Labour = Tory
#51
And I'm not a fully paid up member of the mystified 62% of Lib Dem voters.
Reply
#52
I fully understand what the allure of populism is, it's exploiting the frustrations of the population externalising the blame for problems people conceive. No shit that's popular, you point out that someone you don't like is the root cause of all the ills in the world and say that getting rid of them will fix all the problems you have. It's easy, it's quick, it's dirty and it doesn't take any effort to build an argument.

That's a world away from what the article was suggesting which was to essentially replicate that and feed into it, it was an embarrassing defence of populism which doesn't fix the problems. People are frustrated by immigration levels, something that has skyrocketed due to the things that those same people voted for (Brexit and the Conservatives) and Ed Davey making chocolates in Henley-in-Arden is the problem to blame? Seriously? As I said, if I didn't have to live in this country I'd say let those people touch the stove and learn, but they'll probably keep blaming immigrants and young professionals for their problems anyway like they've been doing despite literally voting for the things causing their grievances.
Reply
#53
The piece just appears to amplify the stories that lead to the ‘we are being ignored’ mindset that Farage and co love to highlight. Praise for a ‘say it as it is MP’ whilst not focussing on what they would actually do is simply trumpeting that populist agenda.
Reply
#54
Absolute Annekin Skywalker vibes.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#55
(05-10-2025, 07:58 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I fully understand what the allure of populism is, it's exploiting the frustrations of the population externalising the blame for problems people conceive. No shit that's popular, you point out that someone you don't like is the root cause of all the ills in the world and say that getting rid of them will fix all the problems you have. It's easy, it's quick, it's dirty and it doesn't take any effort to build an argument.

That's a world away from what the article was suggesting which was to essentially replicate that and feed into it, it was an embarrassing defence of populism which doesn't fix the problems. People are frustrated by immigration levels, something that has skyrocketed due to the things that those same people voted for (Brexit and the Conservatives) and Ed Davey making chocolates in Henley-in-Arden is the problem to blame? Seriously? As I said, if I didn't have to live in this country I'd say let those people touch the stove and learn, but they'll probably keep blaming immigrants and young professionals for their problems anyway like they've been doing despite literally voting for the things causing their grievances.

I don't think that's what the article is saying at all. 

It's also vey surprising to me how solid Reform support is amongst *some* young professionals. When I've asked them about that they've suggested that the system is so stacked against them (and that's a fair point) that smashing it up and seeing what happens is not an outrageous thought for them. Where have we seen that recently?

I'm liking your new "touch the stove" phrase, a bit like your "touch grass" one from late last year - I'm also certain that it must have come from a lanyard ridden conference room.

(05-10-2025, 08:19 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The piece just appears to amplify the stories that lead to the ‘we are being ignored’ mindset that Farage and co love to highlight. Praise for a ‘say it as it is MP’ whilst not focussing on what they would actually do is simply trumpeting that populist agenda.

It doesn't change the fact that they are being ignored. The optics of the latest projections on net migration will completely feed into that narrative.
Reply
#56
Optics again, is that your safe word? Optics only matter if they are being used by snake oil salesmen to get power without any real solution to them. The only optic that matters is reality - we as a country need immigration.
Reply
#57
I read the article, that's exactly what it's saying. It's a defence of populist rhetoric, feed into anger and blame people like Ed Davey for everything because it's the Lib Dems fault that net migration was 900k last year thanks to pressures caused by changes to immigration rules that made it easier for non-EU migrants post-Brexit. It's the exact same crap that Corbyn fed into, that the Gary bloke is feeding into by pretending that a magical wealth tax and upping the highest rate of income tax to 90% will fix everything. But no, you can't call it out because people don't care about fixing problems they just want to smash everything up and the people saying that won't fix everything are the actual problem being part of the establishment/elite/blob/lanyard class/whatever new populist buzzword of the month to describe people you want to blame all the problems on. That's not a solution.

And touch grass is a commonly known slang term to people not over the age of 35, touching the stove is pretty obvious. If you've not heard those two then that's emblematic of you being much closer to the "lanyard class" than you want to admit.
Reply
#58
And optics appear to only work one way - when the optics of Brexit being a total fuckup were being shouted out by many and the reality of that happening comes to pass how do you think we feel being ignored on that subject?

The optics of austerity were awful and have left lasting damage that we are trying too get away from still, I was ignored when that was going on, why didn’t that count in your world?
Reply
#59
(05-10-2025, 11:29 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Optics again, is that your safe word? Optics only matter if they are being used by snake oil salesmen to get power without any real solution to them. The only optic that matters is reality - we as a country need immigration.

Of course. Perhaps the government ought to tell people that then.
Reply
#60
Maybe we wouldn’t be in this mess if the people like yourself who considered Farage and Johnson as ‘useful idiots’ to get their dirty work done would have called them out in the 1st place. The brass balls of the Brexit class to blame politicians such as Davey when they have created the situation is laughable.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)