Bartley
#41
(05-03-2025, 10:50 PM)Everything Zin Wrote: For the first goal he was left exposed against a fast, tricky winger - he was always going to struggle. When he went off and Luton started pumping balls into the box, we missed him.

I disagree.  A player of his experience should at least be able to show the attacker one way or the other and be prepared to get a foot on the ball.  He did neither. He was too far away and given that he wasn't going to get anywhere near from that distance, he might as well have committed himself one way or the other and at least have tried to get a tackle in.  He effectively just stood and watched.  It's not the first time.  He did it a few games ago ( Sunderland?) and a similar cock up vs Blues some time ago was abysmal defending.  I agree re the lack of back up but that makes it even more imperative that you do something.
Reply
#42
Do we always have to have a scapegoat?
Reply
#43
(05-04-2025, 10:33 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: Do we always have to have a scapegoat?

He's not being scapegoated. He's being held to account for another poor display, for pointing fingers instead of showing leadership, and his general attitude.
"I'm not a nerd Bart. Nerds are smart"
Reply
#44
(05-04-2025, 08:57 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(05-04-2025, 07:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: Not defending Bartley's attempt at jockeying but Furlong dropped us right in the shit for their first goal.

Sorry Jacko can’t agree, Furlong was doing what he was supposed to do when Diakate got the ball inside him, attack down the right, he wasn’t to know Diakate would lose the ball totally exposing the right side.
As good as Diakate played yesterday it was his miss control that exposed the breakaway and Bartley’s lack of pace or Jockeying that allowed the winger to cut inside.

Correct
Reply
#45
(05-04-2025, 06:02 PM)excitedbaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2025, 08:57 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(05-04-2025, 07:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: Not defending Bartley's attempt at jockeying but Furlong dropped us right in the shit for their first goal.

Sorry Jacko can’t agree, Furlong was doing what he was supposed to do when Diakate got the ball inside him, attack down the right, he wasn’t to know Diakate would lose the ball totally exposing the right side.
As good as Diakate played yesterday it was his miss control that exposed the breakaway and Bartley’s lack of pace or Jockeying that allowed the winger to cut inside.

Correct

Diakite's role in this goal goes unremarkable because he is generally popular with the fans .....so we notice his good play and overlook his mistakes.

Bartley on the other hand is coming information criticism, so we analyse his role in any goal conceded to see if we can attribute some responsibility for it.

Diakite lost possession in the middle of the pitch leaving us exposed to a counter attack. That's what happened.
Reply
#46
I'm finding this thread a bit strange. We're discussing a player who:
  • is 34 years old
  • has an ongoing knee problem
  • has missed many matches in recent seasons due to injury and occasional suspension
  • is known for his tendency to switch off at key moments
  • has been through phases many times in his career where his form has been dreadful
He made a colossal and unacceptable error for Luton's first goal, put in a difficult one-on-one situation but did nothing to help his goalkeeper. He was skinned for pace several times - AJ commented "Bartley's got to get closer on his man" more than once. Why are people pretending there's nothing to see here? Reading that he's "our best central defender" is incredible.

No spacegoating from me, he's been a good club servant despite his limitations - but if he plays more than a handful of matches next season we're in trouble. I hope the recruitment team can see that we need significant upgrades on Bartley and Holgate, as well as Taylor back in the squad.
Reply
#47
(05-05-2025, 07:00 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Diakite's role in this goal goes unremarkable because he is generally popular with the fans .....so we notice his good play and overlook his mistakes.

Bartley on the other hand is coming information criticism, so we analyse his role in any goal conceded to see if we can attribute some responsibility for it.

Diakite lost possession in the middle of the pitch leaving us exposed to a counter attack. That's what happened.

Exactly this Shabby. It was down to Diakite who was caught in possession, allowing them to catch us out of shape. Yes Bartley did fail to make a desicive move to the attacker, but if he dives in, and he takes it past him, then it's a free run on goal, or if he makes contact, he's sent off.
Reply
#48
(05-05-2025, 07:00 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(05-04-2025, 06:02 PM)excitedbaggie Wrote:
(05-04-2025, 08:57 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(05-04-2025, 07:56 AM)Jacko Wrote: Not defending Bartley's attempt at jockeying but Furlong dropped us right in the shit for their first goal.

Sorry Jacko can’t agree, Furlong was doing what he was supposed to do when Diakate got the ball inside him, attack down the right, he wasn’t to know Diakate would lose the ball totally exposing the right side.
As good as Diakate played yesterday it was his miss control that exposed the breakaway and Bartley’s lack of pace or Jockeying that allowed the winger to cut inside.

Correct

Diakite's role in this goal goes unremarkable because he is generally popular with the fans .....so we notice his good play and overlook his mistakes.

Bartley on the other hand is coming information criticism, so we analyse his role in any goal conceded to see if we can attribute some responsibility for it.

Diakite lost possession in the middle of the pitch leaving us exposed to a counter attack. That's what happened.

For me Furlong fired a poor ball to a player obviously marked then bombed 20 yards past him without checking all was well with his (shit) pass. He was on the halfway line when the ball hit the net.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)