Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(05-07-2025, 07:25 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: The offside rule as it is, is fine.
The problem lies with the application of VAR and the definition of a 'clear and obvious error'
Exactly.
Offside is an arbitrary decision, you’re either off or you’re not. There’s no need to change it, just enforce it better.
I know it’s overly simplistic, but if you can’t get the decision right with one reply on VAR it’s not clear and obvious so play on.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
05-07-2025, 07:43 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-07-2025, 07:43 PM by Ted Maul.)
(05-07-2025, 07:40 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-07-2025, 07:25 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: The offside rule as it is, is fine.
The problem lies with the application of VAR and the definition of a 'clear and obvious error'
Exactly.
Offside is an arbitrary decision, you’re either off or you’re not. There’s no need to change it, just enforce it better.
I know it’s overly simplistic, but if you can’t get the decision right with one reply on VAR it’s not clear and obvious so play on.
Bingo. By definition if you have to review it for five minutes it is neither clear, nor obvious.
Posts: 9,633
Threads: 518
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(05-07-2025, 07:43 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-07-2025, 07:40 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-07-2025, 07:25 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: The offside rule as it is, is fine.
The problem lies with the application of VAR and the definition of a 'clear and obvious error'
Exactly.
Offside is an arbitrary decision, you’re either off or you’re not. There’s no need to change it, just enforce it better.
I know it’s overly simplistic, but if you can’t get the decision right with one reply on VAR it’s not clear and obvious so play on.
Bingo. By definition if you have to review it for five minutes it is neither clear, nor obvious.
I agree, kind of, it means linos would need to start giving decisions again in real time though so we have accept that VAR would only ever be used to disallow goals.
Not sure that's what we all want. They just need to find a way of calibrating and setting the tolerance so that the attacking team has more advantage.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
They'll just measure to the mm to determine if there's daylight between the players.
I don't agree that the offside rule is fine, though. I don't like this rule where you can pass to someone who is offside and if they leave it then an on running player can be deemed to be onside, or it forces a defender to attempt to clear the ball. I know there's been some rule change around deliberately playing the ball but it's very vague.
I'd much prefer if you're in an offside position then it's a free kick regardless of whether the ball reached the player or not, or even if it was played to a different player. If you're on the pitch you're interfering with play. Get back onside you lazy buggers! ANd stop all this is he/isn't he interfering with play or in the keepers eye-line etc.
The offside trap is a thing of beauty if worked properly, as is breaking it!
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 7,870
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
Never mind that, the lino not flagging until a player actually gets to the ball wastes monumental amounts of time.
In the form of his life.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(05-07-2025, 07:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (05-07-2025, 07:43 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-07-2025, 07:40 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-07-2025, 07:25 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: The offside rule as it is, is fine.
The problem lies with the application of VAR and the definition of a 'clear and obvious error'
Exactly.
Offside is an arbitrary decision, you’re either off or you’re not. There’s no need to change it, just enforce it better.
I know it’s overly simplistic, but if you can’t get the decision right with one reply on VAR it’s not clear and obvious so play on.
Bingo. By definition if you have to review it for five minutes it is neither clear, nor obvious.
I agree, kind of, it means linos would need to start giving decisions again in real time though so we have accept that VAR would only ever be used to disallow goals.
Not sure that's what we all want. They just need to find a way of calibrating and setting the tolerance so that the attacking team has more advantage.
What does the A in VAR stand for?
At the moment we've created a system where referees are almost redundant, they don't make a decision knowing that VAR with review for them. Power and onus still needs to be on the referees to make the initial decisions and then VAR can advise of a clear and obvious error.
I wouldn't be against a challenge system, where each team is allowed three per 90 minutes. Would stop players appealing for everything, and would really zero in on the proper howlers as it has in cricket.
Posts: 9,633
Threads: 518
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(05-07-2025, 07:57 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-07-2025, 07:48 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (05-07-2025, 07:43 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (05-07-2025, 07:40 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (05-07-2025, 07:25 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: The offside rule as it is, is fine.
The problem lies with the application of VAR and the definition of a 'clear and obvious error'
Exactly.
Offside is an arbitrary decision, you’re either off or you’re not. There’s no need to change it, just enforce it better.
I know it’s overly simplistic, but if you can’t get the decision right with one reply on VAR it’s not clear and obvious so play on.
Bingo. By definition if you have to review it for five minutes it is neither clear, nor obvious.
I agree, kind of, it means linos would need to start giving decisions again in real time though so we have accept that VAR would only ever be used to disallow goals.
Not sure that's what we all want. They just need to find a way of calibrating and setting the tolerance so that the attacking team has more advantage.
What does the A in VAR stand for? 
At the moment we've created a system where referees are almost redundant, they don't make a decision knowing that VAR with review for them. Power and onus still needs to be on the referees to make the initial decisions and then VAR can advise of a clear and obvious error.
I wouldn't be against a challenge system, where each team is allowed three per 90 minutes. Would stop players appealing for everything, and would really zero in on the proper howlers as it has in cricket.
Now we're talking.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 8,006
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
3 people independently making a yes or no decision within 30 seconds. Majority wins, job done.
Posts: 7,870
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
13
(05-07-2025, 08:19 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: 3 people independently making a yes or no decision within 30 seconds. Majority wins, job done.
You just know they’d all be Villa fans if it involved us.
In the form of his life.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(05-07-2025, 08:23 PM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: (05-07-2025, 08:19 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: 3 people independently making a yes or no decision within 30 seconds. Majority wins, job done.
You just know they’d all be Villa fans if it involved us.
They could give it to some of the 48,000 Blues fans on the ST waiting list to pass the time.
|