Indian Trade Deal
#21
No NICs obligations, employer and employee
Reply
#22
For who BB, I don’t believe you are being deliberately vague here but are you saying that any company can hire an Indian worker at a cheaper rate?
Reply
#23
Anyone hiring an Indian worker on a 3-year rotation, then you can just cycle them in and out.
Reply
#24
I’m under the impression that this just relates to inter-company only
Reply
#25
Not according to the text, and the Home Office wasn't consulted so haven't done an impact assessment.
Reply
#26
Have a read of 5.DCC and the legal text needs to be finalised Btw

The DCC will support business and trade by ensuring that employees moving between UK and India, and their employers, will only be liable to pay social security contributions in one country at a time.

I’m looking for the quote but Reynolds stated that it was for inter-company transfers.

“We have 17 of these agreements with the EU, with South Korea, with the US and a whole range of partners, and what it is about is making sure when people are inter-company transfers between the UK and India … they don’t simultaneously pay into both social security systems”
Reply
#27
The inference of it being linked to intra-company transfers is contradicted by the Indian government, and those agreements are with developed nations not a developing nation that actively wants to export workers because it's reliant on remittance to cover domestic spending obligations.

We've seen this exact issue with Australia, the EFTA countries didn't have it as a condition of their agreement and they also have a greater tariff-free scope with India than we do under this.
Reply
#28
It won’t exempt anyone from paying social security, it just changes where they pay it to. And it works both ways. This is a direct incentive to get Indian companies to set up in the UK and have their own management team set the operations up. It’s a model repeated many times by different companies. The best current example would be TATA from India itself.

And we aren’t part of EFTA and not likely to be for the foreseeable future.
Reply
#29
How many British workers are going to move under this agreement to India compared to the other way? As I said, the incentives are very different to other arrangements.

And you've literally spelled out the issue right there in black and white, it's an incentive for Indian companies to employ Indian workers as they will be cheaper under 3-year rotations compared with every other nationality and reduce the amount of tax paid to the Exchequer as a result. Not to mention consultancies like Accenture.

And I brought up the EFTA because fucking Liechtenstein has a more comprehensive trade agreement with India than we do without this nonsense. How have we managed to get a worse agreement with India than four small European countries considering the greater leverage we have?

Get Starmer's dick out of your mouth, they've had our pants down.
Reply
#30
I don't know and neither do you - I've worked for at least two companies that have sent management over to India to help with setting up production or managing a function.

Your understanding of secondees being transferred over ignore the costs involved including housing, schools for kids, movement costs etc far outweigh the benefits of getting them at a cheaper rate. And you use Accenture or Wipro are already here using Indian nationals remotely or on short term contracts, they don't need to be settling them for a three year rotation.

And Fuck off with the last line - I think it's time to take a break from this site.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: