Didn't even know it was the cup final tomorrow until now!
#21
(05-17-2025, 12:14 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: OF,

Hope you dragged your Dad to West Bromwich 11 years later...

Unfortunately not, but I was there.
Reply
#22
That singer had a mare with abide with me. I ay no musician but even I could tell she kept rushing ahead of the band.

Let's hope for a better game.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#23
Decent game. Thought Mitchell got a touch there.
Reply
#24
(05-17-2025, 03:59 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: That singer had a mare with abide with me. I ay no musician but even I could tell she kept rushing ahead of the band.

Let's hope for a better game.

I'm glad I ain't the only one that thought that.
Reply
#25
Yeah he got a toe on that
Reply
#26
Palace keeper should have been off before the debatable penalty.
Agree, it’s a fascinating contest first half.
Reply
#27
I’m confused why the keeper should have been sent off?according to the panel? He was in the area at the time.His arm was outside but his body and feet inside. What is the law?
Reply
#28
(05-17-2025, 04:22 PM)EastMidsBaggie Wrote: Palace keeper should have been off before the debatable penalty.
Agree, it’s a fascinating contest first half.

I tend to agree although good that it didn’t happen.
Reply
#29
(05-17-2025, 04:27 PM)HugeHons Wrote: I’m confused why the keeper should have been sent off?according to the panel? He was in the area at the time.His arm was outside but his body and feet inside. What is the law?

The same as if his feet and body are not over the goal line but his arm holding a ball is over the line. One is a goal the one that happened is handball and denying a goal scoring opportunity. That’s why he should have been sent off
Reply
#30
(05-17-2025, 11:26 AM)Old Fart Wrote: Two people to blame for its demise.

Man Utd / Alex Ferguson for choosing to piss off to South America to play  in the 2000 FIFA club championship that would pay well instead of playing in the FA Cup. The first club ever not to defend their title. 

And Arsene Wenger for playing his second XI in all cup ties including the League Cup by whatever name it was known at the time.

For Man Utd not to be interested in the cup and to not defend their title is an insult to those that died in the 1958  Munich air crash.    

United had lost the 1957 final to the shyte from Witton.   The 58 cup final took place three months after the crash.  Six players from the 57 final died in the crash plus two others and two others never played again due to their injuries.
Dudley's own Duncan Edwards was one of the dead. 

When the 1958 Final match programme was printed, most of the positions had no names in them as they were not sure how many players would be available.  Only two named had also played in the 57 final. 

United lost 2-0 to Bolton. 

Out of this carnage and world wide public sympathy grew the legend of the Busby Babes.   Still United decided long ago that money was more important than honour. 


I would also like to report a case of child abuse. 

 In 1957 I was dragged to the centre of Birmingham on a Sunday afternoon by my father, a Villa fan,  to witness Villa bringing the cup back to Brum. 

 I can still recall Johnny Dixon  holding the cup aloft on the balcony of the town hall. 

 I had recently fallen off the roof of the garden shed and broken my collar bone,  so it was more painful than usual watching that shyte.  

When we got home the cat had had kittens.

Also  TV for  pissing about with the start times.  The tradition was for  a 3:00 pm start.

And changing the format of the semi finals.  I still have ticket stubs from semi-final tickets at Villa Park for games not involving us.

The drama of a Saturday afternoon with four teams playing at neutral venues, usually Villa Park, or Old Trafford, or Highbury, or Hillsborough was electrifying.  Being there as a neutral was great.  I used to buy my tickets from touts which sometimes meant a very long walk home as I used my bus fare to get the ticket.


The biggest damage was caused by the abolishment of 3rd replays (and now even 1st replays), the use of Wembley for semi-finals before that and the growth of the Champion League, which led to the bigger clubs playing second teams in the early rounds to rest their players for the latter competition and the Prem where challenging for Champions League spots became more important than the early rounds of the cup. Plenty of other reasons also: over saturation of tv coverage diluting the 'speicalness' of televised matches, which were previously mainly cup focused, the new Wembley ruining the 'mystique' of reaching the 'old' stadium etc.

Took VAR 3 minutes to check what you could see in 3 seconds.

City don't even look like scoring.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)