Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
You do know as do I, there's significantly greater demand in one direction than the other. There's a reason India has been pushing for this and not us, there is a reason that this exact issue has stalled the EU FTA on this exact point for 18 years.
And if there was no cost benefit they'd not be pushing for this. Again, the incentive is to make it cheaper to hire Indian workers over any other nationality to do the same job
You've spent months on here blindly defending everything this government has done, to the point you're now trying to argue that this incentives for a temporary worker agreement with India are the same as with developed nations in spite of the huge discrepancy in push-and-pull factors and trying to ignore the point that our government has agreed to this while failing to secure the same level of access to the Indian market as Liechtenstein and Iceland.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
For clarity we disagree on a point in the document that isn't clear. You believe that it applies to all companies who can bring in as many employees as they want on a three year rotation because they are cheaper. I believe that it only applies to Inter company transfers in general with the rest limited by the number of Visa's allowed by each country.
We disagree on a point - no need to get personal.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
No, you are trying to underplay the issue that this brings in based on the incentive it offers one side over the other (hence why the Indian government pushed for it) while ignoring the problem that we've accepted it for worse trade access to the Indian markets than what EFTA members have.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Fair enough, like I say we disagree on a point that isn't clear in a document that hasn't been clarified or ratified. You feel the need to get personal over this, so be it.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
Because you are still refusing to even acknowledge the point about the India-EFTA agreement, your only mention of it was in dismissal of it when it's directly relevant to the scope of the deal. Why would you be trying to ignore that notably salient point unless you were trying to defend what the government signed? I'd care less about this if we were getting good access to the Indian markets in return but we're not even getting what other smaller European countries have, let alone comprehensive free trade with India.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
We're not in EFTA and even if I did acknowledge it doesn't mean you need to get personal. EFTA have different products and services to offer so the deal will be weighted differently, India can be more generous with them knowing it is a much smaller deal both ways. The deal will benefit UK companies and jobs such as with JLR who are struggling to find markets at the moment, China has collapsed, US is untouchable so India will help. The drinks industry benefit and tariffs on the whole, especially for our access to government contracts in India.
You've had plenty of opportunity to recognise that you don't know everything here, as I have done. You've also had opportunity to step back from the insulting language - I accept it from some on here because I'll give it back, I don't recall having a bad word with you in the past so I don't accept it in the circumstances of this debate.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
I'm directly comparing the access to the Indian market we have under this deal as compared with what the EFTA has as a baseline, it's entirely prescient to whether the arrangements we have are good or not and you have continually ignored it despite me continually bringing it up.
I know full well the benefits of free trade, I'm a liberal and support free trade. What I don't want is for the UK to give concessions on a major point of contention without even recieving an equivalent tariff line arrangement as a bloc that didn't concede on that. If we'd had an equivalent tariff line as EFTA has then those benefits from trade would be amplified. There's been big issues with ECTA already in the imbalance of benefits and even that has fewer export barriers than what we will have (85% for us over 10 years, 85% for Australia already and 90% over 6 years). Even factoring in improvements in India's FTA utilisation as it develops that's not a good trade off, even the minister responsible's best defence is Chile which is incredible given we have nowhere near the comparable immigration pull with Chile as we do with India.
And I'm getting really annoyed with people steadfastly defending government policy with selective arguments, you've been doing this on here by ignoring the point about EFTA when that's the thing I've repeatedly said, even quoted in your first response in this thread. It's a huge point of contention over whether we've got an equitable or one-sided FTA with India.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Fair enough - and you need to realise that if you feel that disagreeing with you is seen as 'defending government policy with selective arguments' that isn't always the way its intended so your personal insult, when we don't tend to have that normal protocol, is out of order. By now I would have expected you to have stepped back from it but you just find reason to excuse yourself for it. That in itself speaks volumes to me.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
05-07-2025, 02:25 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-07-2025, 02:49 PM by Protheroe.)
And as the OP of the thread implies, the optics of a guy who's never had a job outside politics telling people not to worry about the rotation of Indian workers into this country on a three year cycle are simply awful.