Serious question
#1
So, I'm watching the cup final. Want Palace to win.
Now can anyone explain why City didn't get a free kick after Henderson handled outside the area.
Reply
#2
(05-17-2025, 04:50 PM)lesley Wrote: So, I'm watching the cup final. Want Palace to win.
Now can anyone explain why City didn't get a free kick after Henderson handled outside the area.

Can only retrospectively give a pen or red card I think.
Reply
#3
Bad decision. The VAR got it wrong for the pen as well. Biazarre all round.
Reply
#4
I really don't understand these var rules. Perhaps it's a good job I don't really need to at the moment!
Reply
#5
(05-17-2025, 05:00 PM)lesley Wrote: I really don't understand these var rules. Perhaps it's a good job I don't really need to at the moment!

Tbf the var’s don’t understand them either
Reply
#6
(05-17-2025, 04:50 PM)lesley Wrote: So, I'm watching the cup final. Want Palace to win.
Now can anyone explain why City didn't get a free kick after Henderson handled outside the area.

The goal keepers feet were grounded inside the box, it therefore doesn’t matter that he touched the ball in the ait outside. This rule stops very marginal decisions being made. Usually only keepers know. I only know this due to the PIG taking the ball outside the box against M United a few years back.
Reply
#7
Thanks everyone.
Reply
#8
VAR can’t give free kicks or yellow cards and even though it was checked, nothing they could do as wasn’t deemed to be a goal scoring opportunity. Lucky really as should’ve been a free kick and yellow which meant Henderson wouldn’t be able to get away with time wasting.

The penalty was a penalty. Bernardo got to the ball first.

Anyway, we’ll done Palace!
Reply
#9
(05-17-2025, 05:04 PM)Jerry Wrote:
(05-17-2025, 04:50 PM)lesley Wrote: So, I'm watching the cup final. Want Palace to win.
Now can anyone explain why City didn't get a free kick after Henderson handled outside the area.

The goal keepers feet were grounded inside the box, it therefore doesn’t matter that he touched the ball in the ait outside. This rule stops very marginal decisions being made. Usually only keepers know. I only know this due to the PIG taking the ball outside the box against M United a few years back.
That’s not right. The whole conversation has been around him not getting sent off as var decided it was hand ball outside the box but not an obvious goal scoring opportunity.
Where his feet were grounded is irrelevant
Reply
#10
(05-17-2025, 05:04 PM)Jerry Wrote:
(05-17-2025, 04:50 PM)lesley Wrote: So, I'm watching the cup final. Want Palace to win.
Now can anyone explain why City didn't get a free kick after Henderson handled outside the area.

The goal keepers feet were grounded inside the box, it therefore doesn’t matter that he touched the ball in the ait outside. This rule stops very marginal decisions being made. Usually only keepers know. I only know this due to the PIG taking the ball outside the box against M United a few years back.

Are you reading the rules of rugby?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: