they should be statues - surely
Whenever you put a lifeform (dead or alive) into a the freezer, then warm it up again (potentially naturally via Earth's warmth) would it not spring to life again having defrost? Or are you suggesting its unfeasible to have hundreds of Microwaves on defrost setting, to warm up the mushrooms. Please clarify.
They were activated by one person, who they don't follow, but instead attack the camp.
How come they go to the camp?
Is it the fungus in the pipe - but in this episode, this is shown after they are heading for the town (or am I mistaken?).
.
The camp was relying on a single wall, and a few drums of explosive liquid. No use of hundreds of years of knowledge on how to build defenses.
The cars weren't parked side on, but had small wedges, to block the gate.
There is a clear lack of electronics. Throughout TLOU. This answer this.
During the attack, all of a sudden, the infected have a hive mind and go to a poorly defended part of the wall, which happens to be weak. How did they possibly know that this section of the wall was weak? It looked no better made than any of the other sections.
No idea, I think this maybe something from the game I've forgot. Perhaps the mushrooms were opportunistic?
And no proper centre line of defence. Anyone would have either have built heavily reinforced walls, made a double wall, built a moat, developed obstacles or something.
What do you think this is? 8th Century Tamworth? These are frickin walking homicidal mushrooms FFS sakes!
Because Joels brother goes for the larger infected creature - all the rest ignore him
Similar happens later on with his wife.
We don't see anyone turn - are they still even infectious?
We know that the infected aren't as capable - Joel and his girlfriend struggled to deal with two in the library in season 1, (two strong, capable and experienced fighters), and Ellie easily kills one during the last episode. Ellie clearly being much weaker, with apparently much less ability to fight?
Erm... right, so there is clearly a hierarchy on strength of respective mushrooms. And?
It is clear that humans are losing and doing so badly (unsurprising, as it looks like there are only a couple of hundred people - at most) and then the dogs are released.
These 12 dogs win the battle. Leaving several survivors to deal with those who've been bitten - and it seems that nobody turned??
How do you know that they haven't turned? It takes about 2 days or so to turn. A bloater (big boss type one) takes a couple of years (per the game), so the mushrooms are in it for the long game, ay it. To answer straightforwardly, TLOU is not like Walking Dead where people turn quicker.
Did you notice that the guns had no recoil?
I assume that they've been manufacturing fuel/alcohol and bullets - this could have been shown, even briefly, in the last episode, even in the background as part of the town's preparations.
Crikey this is a bit British Army Yearbook ay it?!?!
I thought season one was brilliant. But the whole attack on the town felt so random, and not remotely possible in the world that has been built so far.
Unfortunately to say, and Midge and whomever played TLOU, may agree with me in that the series is extremely well done in comparison to the game, as there are clearly things that the game is unable to coherently replicate to the TV screen. With that said the TV show has generously gifted and kept to story (somewhat). It is technically on track in its current episodes with series two, but in fairness if you never played the PlayStation games, just sit back and enjoy.
Responses.


