Labour = Tory
#31
And i don't think anyone could disagree with that, especially as most of us are not in the NHS which I assume you are, but isn't this what the 10 year plan is trying to address? Again, please don't see this as defending Labour as I'm being accused of more and more on here, this is me asking questions that I don't know the answer to.
Reply
#32
(05-09-2025, 11:33 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(05-09-2025, 11:07 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So that’s what they shouldn’t do - what should they do?

A personal opinion:  Healthcare systems management doesn't lend itself to ill thought out whimsical decision making in silos.  We could scream 'sack managers' or 'stop gender reassignment' or 'no surgery for smokers' but the consequences of those decisions are felt elsewhere and, taken in an uncoordinated approach. often result in unintended consequences.  

The examples of uncoordinated, reactionary cuts given in the BBC article have consequences.

If you poorly manage paediatric diabetes you risk increased admissions and early kidney failure in adulthood.
If you stop talking therapies then you probably increase unemployment and physical health problems.
If you reduce the amount of doctors and nurses you restrict access to services full stop.  

There needs to be a programme of work, with academic rigour, which looks at the compounding problems faced, considers options and acknowledges that not everyone will be happy with the solutions offered.  Then there needs to be the political will to see it through.

Talk seriously - invoking cross party talks - about what it takes to sustain a health and social care system for the 21st century.  At the very least, produce an impact assessment, of planned cuts so they know what they have as a baseline.

Rules and principles for engagement would need to be established with constraints being understood upfront.

The following are unavoidable factors:

An ageing population
A reluctance to pay more tax
Increasing expectation from patients and public linked to better education and development of innovative treatment
The increased cost of worklessness
A falling birth rate creating workforce problems in an anti immigration world
Competition at a departmental level for funding 

Shunting the problem to local managers is not going to result in difficult decisions being made well.  The response to these factors are POLITICAL decisions, not healthcare decisions.  

I hold a personal view that a fundamental rethink of what the NHS provides is needed.  I'm saying that the government needs to lead those discussions, as painful as they may be.  Should Streeting be expected to have done that in 12 months?  No.  Should he have said it's needed - 100% yes.

It's not a problem of Labour's doing, but a failure to respond properly to these very well understood factors, will be.

Good post but the bit in bold will never happen as the main political parties will run out of shit to throw at each other. The failing of the health service is really useful ammo when you're in opposition. It's a huge pain in the neck when you're on the hook to fix it.
Reply
#33
(05-09-2025, 11:56 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Good post but the bit in bold will never happen as the main political parties will run out of shit to throw at each other. The failing of the health service is really useful ammo when you're in opposition. It's a huge pain in the neck when you're on the hook to fix it.

Good point Ted and I was going to comment on the ability to do that especially with the new kids on the block.
Reply
#34
(05-09-2025, 11:56 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-09-2025, 11:33 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(05-09-2025, 11:07 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So that’s what they shouldn’t do - what should they do?

A personal opinion:  Healthcare systems management doesn't lend itself to ill thought out whimsical decision making in silos.  We could scream 'sack managers' or 'stop gender reassignment' or 'no surgery for smokers' but the consequences of those decisions are felt elsewhere and, taken in an uncoordinated approach. often result in unintended consequences.  

The examples of uncoordinated, reactionary cuts given in the BBC article have consequences.

If you poorly manage paediatric diabetes you risk increased admissions and early kidney failure in adulthood.
If you stop talking therapies then you probably increase unemployment and physical health problems.
If you reduce the amount of doctors and nurses you restrict access to services full stop.  

There needs to be a programme of work, with academic rigour, which looks at the compounding problems faced, considers options and acknowledges that not everyone will be happy with the solutions offered.  Then there needs to be the political will to see it through.

Talk seriously - invoking cross party talks - about what it takes to sustain a health and social care system for the 21st century.  At the very least, produce an impact assessment, of planned cuts so they know what they have as a baseline.

Rules and principles for engagement would need to be established with constraints being understood upfront.

The following are unavoidable factors:

An ageing population
A reluctance to pay more tax
Increasing expectation from patients and public linked to better education and development of innovative treatment
The increased cost of worklessness
A falling birth rate creating workforce problems in an anti immigration world
Competition at a departmental level for funding 

Shunting the problem to local managers is not going to result in difficult decisions being made well.  The response to these factors are POLITICAL decisions, not healthcare decisions.  

I hold a personal view that a fundamental rethink of what the NHS provides is needed.  I'm saying that the government needs to lead those discussions, as painful as they may be.  Should Streeting be expected to have done that in 12 months?  No.  Should he have said it's needed - 100% yes.

It's not a problem of Labour's doing, but a failure to respond properly to these very well understood factors, will be.

Good post but the bit in bold will never happen as the main political parties will run out of shit to throw at each other. The failing of the health service is really useful ammo when you're in opposition. It's a huge pain in the neck when you're on the hook to fix it.

Nothing is impossible with political will and grown-ups.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#35
(05-09-2025, 12:27 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(05-09-2025, 11:56 AM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-09-2025, 11:33 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(05-09-2025, 11:07 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So that’s what they shouldn’t do - what should they do?

A personal opinion:  Healthcare systems management doesn't lend itself to ill thought out whimsical decision making in silos.  We could scream 'sack managers' or 'stop gender reassignment' or 'no surgery for smokers' but the consequences of those decisions are felt elsewhere and, taken in an uncoordinated approach. often result in unintended consequences.  

The examples of uncoordinated, reactionary cuts given in the BBC article have consequences.

If you poorly manage paediatric diabetes you risk increased admissions and early kidney failure in adulthood.
If you stop talking therapies then you probably increase unemployment and physical health problems.
If you reduce the amount of doctors and nurses you restrict access to services full stop.  

There needs to be a programme of work, with academic rigour, which looks at the compounding problems faced, considers options and acknowledges that not everyone will be happy with the solutions offered.  Then there needs to be the political will to see it through.

Talk seriously - invoking cross party talks - about what it takes to sustain a health and social care system for the 21st century.  At the very least, produce an impact assessment, of planned cuts so they know what they have as a baseline.

Rules and principles for engagement would need to be established with constraints being understood upfront.

The following are unavoidable factors:

An ageing population
A reluctance to pay more tax
Increasing expectation from patients and public linked to better education and development of innovative treatment
The increased cost of worklessness
A falling birth rate creating workforce problems in an anti immigration world
Competition at a departmental level for funding 

Shunting the problem to local managers is not going to result in difficult decisions being made well.  The response to these factors are POLITICAL decisions, not healthcare decisions.  

I hold a personal view that a fundamental rethink of what the NHS provides is needed.  I'm saying that the government needs to lead those discussions, as painful as they may be.  Should Streeting be expected to have done that in 12 months?  No.  Should he have said it's needed - 100% yes.

It's not a problem of Labour's doing, but a failure to respond properly to these very well understood factors, will be.

Good post but the bit in bold will never happen as the main political parties will run out of shit to throw at each other. The failing of the health service is really useful ammo when you're in opposition. It's a huge pain in the neck when you're on the hook to fix it.

Nothing is impossible with political will and grown-ups.

Agreed, however the grown-ups are few and far between and I'm not sure the political will has ever been there.
Reply
#36
Nigel will solve it

He will introduce an insurance based system.

The gammons with their high blood pressure and dodgy prostates will get what they want. And pay for it themselves.
Reply
#37
(05-09-2025, 11:55 AM)baggy1 Wrote: And i don't think anyone could disagree with that, especially as most of us are not in the NHS which I assume you are, but isn't this what the 10 year plan is trying to address? Again, please don't see this as defending Labour as I'm being accused of more and more on here, this is me asking questions that I don't know the answer to.

Nobody appears to know what's in the 10 year plan (it's late, so it's now a 9.5 year plan) including the leaders of ICBs who wrote a 'blueprint' for their future (published this week) whilst simultaneously stating that they will need to revise it when the 10YP is published.

It will almost certainly point to, as current planning guidance does to 3 main shifts:

From treatment to prevention (noting that the NHS has a limited role in determining population health - that is led by factors outside of the NHS such as employment, nutrition, social inclusion, primary mental health, environment etc).  Note, prevention - in most medical conditions except maternity - takes years or decades to realise benefits so a degree of double running costs are unavoidable.  

Hospital to community (if only the last Labour government hadn't built loads of hospitals on 40 year mortgages and if only the last Tory government hadn't allowed the decimation of primary and community care)

Analogue to Digital.  

None of those things are "wrong" to do but it won't address the fundamentals I highlighted earlier - demand outstripping resources - and the crumbling social care system (that is reliant on the people Dekka is trying to stand up for).

If it points to rationing/reprioritisation, funding models, an aligned Social Care strategy (the 10YP will only be health) then I'll eat my hat.  Successive governments haven't done that.  I wouldn't trust the Tories to do it fairly so Labour need to step and deliver it, preferably in the spirit of the great Keir (not v2.0) when he created the NHS.  

Something more drastic is needed and we need grown ups to deliver it.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#38
(05-09-2025, 01:31 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: From treatment to prevention (noting that the NHS has a limited role in determining population health - that is led by factors outside of the NHS such as employment, nutrition, social inclusion, primary mental health, environment etc).  Note, prevention - in most medical conditions except maternity - takes years or decades to realise benefits so a degree of double running costs are unavoidable.  

Hospital to community (if only the last Labour government hadn't built loads of hospitals on 40 year mortgages and if only the last Tory government hadn't allowed the decimation of primary and community care)

Analogue to Digital.  

It's pretty shambolic if we've reached 2025 and those are the three things that would transform the NHS - without going full Proth, any other business would have ceased to function years ago if it was so poorly ran. Still, here we are. Let's see what the grown-ups can cook up.
Reply
#39
(05-09-2025, 02:18 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(05-09-2025, 01:31 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: From treatment to prevention (noting that the NHS has a limited role in determining population health - that is led by factors outside of the NHS such as employment, nutrition, social inclusion, primary mental health, environment etc).  Note, prevention - in most medical conditions except maternity - takes years or decades to realise benefits so a degree of double running costs are unavoidable.  

Hospital to community (if only the last Labour government hadn't built loads of hospitals on 40 year mortgages and if only the last Tory government hadn't allowed the decimation of primary and community care)

Analogue to Digital.  

It's pretty shambolic if we've reached 2025 and those are the three things that would transform the NHS - without going full Proth, any other business would have ceased to function years ago if it was so poorly ran. Still, here we are. Let's see what the grown-ups can cook up.

As I said, prevention - in the primary sense - isn't the NHS's bag. They don't create jobs, fix your diet,stop you from drinking 8 pints every night... I don't think it's well positioned to do that.

If it had been, however, a combination of the 2 matters below - both central government policy under Blair - has meant that secondary care providers have been DISINCENTIVIZED to avoid demand.

1. A payment system ("payment by results") which rewards a hospital if it sees more patients.
2. A Foundation Trust/PFI model which has meant that income generation has been a necessity in order to keep the lights on.

Whilst you're quite right to point out that it's ridiculous it's worth remembering that the NHS wears 3 hats in this instance but is constrained by the model dictated by politicians:

1. It provides services
2. It pays another part of itself to provide those services but not to reduce demand and if it doesn't manage to pay enough the PFI agreement breaches
3. It is the enforcement arm of the government to make it all work.

That's not a carte blanche defence of it all - but they're hugely important factors.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#40
(05-09-2025, 12:27 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: Nothing is impossible with political will and grown-ups.

Pity we have neither in Parliament on so many fundamental issues.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: