Rwanda lite
#11
Do what, stop giving people who didn’t need it free money? My uncle laughed every time he got it as it topped up the thousands he’d got sitting in the Dudley Building Society
Reply
#12
(05-16-2025, 09:23 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Do what, stop giving people who didn’t need it free money? My uncle laughed every time he got it as it topped up the thousands he’d got sitting in the Dudley Building Society

Wasn’t it means tested to £11k?

Still defending policies that negatively effect the elderly, sick and disabled then. How’s that playing out with Starmer and Labours popularity with their core vote?
Reply
#13
11k income not savings

Sorry misread the question - the winter fuel allowance went to anyone over 65, no criteria at all. My Uncle who had six figures in the building society got it, he even got it when he was in a care home before he died. Any OAP that spent the winter on a cruise or in Spain got it. All pensioners got it - free money for being old when it wasn't needed.

You’ve gone from wanting a government that would make the tough decisions and get rid of popularism to simply wanting what the popular vote wants.
Reply
#14
(05-17-2025, 10:14 AM)baggy1 Wrote: 11k income not savings

Sorry misread the question - the winter fuel allowance went to anyone over 65, no criteria at all. My Uncle who had six figures in the building society got it, he even got it when he was in a care home before he died. Any OAP that spent the winter on a cruise or in Spain got it. All pensioners got it - free money for being old when it wasn't needed.

You’ve gone from wanting a government that would make the tough decisions and get rid of popularism to simply wanting what the popular vote wants.

It’s strange how all the ‘tough decisions’ Labour have made under Starmer are against the most vulnerable. Never against those ‘with the broadest shoulders’ as Starmer used to say. I appreciate he has absolutely no principles or convictions that he won’t move away from if it’s politically expedient to do so, as the leader of Plaid Cymru said and he petulantly dismissed, with the sycophantic Reeves guffawing in the background. 

The irony of you suggesting what I want is populist whilst Labour court Reform voters in the forlorn hope they can out Reform them. Peddling simple solutions about social care being solved by UK workers, that it won’t cost those against immigration more in taxes or loss of assets even if it’s possible, or the real possibility it’ll see care standards drop further due to a lack of staff. Not telling people who Labour hope to attract in votes the truth whilst taking for granted their core vote is not ‘grown up’ or making the ‘tough decisions’, it’s pandering, conviction free Snake Oil salesmanship that once upon an election you would have been totally against.
Reply
#15
Picking on groups of people that can't or won't react aggressively. Cowardly
Reply
#16
It’s pointless debating with you Dekka, you ignore what you don’t want to hear. There were less than 10k visas taken for socialcare last year.
Reply
#17
(05-17-2025, 12:58 PM)baggy1 Wrote: It’s pointless debating with you Dekka, you ignore what you don’t want to hear. There were less than 10k visas taken for socialcare last year.

You ignore experts and those working in social care, care homes, disability groups and charities who have all said Labours policies will see people poorer, that they won’t work and have been made before they were consulted. I’ve linked to countless articles from experts (you used to like them) and you’ve ignored them. It’s pointless debating with you because you’re unwilling to criticise Labours policies on anything.

Answer these questions… who are going to take up the 130k vacancies in Care? The 10k visas last year excuse you cling onto doesn’t answer the question. All taking away those 10k visas does is exasperate the problem further. Are you going to force uk citizens into those jobs? Does that mean people will have to pay more? Who’s paying for that ‘working people’?
Reply
#18
It's not often I agree with a Guardian columnist but I'll make an exception here:
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre...loved-ones
Reply
#19
You’re looking for a solution in the wrong place. There simply are the immigrant workforce arriving in the same numbers as there were. When the family visa was stopped the numbers dropped off a cliff.
Reply
#20
(05-17-2025, 01:48 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It's not often I agree with a Guardian columnist but I'll make an exception here:
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfre...loved-ones

It's a complete nothing burger of an article. The data she links to doesn't prove her point, either, because it's about wages per se, as opposed to within the care sector. The care sector absolutely is reliant on cheap foreign labour, because not enough British people would do such arduous work for such a low salary. However, the Zoe Williams of this world seems content for that to continue as long as she can look doey-eyed at them on the stroll home from Waitrose.

The reality of the sector is that the reliance on poorly paid labour with minimal training often means atrocious standards of care and people who wouldn't be trusted to work on a till in Spar are left looking after very vulnerable people, with often disastrous outcomes. The entire sector needs root and branch reform, including funding. Starmer should be criticised for avoiding that work in favour of currying favour with Reform voters, not because he didn't use appropriately fluffy words to talk about care workers.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)