Local elections
#91
(05-02-2025, 09:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-02-2025, 08:12 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-02-2025, 08:00 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-02-2025, 07:47 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: If you think it’s because they haven’t pulled miracles out of their arses in 9 months, you may be right. They were never going to.

This - Dekka is spouting the same line that reform are in that everything is shit and change must come. What he doesn’t realise is that he is championing them with his impatience.

WFA - lots of noise, no impact
IHT for farmers - lots of noise, no impact

VAT on private schools - lots of noise, no impact
PIP reform - lots of noise, let’s see shall we. There seems to be a pattern.

Meanwhile, NHS waiting lists down, minimum wage up, GP numbers up etc etc

You are really, really wrong on those two.

IHT will take time to filter through so let’s see shall we, or maybe explain why farmers should get preferential treatment to all other business owners.

WFA - you’ll have to explain where the big losers were with that one. The stories of pensioners freezing in their beds was a bit over the top IMO

I've put my opinion out there already, I don't care about the former (don't particularly think IHT is a good tax and want it replaced with an LVT which is a much better wealth tax, but if it exists then it should apply to agricultural land) and the latter I think is sensible given the triple lock and the drop in energy prices since 2022. So this isn't about my opinion on policy, it's about Labour's awful comms strategy - or lack of one. 

Labour have absolutely fucked up their message over those two policies and a lot of people who held up the vote in the "red wall" - agricultural areas and old people - are pissed. Not only has it come up on the doorstep unprompted in a Labour-Lib Dem marginal ward that the Lib Dems gained today but there's multiple polling focus groups where they both keep coming up, especially the WFA cut. The optics around it are awful, they're very easy to attack, they effect motivated voters who will turn out and it's stuck in people's heads. It's worse than the Lib Dems during the coalition so far and the Lib Dems during the coalition had zero media strategy.
Reply
#92
“Stop the clock” arf indeed. Stop being a closet full of cliches Dekka - do something about it. You turned your nose up at real change and now blame everyone else for the situation we’re in.
Reply
#93
(05-02-2025, 09:49 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Arf stop the clock… I knew somehow it would be the fault of those sticking up for the disabled and pointing out Labour are punching down. You keep telling yourselves that. At least off the record at least some of your party acknowledge things aren’t well very Labour 

Context

Things cannot be "very Labour" for the simple reason that there is no money to spend. And there will be even less money to spend for the remaining years of this government.

If you think things are shit now, just you wait. Tradesmen asking nicely for cash is a sign, as are tradesmen downing tools when they reach a certain income, as are professionals going down to a three day week to remain below punitive income thresholds. 

You cannot be "very Labour" when you simply can't raise any more money. We are at that stage where everyone sentient will seek to avoid tax where possible and recognises a disincetive when they see one. Until the government does a single thing to incentivise risk and growth we are truly fucked.
Reply
#94
(05-02-2025, 07:47 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’m not sure we’ve ever discussed what underpinned their election success Derek so it’s odd to begin by telling me what I think it was founded on. I agree it’s built on sand, as will anyone that governs a society where the number of people voting for more than. 2 parties has moved from 4% to over half in fifty odd years

If you think it’s because they haven’t pulled miracles out of their arses in 9 months, you may be right. They were never going to.

Fully costed, fully funded. Right. Pensions and ISA's are the next gouge at the budget.

Starmer lied to the electorate when he didn't need to.

The results show Libs taking middle England and Reform taking the rest.

Uniparty is finished. Will the others be better? I'd like to see the Libs coming forward, but both Lanour and Tories are finished for years in the eyes of the voters.

 The results make that very clear.
Reply
#95
With pension savings now subject to IHT he’s rendered them univestable for anyone approaching the IHT limit. I can’t think of a more damaging disincentive than to suggest the state could take 40% of your retirement savings.
Reply
#96
(05-03-2025, 03:27 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-02-2025, 07:47 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’m not sure we’ve ever discussed what underpinned their election success Derek so it’s odd to begin by telling me what I think it was founded on. I agree it’s built on sand, as will anyone that governs a society where the number of people voting for more than. 2 parties has moved from 4% to over half in fifty odd years

If you think it’s because they haven’t pulled miracles out of their arses in 9 months, you may be right. They were never going to.

Fully costed, fully funded. Right. Pensions and ISA's are the next gouge at the budget.

Starmer lied to the electorate when he didn't need to.

The results show Libs taking middle England and Reform taking the rest.

Uniparty is finished. Will the others be better? I'd like to see the Libs coming forward, but both Lanour and Tories are finished for years in the eyes of the voters.

 The results make that very clear.

Yes because local election results four years ahead of an election are always used as an accurate barometer of the next governing party aren’t they? Do you ever consider thinking before you type?
Reply
#97
(05-02-2025, 09:57 PM)baggy1 Wrote: “Stop the clock” arf indeed. Stop being a closet full of cliches Dekka - do something about it. You turned your nose up at real change and now blame everyone else for the situation we’re in.

My politics haven’t changed I’m still centre/centre left, perhaps admit that the Labour party has drifted to the right in the pursuit of voters it will never convince to vote for them, whilst abandoning those that would if they didn’t feel betrayed and vilified by them. 

I wasn’t a big fan of Corbyn, because he came with too much baggage that meant he didn’t win two elections, but I still voted Labour because they hadn’t abandoned the most vulnerable or used divisive  language about ‘working people’ and everyone else. 

I’m not a party political person, I have voted Lib Dem as well as Labour previously, I’m not exactly sure what you think I can do about the folly that is the governments right of centre political direction.
Reply
#98
(05-02-2025, 09:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: You are holding it open for them trumpeting their success as well.

(05-02-2025, 08:12 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(05-02-2025, 08:00 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-02-2025, 07:47 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: If you think it’s because they haven’t pulled miracles out of their arses in 9 months, you may be right. They were never going to.

This - Dekka is spouting the same line that reform are in that everything is shit and change must come. What he doesn’t realise is that he is championing them with his impatience.

WFA - lots of noise, no impact
IHT for farmers - lots of noise, no impact

VAT on private schools - lots of noise, no impact
PIP reform - lots of noise, let’s see shall we. There seems to be a pattern.

Meanwhile, NHS waiting lists down, minimum wage up, GP numbers up etc etc

You are really, really wrong on those two.

IHT will take time to filter through so let’s see shall we, or maybe explain why farmers should get preferential treatment to all other business owners.

WFA - you’ll have to explain where the big losers were with that one. The stories of pensioners freezing in their beds was a bit over the top IMO

FWIW, Private Eye reporting this week that the NFA will quietly pivot away from their IHT campaign as it hasn't been popular with the public and the likes of Clarkson have harmed their cause.

Reform winning councils reminds me of the BNP doing similarly and then proving to be similarly inept.

Generally, I agree with Ted Maul's post about the right governing on easy mode. We live in a society where we can't have sensible conversations about social care, immigration, the general budget without media and social media screeching and so we end having stupid conversations and people voting for stupid options like Reform.

To be clear, voting for Reform is not like voting for Trump. The US is a two party state, both of which govern at regular intervals. Trump's first term was fairly uneventful and him winning a second term against Harris was predictable. That the US famed "checks and balances" has failed to prevent him trashing the US in his second term is another matter.

Reform on the other hand, are a party run by someone who can barely bother to work as an MP, full of similar political underachievers, who have no feasible solutions for anything.

Nearly 10 years on from Brexit and we still live in a low information society. Until that is fixed, little will change.
Reply
#99
(05-03-2025, 05:50 AM)Protheroe Wrote: With pension savings now subject to IHT he’s rendered them univestable for anyone approaching the IHT limit. I can’t think of a more damaging disincentive than to suggest the state could take 40% of your retirement savings.

This deserves a thread of its own really. Couple of points on this, yes for those approaching the £1m figure of joint assets then that will make them need to plan better, and with the value of property as it is there are more people being put in that position. However I thought this was one of your gripes in that all that unearned income was not subject to taxation and surely this is a way to have a ‘wealth tax’ that effectively catches wealth rather than income. 

And also, investing in a pension should be to provide for later life and spend that investment instead of having an ‘earned’ income. It shouldn’t be as a way of avoiding taxation to pass on after you have died. If you aren’t going to use up all of your pension then you should draw it down and give it away which will be at a lower tax rate dependant on how much you are drawing down.

Ultimately adding your pension pots into IHT is the wealth tax that everyone is asking for (albeit a posthumous one).

(05-03-2025, 07:43 AM)Squid Wrote: Nearly 10 years on from Brexit and we still live in a low information society. Until that is fixed, little will change.

Be careful Squid, you’ll be accused of arrogance and not understanding why people voted for Reform. I agree by the way.

(05-03-2025, 07:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(05-02-2025, 09:57 PM)baggy1 Wrote: “Stop the clock” arf indeed. Stop being a closet full of cliches Dekka - do something about it. You turned your nose up at real change and now blame everyone else for the situation we’re in.

My politics haven’t changed I’m still centre/centre left, perhaps admit that the Labour party has drifted to the right in the pursuit of voters it will never convince to vote for them, whilst abandoning those that would if they didn’t feel betrayed and vilified by them. 

I wasn’t a big fan of Corbyn, because he came with too much baggage that meant he didn’t win two elections, but I still voted Labour because they hadn’t abandoned the most vulnerable or used divisive  language about ‘working people’ and everyone else. 

I’m not a party political person, I have voted Lib Dem as well as Labour previously, I’m not exactly sure what you think I can do about the folly that is the governments right of centre political direction.

If you hadn’t noticed the whole country has drifted to the right. It’s what happens when there is no money - the squeeze on taxes has reached maximum and people who are paying more and more start to look at how it is being spent. When they see waste like giving rich pensioners free money then they start to push back.
Reply
(05-03-2025, 07:37 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(05-03-2025, 03:27 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(05-02-2025, 07:47 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’m not sure we’ve ever discussed what underpinned their election success Derek so it’s odd to begin by telling me what I think it was founded on. I agree it’s built on sand, as will anyone that governs a society where the number of people voting for more than. 2 parties has moved from 4% to over half in fifty odd years

If you think it’s because they haven’t pulled miracles out of their arses in 9 months, you may be right. They were never going to.

Fully costed, fully funded. Right. Pensions and ISA's are the next gouge at the budget.

Starmer lied to the electorate when he didn't need to.

The results show Libs taking middle England and Reform taking the rest.

Uniparty is finished. Will the others be better? I'd like to see the Libs coming forward, but both Lanour and Tories are finished for years in the eyes of the voters.

 The results make that very clear.

Yes because local election results four years ahead of an election are always used as an accurate barometer of the next governing party aren’t they? Do you ever consider thinking before you type?

I think you're an idiot before I type.

If you can't acknowledge that Thursday was nothing but a disaster for both major parties with the public sending them a massive vote of no confidence then you are even more deluded than I gave you credit for ..
It would have been even worse if the full round of elections took place.

Both parties are in danger of walking into a Reform disaster if they don't listen to the voting public  The Tories have to change and Labour have to listen.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)