Poll: Who do we sell?
You do not have permission to vote in this poll.
Fellows (£15M)
60.00%
36 60.00%
Maja (£7-10M)
25.00%
15 25.00%
Griffith (£10M)
13.33%
8 13.33%
Price (£15M)
1.67%
1 1.67%
Total 60 vote(s) 100%
* You voted for this item. [Show Results]

So, who do we sell to fund the rebuild?
#31
(05-03-2025, 08:32 PM)Russbaggie03 Wrote: We will agree to disagree re price and his potential price. I think he would have carried us further if he was top 4 prem potential. 
Hope he does kick on and continue to develop and be part of a strong footballing team next season of course.

Hard to carry us anywhere under Mowbray who invariably had him everywhere but his best position.

Time will tell - he’s a very very talented player
Reply
#32
I know this is just a speculative thread as we have no head coach and no pattern of play as yet but find it hard to see any positives from selling the only players that get us excited. Price, first half yesterday, did a little drag back, turn and first time pass that had us drooling. We pay money to see players that do the stuff we ourselves never could. In my lifetime watching Albion I can barely remember a time when selling our best players has paid off. Far better to attempt what blues have done, increase revenue.
Reply
#33
(05-04-2025, 08:59 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I know this is just a speculative thread as we have no head coach and no pattern of play as yet but find it hard to see any positives from selling the only players that get us excited. Price, first half yesterday, did a little drag back, turn and first time pass that had us drooling. We pay money to see players that do the stuff we ourselves never could. In my lifetime watching Albion I can barely remember a time when selling our best players has paid off. Far better to attempt what blues have done, increase revenue.

Exactly, I’ve been saying this for at least a year. It’s not a sustainable business model that will deliver success on the pitch. We are still in the JP mindset where we keep things small and don’t invest outside the playing staff, it wont work long term if we are trying to compete with all of our neighbouring WM teams let alone the rest of the country.
Reply
#34
(05-04-2025, 08:59 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I know this is just a speculative thread as we have no head coach and no pattern of play as yet but find it hard to see any positives from selling the only players that get us excited. Price, first half yesterday, did a little drag back, turn and first time pass that had us drooling. We pay money to see players that do the stuff we ourselves never could. In my lifetime watching Albion I can barely remember a time when selling our best players has paid off. Far better to attempt what blues have done, increase revenue.

It’s a good point. Is it “easier” for Blues to increase revenue or have we been slack in that regard?

I’d say mainly the former but bit of both
Reply
#35
(05-03-2025, 04:11 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Whilst the return of the loans and the expiry of some very hefty contracts will surely help our financial situation, we are going to have to make one big, profit turning sale this summer.

I’d hope we may be able to move Wallace, Cole and Frabotta out to free up some wages, but we will still need to make a decent sale.

So who will it be? I think we will see 3-4 players attracting attention.

We should get 15/20 quid for Captain Fantastic Kyle
Reply
#36
Increasing revenue is one thing. Selling players when their value is highest is another. We need to do both in order to compete.

Too much of the former and we end up with a squad of players who've been here a decade and achieved nothing (sound familiar), too much of the latter and we never had a squad together long enough to mount a challenge at any level.
Reply
#37
(05-04-2025, 06:25 AM)Mullers Wrote: Sadly, I can’t see us increasing Fellows’ value beyond what it is now (likely £15m-£20m plus a decent sell on clause). So I would like to see us realise that profit this summer.

I don’t think we have maximised Griffiths’ and Price’s value - Griffiths because he has simply not had a full season of being our No.1, and Price because he has only had half a season with us. We need to keep them for the spine of our starting 11 next season (along with Heggem, Diakite and Dike, if we can keep the latter two fit).

Maja is an interesting one - it was a good bit of business picking him up on a free, but again he has not had a full, consistent season for us because of his unfortunate injuries. Still, he is 26 - an age where a forward’s value can plateau, so there is a decision to be made if an offer comes in.

I can see Fellows value increasing if he gets regular starts under a good coach, particularly if he starts adding goals to his game.  I’d keep him with a potential sale in an inflated January market.

There’s no way we’d get £5m for Griffith never mind £10m, so I’d keep him.  Maja won’t command a big fee due to his recent injury and we desperately need the 10 that Price is.  So I’d keep them all and make do as best we can til January.
Reply
#38
I don't think we actually get that much for Fellows. I think it'll be £10-12m guaranteed, with any extra based on appearances, goals, club success, international recognition, etc.

I'd much rather sell Maja, given his injury plagued two years, but I don't think we get that much for him, and he'll probably try to run down his contract rather than take the move (unless it's a really good move).

Griffiths displays mean we wouldn't get a lot for him. Plenty of potential, but there's still a lot of development to do. I would imagine it'll be another year or two before we're able to get a good fee for him, as long as he keeps developing.
"I'm not a nerd Bart. Nerds are smart"
Reply
#39
(05-04-2025, 09:08 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-04-2025, 08:59 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I know this is just a speculative thread as we have no head coach and no pattern of play as yet but find it hard to see any positives from selling the only players that get us excited. Price, first half yesterday, did a little drag back, turn and first time pass that had us drooling. We pay money to see players that do the stuff we ourselves never could. In my lifetime watching Albion I can barely remember a time when selling our best players has paid off. Far better to attempt what blues have done, increase revenue.

Exactly, I’ve been saying this for at least a year. It’s not a sustainable business model that will deliver success on the pitch. We are still in the JP mindset where we keep things small and don’t invest outside the playing staff, it wont work long term if we are trying to compete with all of our neighbouring WM teams let alone the rest of the country.
I agree Dekka, hopefully this is a short term solution to get round the immediate FFP issues to enable us to compete in the window this summer.

Longer term I think we need to hear a bit from the owners about their plans to give the place a bit of a lift after a disappointing season.  How are they going to move us forward?  What is the plan to raise revenue as opposed to just trying to be smarter with what we’ve got?

If the plan is to just buy and sell better then it’s not going to take us very far.  Everyone is trying to unearth the gems, we need to know about ground capacity and what the club are doing to generate more day to day revenues.  They don’t need to gob-off like the chavvy Blues lot but just give the fans some kind of vision and sense of ambition.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#40
Keep it simple.

Sell (Nominal fee) or give away Wallace - save on wages. 

Sell (Nominal fee) or give away Bartley - save on wages.

Sell Fellows.  Get £10m in the bank immediately and add another £5m in realistic add-ons, plus that all important 20% of any profit made on future sale above £10m.  Similar to O’Shea sell-on % fee. 

Look for £300k - £1.5m gems. Plenty out there. 
Develop the likes of Taylor, Whitwell & Co. 

Commit to Josh Griffiths as no.1 - he will be a real asset in 2/3 yrs time and then we SELL! In comes Cisse…similar drill.

Maja and Dike. Get them super fit and hit the ground running Aug to Dec.  If big money comes in for Maja that means a huge profit for us on him we SELL and re-invest in the next one! 

Better decision making all round. 
Onwards and upwards.
A strategic plan must be in place. Signs of it already with Price signing and sale of Asante and yes, wait for it, Palmer! 
More of the same please.

That’s the playing side. 

Wide developments must be match-day experience, commercial revenue, stadium.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: