Rwanda lite
#31
(05-17-2025, 08:49 PM)baggy1 Wrote: No we didn’t - you thought wrong

So you want to completely remove WFA? Is the saving covering  the 130k jobs we need, with the imaginary stampede of U.K. citizens wanting to take them if only they paid what a £5 more an hour?
Reply
#32
No - WFA is given to those that need it now. That was sorted last year by the government, you’ve moaned about it ever since
Reply
#33
(05-17-2025, 08:58 PM)baggy1 Wrote: No - WFA is given to those that need it now. That was sorted last year by the government, you’ve moaned about it ever since

Given to those with less than £227.10 income and £10,000 in the bank because they can get pension credit, not given to those with £229 income and fuck all in the bank because they are 'rich pensioners'  - complete mess where a lot off people who definitely need it do not get it - should have been properly means tested as is housing benefit where for every £10 over an amount up to, say £15,000 income, you lose some.
Reply
#34
(05-17-2025, 08:58 PM)baggy1 Wrote: No - WFA is given to those that need it now. That was sorted last year by the government, you’ve moaned about it ever since

So it was means tested or how did they make the decision who got WFA and who didn’t? Btw until recently I had barely mentioned WFA and I only mention now in the context of how Labour are going to pay more for carers when they won’t raise taxes for individuals. The massive elephant in the the room they won’t mention.
Reply
#35
What are you talking about - previously WFA was paid to all pensioners. This government changed that to only those who receive Pension Credit should get it.
Reply
#36
(05-18-2025, 07:10 AM)strawman Wrote:
(05-17-2025, 08:58 PM)baggy1 Wrote: No - WFA is given to those that need it now. That was sorted last year by the government, you’ve moaned about it ever since

Given to those with less than £227.10 income and £10,000 in the bank because they can get pension credit, not given to those with £229 income and fuck all in the bank because they are 'rich pensioners'  - complete mess where a lot off people who definitely need it do not get it - should have been properly means tested as is housing benefit where for every £10 over an amount up to, say £15,000 income, you lose some.

Don’t disagree with that but the increases in pensions since the introduction of WFA will have covered some of that. BB did an example of pension increases a while back that compared the position to the cost of bills IIRC. It would be good to see that comparison again to show if the increases have taken away that need. I could be completely wrong there btw.
Reply
#37
(05-18-2025, 07:57 AM)baggy1 Wrote: What are you talking about - previously WFA was paid to all pensioners. This government changed that to only those who receive Pension Credit should get it.

You said it wasn’t means tested earlier in the thread. If you’re eligible for PC then you have been means tested. 

How and who is paying for the uplift in carers wages and is this going to be reflected in the absolute pittance unpaid carers get as well? Just checking as it seems missing from Labours rhetoric on this subject.
Reply
#38
Fucks same Dekka. Previously it wasn’t means tested, the changes made now mean that it is, as you say, by default through the PC process.

And on the carers issue, it is just a fact that they are underpaid. That results in the low level of care in places and vacancies in the profession. You can’t just say we want to continue with these low standards because we can’t afford it.
Reply
#39
(05-18-2025, 09:42 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Fucks same Dekka. Previously it wasn’t means tested, the changes made now mean that it is, as you say, by default through the PC process.

And on the carers issue, it is just a fact that they are underpaid. That results in the low level of care in places and vacancies in the profession. You can’t just say we want to continue with these low standards because we can’t afford it.

That’s not really answering the questions, who and how are people going to pay for the uplift in wages? Labour aren’t explaining how they intend to make this happen and they aren’t explaining who are going to take on the jobs. Going full circle, this is just Labour using populist rhetoric and not being honest with people by virtue of ignoring the fact it’s going to cost more to look after people.

I could also argue that you can’t say people who need support through PIP shouldn’t have it because it cost too much, so we are moving the goalposts and cutting £5bn, which is Labour government’s position.

There is absolutely no consistency with any of their policies, they are reactionary and knee jerk. No social care reform, but cut visas for carers with no plan in place to address the 130k vacancies, growth smaller than expected, cut billions from the disabled because it’s the easiest thing to cut.
Reply
#40
So your solution is simply to keep costs down by recruiting cheap labour.

Care costs are what they are, they’re paid for by a selection of means, government funding, insurance and personal payments. PIP is a government payment to those most in need of it, assessment is being changed to reflect the ability to continue funding where needed.

If you think we live in a country where the state can afford to pay for everything and not make sure it’s appropriate then you are deluded. WFA wasn’t needed by many, PIP is being abused in places and needs to be tightened up. Care needs to be appropriately funded.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)