Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
https://www.wba.co.uk/news/albion-assemb...april-2025
All seems very pleasant.
Do they leave bits out of the minutes? There's details in there that I knew from reading the Twitter and this dump.
Would be interesting to hear the perspectives of anyone on the Assembly. To me it always feels like the sort of thing that the club feels it should do, and that fans like to feel involved with without actually being able to enact any change or challenge.
Posts: 7,724
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(05-12-2025, 02:21 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: https://www.wba.co.uk/news/albion-assemb...april-2025
All seems very pleasant.
Do they leave bits out of the minutes? There's details in there that I knew from reading the Twitter and this dump.
Would be interesting to hear the perspectives of anyone on the Assembly. To me it always feels like the sort of thing that the club feels it should do, and that fans like to feel involved with without actually being able to enact any change or challenge.
It's summarised aside from the various written statements read out by the club delegates in attendance. So no real detail.
Posts: 1,764
Threads: 45
Joined: Feb 2022
Reputation:
3
It seems to me and I could well be wrong but this assembly leans heavily
Towards more supporting and promoting of the Foundation more than the actual 1st teams matters
Which makes sense really as nobody from the footballing side of the club seems to be involved?
Is there anyone on here who is involved who could perhaps give more detail on
The workings of the Assembly.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
Richbaggie normally attends
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 406
Threads: 15
Joined: Jan 2024
Reputation:
3
Great to read that the club is working on setting up a Fan Advisory Board. I would be keen to understand how this will differ from the work of the Assembly though, as overlap risks competing ideas and inefficiency. The same applies to the talk of an Independent Supporters Trust. I’m all for supporter representation, greater links between fans and the club, holding directors accountable, etc, but I think for these bodies to work best, there needs to be a clear, simple structure.
On the topic of the IST, I’m not a fan of how the A4A Twitter account morphed into an IST one - not sure what others think.
He’s gorra gew, Franksy!
Posts: 7,724
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(05-12-2025, 09:19 PM)Mullers Wrote: Great to read that the club is working on setting up a Fan Advisory Board. I would be keen to understand how this will differ from the work of the Assembly though, as overlap risks competing ideas and inefficiency. The same applies to the talk of an Independent Supporters Trust. I’m all for supporter representation, greater links between fans and the club, holding directors accountable, etc, but I think for these bodies to work best, there needs to be a clear, simple structure.
On the topic of the IST, I’m not a fan of how the A4A Twitter account morphed into an IST one - not sure what others think.
Agree totally ridiculous, I said at the time on SM they should have just dissolved the group and patted themselves on the back for playing a small part in getting the previous owners out of the picture.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(05-12-2025, 09:30 PM)Jacko Wrote: (05-12-2025, 09:19 PM)Mullers Wrote: Great to read that the club is working on setting up a Fan Advisory Board. I would be keen to understand how this will differ from the work of the Assembly though, as overlap risks competing ideas and inefficiency. The same applies to the talk of an Independent Supporters Trust. I’m all for supporter representation, greater links between fans and the club, holding directors accountable, etc, but I think for these bodies to work best, there needs to be a clear, simple structure.
On the topic of the IST, I’m not a fan of how the A4A Twitter account morphed into an IST one - not sure what others think.
Agree totally ridiculous, I said at the time on SM they should have just dissolved the group and patted themselves on the back for playing a small part in getting the previous owners out of the picture.
Similarly, this is why many small shareholders didn't join S4A back in the day.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(05-12-2025, 03:35 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: It seems to me and I could well be wrong but this assembly leans heavily
Towards more supporting and promoting of the Foundation more than the actual 1st teams matters
Which makes sense really as nobody from the footballing side of the club seems to be involved?
Is there anyone on here who is involved who could perhaps give more detail on
The workings of the Assembly.
Hopefully they'd look at the issues raised by Lepko in his recent blog about growing the club
Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
Apologies for not replying sooner, I have been away. I'll try and address everything raised.
I have been part of the Assembly since it's inception, I am also involved with the development of the proposed Independent Supporters Trust and the proposed Fan Advisory Board.
With regards to the minutes. Meetings last roughly 2 hours. The minutes are very much a summary of the discussion areas. The whole transcript would be huge and nobody but the insane or truly bored would read them. I work with the club and I sign off the minutes before they are released. I often push back where I think areas are missed. I would like more meat on the bones sometimes as I know members are passionate in getting points across and that doesn't get portrayed through the minutes. There are also things that simply can't go in the minutes because they are commercially sensitive. We sometimes have to sign NDA's to ensure nothing is leaked prior to official club comms. They shared the early bird pricing proposal back in Feb meeting to judge the response before finalising it all. The AA purpose is that, fan consultation where we feed back. We take concerns that fans have (I often feed in 4 or 5 items that fans reach out to me about via twitter. We aren't there to discuss football matters, that's never been the purpose. Down the years, its mainly focused on ticketing, merchandise and match day experience. There are sub groups set up to drill down into some of these areas. How much influence do we have? Down the years, not enough, especially when Peace was chairman as he didn't give a fuck about the Assembly. To be fair to Gourling, he was present at every meeting and seemed to genuinely listen. Under Patel, engagement feels the most important than it's ever been. We have banged the drum about safe standing, cleaning the bloody stadium, traffic issues and the matchday experience for so long, we are now starting to see inroads albeit the last 2 have a long way to go regards improvements. Much of what Chris Lep mentioned in his piece, has been discussed numerous times.
The club is now looking to add a layer above the AA that I think will help drive much of the improvements fans want to see. The proposed Fan Advisory Board, or Shadow Board, which many medium to big clubs already have, will discuss more strategic and commercially sensitive stuff with the club. There will be representation from the AA on there, a couple of established fan groups (Access All Albion and Proud Baggies) a rep from the proposed IST plus 4 other members who will be chosen after applications are sent in and then interviewed by someone from the FSA, an independent person and someone from the club. They are hoping for some quality applications that can really add value. Other clubs FABs have CEO's of large companies and banks on theirs. The FSA are very much involved in setting this up and I have been in a couple of meetings with Ashley from the FSA who is guiding the club and will be part of the interviews. (as an addition, he attended the AA in feb and he was really complimentary about the discussions that took place that night, he thought the AA was the best fan engagement evenings that he'd been to)
Finally, with regard to the A4A morphing into the IST, I think some context is needed here. The IST hasn't been set up yet. The twitter account was utilised rather than closed down as they have 7k followers and a database that could be tapped into. There are A4A people part of the group looking to launch it, but the current Working Party is made up of about 6, working with the FSA to set it all up. There's a huge amount to do and it's a drain on peoples time but it's important that the club has an independent trust set up. We are one of the few clubs not to have one. We have been having regular meetings with Jayne Hughes from the FSA who is guiding the Working Party looking to get it off the ground. There has been some sniping on social media but the one thing I would say, if the current Working Party weren't putting the effort in, I don't see anyone else doing it and I feel that it's important that there is a fans body, totally independent from the club, set up and functioning well during peacetime rather than wait for a protest one to be launched during more difficult years like A4A felt they needed to do.
I have linked something below that shows how much work is needed to become an affiliated FSA trust member. Hopefully people will support the efforts and come along to meetings and get involved. Much better to do that than throw bricks from afar.
https://thefsa.org.uk/fan-resources/reso...-trust/#C1
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(05-13-2025, 10:13 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Apologies for not replying sooner, I have been away. I'll try and address everything raised.
I have been part of the Assembly since it's inception, I am also involved with the development of the proposed Independent Supporters Trust and the proposed Fan Advisory Board.
With regards to the minutes. Meetings last roughly 2 hours. The minutes are very much a summary of the discussion areas. The whole transcript would be huge and nobody but the insane or truly bored would read them. I work with the club and I sign off the minutes before they are released. I often push back where I think areas are missed. I would like more meat on the bones sometimes as I know members are passionate in getting points across and that doesn't get portrayed through the minutes. There are also things that simply can't go in the minutes because they are commercially sensitive. We sometimes have to sign NDA's to ensure nothing is leaked prior to official club comms. They shared the early bird pricing proposal back in Feb meeting to judge the response before finalising it all. The AA purpose is that, fan consultation where we feed back. We take concerns that fans have (I often feed in 4 or 5 items that fans reach out to me about via twitter. We aren't there to discuss football matters, that's never been the purpose. Down the years, its mainly focused on ticketing, merchandise and match day experience. There are sub groups set up to drill down into some of these areas. How much influence do we have? Down the years, not enough, especially when Peace was chairman as he didn't give a fuck about the Assembly. To be fair to Gourling, he was present at every meeting and seemed to genuinely listen. Under Patel, engagement feels the most important than it's ever been. We have banged the drum about safe standing, cleaning the bloody stadium, traffic issues and the matchday experience for so long, we are now starting to see inroads albeit the last 2 have a long way to go regards improvements. Much of what Chris Lep mentioned in his piece, has been discussed numerous times.
The club is now looking to add a layer above the AA that I think will help drive much of the improvements fans want to see. The proposed Fan Advisory Board, or Shadow Board, which many medium to big clubs already have, will discuss more strategic and commercially sensitive stuff with the club. There will be representation from the AA on there, a couple of established fan groups (Access All Albion and Proud Baggies) a rep from the proposed IST plus 4 other members who will be chosen after applications are sent in and then interviewed by someone from the FSA, an independent person and someone from the club. They are hoping for some quality applications that can really add value. Other clubs FABs have CEO's of large companies and banks on theirs. The FSA are very much involved in setting this up and I have been in a couple of meetings with Ashley from the FSA who is guiding the club and will be part of the interviews. (as an addition, he attended the AA in feb and he was really complimentary about the discussions that took place that night, he thought the AA was the best fan engagement evenings that he'd been to)
Finally, with regard to the A4A morphing into the IST, I think some context is needed here. The IST hasn't been set up yet. The twitter account was utilised rather than closed down as they have 7k followers and a database that could be tapped into. There are A4A people part of the group looking to launch it, but the current Working Party is made up of about 6, working with the FSA to set it all up. There's a huge amount to do and it's a drain on peoples time but it's important that the club has an independent trust set up. We are one of the few clubs not to have one. We have been having regular meetings with Jayne Hughes from the FSA who is guiding the Working Party looking to get it off the ground. There has been some sniping on social media but the one thing I would say, if the current Working Party weren't putting the effort in, I don't see anyone else doing it and I feel that it's important that there is a fans body, totally independent from the club, set up and functioning well during peacetime rather than wait for a protest one to be launched during more difficult years like A4A felt they needed to do.
I have linked something below that shows how much work is needed to become an affiliated FSA trust member. Hopefully people will support the efforts and come along to meetings and get involved. Much better to do that than throw bricks from afar.
https://thefsa.org.uk/fan-resources/reso...-trust/#C1
Great context Rich, thanks for sharing. I'm definitely guilty of throwing bricks from afar, hence my question around the minutes as it all seems very light-touch, bordering on performative. Really good to hear that under the current leadership it feels as valuable as it ever has.
|