Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(05-28-2025, 07:30 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Crikey, last time I saw pant wetting on this scale was when Megson got the job...
For the record, IF, he takes the job, he gets 100% and total support from me from the off. A completely clean slate and then judged on what he does.
I have absolutely no idea what type of coach he is, what type of person he is, how he likes to set up, how he fits in what Nestor would like. I have no idea if it will work so I'm not going to cough up a lung full of bile and lose my mind before he's even through the door.
What I do know is:
The club WILL know most the answers to the questions I say above. They won't have randomly picked a name out of a hat. They'll have interviewed, more than once. Spoken to people who know him well and seen something that has really impressed them.
It would be a gamble but every single appointment is. Especially when you're fighting hard to ensure you don't breach PSR and every penny is being counted. I have yet to hear of an outstanding candidate that everyone agrees upon that's realistic, attainable and affordable.
Rohl? Even Southampton baulked at the compo wrangle.
Cooper, on a fortune still for Leicester and happy to sit on that.
Cifuentes, most people stuck their noses up as they think he failed at qpr this season.
Norwich, a club similar to us, are choosing a bloke who 3 months ago was being slaughtered by his own fans at Bristol City. There's really not outstanding candidates out there in our position.
We aren't a huge catch, we are a club very much in transition. It needs someone willing to take a risk with us, similar to us needing to take a risk with him. It could be an absolute masterstroke, it could be a disaster. Let's give him the chance, if appointed, to show us what he can do rather than make our minds up based on guesswork.
This is pretty much where I am too, great post Rich.
So many times when a young manager dies well at a club as their first job, our fans cry we never seem to do that, now we apparently are, fans are crying about it.
Posts: 7,988
Threads: 145
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation:
15
(05-28-2025, 07:52 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: [
This is pretty much where I am too, great post Rich.
So many times when a young manager dies well at a club as their first job, our fans cry we never seem to do that, now we apparently are, fans are crying about it.
Fuggin' 'ell even we don't bump them off, even if a few would e deserved it
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
It's also very much worth pointing out that the last two experienced, established managers with promotions on their CVs turned out to be two of our worst appointments ever.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(05-28-2025, 07:49 AM)MrBater Wrote: Unknown bloke with Anglo-Saxon name gets job - boooo
Unknown bloke with exotic name gets job - oooohh we are so forward looking and modern
Think that about sums this up (if it is Mason). Nobody knows how Wicky would've done, but arguably Mason has better UK experience at a higher level.
As long as he actually tries to play football and not some of the dire crap we've had since Slav went then for me that'll be a step up. If he's another Pulis with a foreign name then that'll be annoying.
Let it go man, it's unseemly.
Posts: 19,719
Threads: 2,734
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
49
(05-28-2025, 07:54 AM)MrBater Wrote: (05-28-2025, 07:52 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: [
This is pretty much where I am too, great post Rich.
So many times when a young manager dies well at a club as their first job, our fans cry we never seem to do that, now we apparently are, fans are crying about it.
Fuggin' 'ell even we don't bump them off, even if a few would e deserved it 
We've had a few who did metaphorically!!
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
05-28-2025, 08:03 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-28-2025, 08:10 AM by Duffers.)
(05-28-2025, 07:54 AM)MrBater Wrote: (05-28-2025, 07:52 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: [
This is pretty much where I am too, great post Rich.
So many times when a young manager dies well at a club as their first job, our fans cry we never seem to do that, now we apparently are, fans are crying about it.
Fuggin' 'ell even we don't bump them off, even if a few would e deserved it 
They just died inside.
(05-28-2025, 12:08 AM)1952 Wrote: SOOOO UNDERWHELMING
Why exactly?
The guy is a completely blank slate, no evidence to suggest he’ll either be good or bad. So why is it so underwhelming?
Reminds me of the Clarke appointment. Happy to wait and see how it all pans out with him in charge.
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
Christ on a bike. I thought i'd stumbled onto H&V for a minute.
Theres a few on here, and elsewhere, who already have the 'B' of Boo on the tip of their tongue.
He's not even found his reserved parking space at the training ground and he's being written off.
Ryan, if i was you mate, go elsewhere. If you're not 3-nil up in 20mins first game of the season or if you haven't coached our journeyman bog standard players into Lamine Yamal overnight, you'll be getting pelters.
Posts: 7,999
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(05-27-2025, 11:08 PM)Squid Wrote: Meanwhile, in our local press, Lewis Cox states:
"It’s not a 100pc given Ryan Mason is the new #wba head coach yet but, if he is, am told he’s a seriously fierce driven individual who will not stand for messing. No surprise given his step from playing to coaching so young. A very solid, organised tactician too, is what I hear." This seems to have been ignored, but, whatever you think of Cox, he's more ITK than anyone on here (except Dood, of course), and it doesn't fit the rhetoric that he is too young, naive and will be bullied by the players. What it does suggest is that he is in the frame because he excelled at the interview stage, where, I would imagine, he gave his vision of how he wants to play and take the club forward. Isn't that what we all dreamed of when Bilkul took over?
Many thought Cleverly was harshly treated by Watford, but he had less experience when he took over than Mason, yet probably turned out to be one of their more sensible appointments.
We got our fingers burned with Mowbray and Bilkul's rep was damaged, but, I for one did not see that being the disaster it turned out to be. FWIW I believe that Wicky was the diligent choice but when that went tits up they turned to Johnny on the spot, thinking he would be enough to secure the play offs. So did I.
Hopefully they have learned their lesson and have gone back to their initial instincts and get the person who best fits their vision. If that's Mason, then so be it. He's certainly more exciting than some merry-go-round chancer who's just in it for the money.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-28-2025, 07:30 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Crikey, last time I saw pant wetting on this scale was when Megson got the job...
For the record, IF, he takes the job, he gets 100% and total support from me from the off. A completely clean slate and then judged on what he does.
I have absolutely no idea what type of coach he is, what type of person he is, how he likes to set up, how he fits in what Nestor would like. I have no idea if it will work so I'm not going to cough up a lung full of bile and lose my mind before he's even through the door.
What I do know is:
The club WILL know most the answers to the questions I say above. They won't have randomly picked a name out of a hat. They'll have interviewed, more than once. Spoken to people who know him well and seen something that has really impressed them.
It would be a gamble but every single appointment is. Especially when you're fighting hard to ensure you don't breach PSR and every penny is being counted. I have yet to hear of an outstanding candidate that everyone agrees upon that's realistic, attainable and affordable.
Rohl? Even Southampton baulked at the compo wrangle.
Cooper, on a fortune still for Leicester and happy to sit on that.
Cifuentes, most people stuck their noses up as they think he failed at qpr this season.
Norwich, a club similar to us, are choosing a bloke who 3 months ago was being slaughtered by his own fans at Bristol City. There's really not outstanding candidates out there in our position.
We aren't a huge catch, we are a club very much in transition. It needs someone willing to take a risk with us, similar to us needing to take a risk with him. It could be an absolute masterstroke, it could be a disaster. Let's give him the chance, if appointed, to show us what he can do rather than make our minds up based on guesswork.
I’m just playing Devil’s Advocate really but two points, the first Megson had managerial experience at Stoke and Stockport and was doing ok/well at both clubs until he either had a falling out with the owners or the owners wanted to bring in their own manager due to a change in ownership. It’s a myth that he was this unheard of manager plucked from obscurity at the time. I take your point that some didn’t want Megson but that was mainly this site, which had all the balance of a one legged sausage dog with an inner ear infection at the time. Secondly, any data driven process that churns out TM as the answer should be met with a significant degree of scepticism.
None of us have a clue whether it will work or not but given that our data driven approach process has employed an older manager with a average Champ record when everything is taken into consideration and now potentially has pin pointed a coach with no managerial experience outside of a handful of games as caretaker, I don’t think it’s unreasonable to ask questions about the owners approach to recruitment.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(05-28-2025, 07:52 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (05-28-2025, 07:30 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Crikey, last time I saw pant wetting on this scale was when Megson got the job...
For the record, IF, he takes the job, he gets 100% and total support from me from the off. A completely clean slate and then judged on what he does.
I have absolutely no idea what type of coach he is, what type of person he is, how he likes to set up, how he fits in what Nestor would like. I have no idea if it will work so I'm not going to cough up a lung full of bile and lose my mind before he's even through the door.
What I do know is:
The club WILL know most the answers to the questions I say above. They won't have randomly picked a name out of a hat. They'll have interviewed, more than once. Spoken to people who know him well and seen something that has really impressed them.
It would be a gamble but every single appointment is. Especially when you're fighting hard to ensure you don't breach PSR and every penny is being counted. I have yet to hear of an outstanding candidate that everyone agrees upon that's realistic, attainable and affordable.
Rohl? Even Southampton baulked at the compo wrangle.
Cooper, on a fortune still for Leicester and happy to sit on that.
Cifuentes, most people stuck their noses up as they think he failed at qpr this season.
Norwich, a club similar to us, are choosing a bloke who 3 months ago was being slaughtered by his own fans at Bristol City. There's really not outstanding candidates out there in our position.
We aren't a huge catch, we are a club very much in transition. It needs someone willing to take a risk with us, similar to us needing to take a risk with him. It could be an absolute masterstroke, it could be a disaster. Let's give him the chance, if appointed, to show us what he can do rather than make our minds up based on guesswork.
This is pretty much where I am too, great post Rich.
So many times when a young manager dies well at a club as their first job, our fans cry we never seem to do that, now we apparently are, fans are crying about it. Totally agree richie great post.
|