Who rules the dressing room?
#81
I’m staggered by the idea (as others have said, unsubstantiated) that Bilkul would have refused to offer CC a new deal. Anyone from outside the club looking in under our previous owners would have seen CC was by far our best operational asset and arguably the one ‘thing’ that stopped us from ending up in a relegation battle. I appreciate the argument that another appointment could have done the same, but who knows? We can only deal with the reality that Corberan took a side bottom of the Championship to the cusp of the play-offs in one season, and achieved play-offs again the following season, without any real net spend in terms of transfers. Hence why it would be very confusing and concerning if anyone looked at that prior to buying West Brom and thought “Yeah no time for a change”.
He’s gorra gew, Franksy!
Reply
#82
Yet more unsubstantiated gossip.
Reply
#83
(05-14-2025, 05:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Yet more unsubstantiated gossip.

Rather than than personality quizzes or barbeque discussions.
Reply
#84
I believe Shilen and his team were very disappointed at the team’s capitulation against Southampton in the play off second leg. From that point on they were not convinced that CC could deliver the attacking style they wanted, nor promotion . Hence no new contract and then for them a heaven sent opportunity when CC left … compensation plus a chance for a reset. Unfortunately they may have underestimated the challenge ahead of them.

We probably would not ever have got promoted under CC - he was way too cautious but he had to be given what now seems to be the underwhelming character and skill in the current squad.

The next guy clearly needs to be some kind of genius : integrate attacking play with a bunch of guys who need being told exactly what to do or else they amble around in their own chaotic, directionless world, just happy to take a living.

Good luck Mr Nestor. You’ve a very,very tough call to make
Reply
#85
(05-14-2025, 05:50 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: I believe Shilen and his team were very disappointed at the team’s capitulation against Southampton in the play off second leg. From that point on they were not convinced that CC could deliver the attacking style they wanted, nor promotion . Hence no new contract and then for them a heaven sent opportunity when CC left … compensation plus a chance for a reset. Unfortunately they may have underestimated the challenge ahead of them.

We probably would not ever have got promoted under CC - he was way too cautious but he had to be given what now seems to be the underwhelming character and skill in the current squad.

The next guy clearly needs to be some kind of genius : integrate attacking play with a bunch of guys who need being told exactly what to do or else they amble around in their own chaotic, directionless world, just happy to take a living.

Good luck Mr Nestor. You’ve a very,very tough call to make

If this is true, it’s suggests they know very little about the Championship or even football. We lost to Southampton because they were better than us. We shudda ad a roight gud goo!
Reply
#86
It worries me when owners want 'attacking play' and seems to prefer that to you know, actual results. CC was our best chance of promotion for the foreseeable, we won't get a coach of that calibre again for a while and we will never have the resources to go all out for a promotion push, it will always be down to luck and the playoffs now.

Our owners apparently not seeing that worries me.
Reply
#87
(05-14-2025, 05:08 PM)Squid Wrote:
(05-14-2025, 05:03 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Yet more unsubstantiated gossip.

Rather than than personality quizzes or barbeque discussions.

What if you combined the two subjects into one thread?

What your BBQ’s say about you…?

(05-14-2025, 05:55 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It worries me when owners want 'attacking play' and seems to prefer that to you know, actual results. CC was our best chance of promotion for the foreseeable, we won't get a coach of that calibre again for a while and we will never have the resources to go all out for a promotion push, it will always be down to luck and the playoffs now.

Our owners apparently not seeing that worries me.

Our of owners appointing TM as manager after looking at some spurious stats worries me just as much.
Reply
#88
(05-14-2025, 05:55 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: It worries me when owners want 'attacking play' and seems to prefer that to you know, actual results. CC was our best chance of promotion for the foreseeable, we won't get a coach of that calibre again for a while and we will never have the resources to go all out for a promotion push, it will always be down to luck and the playoffs now.

Our owners apparently not seeing that worries me.

I think Nestor is the problem rather than the owners. The cluster fuck of appointing 2 lettuces needs a belter of an improved response. Another failure and it will be Nestor with his P45.
Reply
#89
Where is this reported? CC not offered a contract. He extended his contract just the year before?
Reply
#90
For me, there's a hint of truth about the dressing room vibe described here. Don't forget the squad's previous track record - some of them have seen off plenty of managers. As Midge says, the truth is somewhere in between. Mowbray certainly didn't sort it.

As for Patel's gang not having faith in CC, I think the steady fall from top to 7th after a cracking start must have been pivotal. He didn't look like "the only coach that could get us promoted" when we dropped out of the top 6. And he had Josh Maja available every game.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)