Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(05-02-2025, 08:21 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-02-2025, 08:14 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (05-02-2025, 07:02 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Simple question Dekka - how many people were that affected by the WFA allowance being cut couldn’t fuel their homes last winter?
With respect, that debate has been done to death and you're offering Protheroe-esque distraction tactics which detract from the fact that Labour are sleepwalking into electoral loss.
As Derek is often asked for his solutions to that, can we ask of you whether you think that's an accurate assessment and, if so, what you're going to do about it?
I'm pretty certain it's inevitable CC if we accept that the only way out of this is by having a popularist government, another argument that has been done to death. My point is that the reaction to policy is driven by social media rather than reality these days - WFA: perception was OAPs would be freezing in their beds, reality was that those that didn't need it didn't get it. PIP: perception is that the disabled will be left to rot in their homes, I expect the reality which will filter through in round 5 years to be very much unnoticeable.
Complaining about perception whilst not promoting reality will get us what we deserve I'm afraid. Hard to disagree with that however, Derek’s position is (possibly) reflective of one where people no longer want to champion (and have exhausting arguments about) the truth on behalf of Labour because they don’t feel that Labour is working for them. That’s how I feel about them and I was a rabid Corbyite Trot.i didn’t quite knock on doors for Corbyn but I was willing to have difficult conversations - face to face and online - with people misrepresenting him and his policies. I wouldn’t do the same for Starmer.
I’m almost at the point where I too accept the inevitable - that a far right/populist collation will form the next government. I just hope that the damage they do is severe enough that it kills populism whilst not severe enough that it hurts my family.
Passivity has its place as I get older which is why I mostly take the piss on here. I actually think my passivity is a symptom of depression but a depression that passivity is managing well!!!
Of course, the near opposite of passivity is chaos - and that fills the vacuum that passiveness creates.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(05-02-2025, 07:43 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-02-2025, 07:23 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-02-2025, 07:02 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Simple question Dekka - how many people were that affected by the WFA allowance being cut couldn’t fuel their homes last winter?
It doesn’t matter, it’s what people believe… have you not learned anything from the last decade be it Brexit or Trump?
The optics of taking money from the elderly and disabled, and raising costs on small business’s, care homes and hospices and at the same time failing to get a grip on the perceived threat of immigration, allowing the very rich to carry on regardless isn’t a good look for a party as it alienates both the left of the Labour Party and millions of those ‘hard working’ voters they are apparently on the side of.
As I said and you prove the point, it isn't about what they do it's about social media and the panic it causes. Look at Chunk last year - the poor lad lost his mind about people dying because of the WFA cut, he only got that perception from social media, not reality. The same is being played out with PIP with the same results.
If you want to change something look at the reality and promote that instead of the 'perception' as perceived by those receiving the information from social media sources that want to manipulate you (successfully as is very apparent).
NHS waiting lists down: https://www.england.nhs.uk/2025/03/nhs-s...-year-low/ , https://www.bma.org.uk/advice-and-suppor...a-analysis
Fixing the Junior Doctors strike, Increase in GPs meaning decrease in patient to GP ratio, National Minimum Wage increase. Whilst dealing with the shit show left from the last couple of decades.
Or we could go down the route that you suggest - A government that will say and give the electorate everything that they want to keep their votes. I can't think where that has been tried before and I'm struggling to remember who was the most vocal critic of this, lets call it, popularism.
You don’t understand that politics has changed you still want it to be played by Queensberry Rules when your opponent has a knuckleduster.
It’s what people believe that matters and what drives their vote as we saw with Brexit. Most people are worse off financially than they were a decade ago and any increase in wages has gone on bills, town centres they use are a shadow of their former seives with antisocial behaviour rife. Migration is an issue in some areas and causing prohlems, dumping people in communities no matter how small in working class areas (invariably) causes resentment and mistrust rightfully or wrongly. Cuts to PIP and heating allowances are issues for thousands of people no matter how much you play them down, say they aren’t that bad or you’re all gullible idiots who believe anything you read on SM.
Those things are what matter to people, they aren’t feeling better off, their experiences with health and social care aren’t feeling better, they don’t feel safe in their own towns or streets, they see people getting away with antisocial behaviour constantly and they are then divided into ludicrous categories like ‘working people’ so deserving and those who aren’t working so non-deserving and of no consequence.
What many believe is things aren’t better, things aren’t changing for the better for them or their families. Patience has ran out, and people wanted to see change now not in four years time. It isn’t fair, I was hardly a fan of the last Tory government so I realise what a mess they created but political rules have changed but your party offer yet more of the same as under the last Tory government.
The rules of engagement have changed, it’s not fair and it’s certainly not ethical but unless people see change quickly then expect snake oil salesmen and women offer simple solutions to complex problems and win elections whilst the middle aged centrists complain and condescend how unfair and stupid it all is.
Posts: 9,616
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(05-02-2025, 10:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-02-2025, 07:43 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-02-2025, 07:23 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-02-2025, 07:02 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Simple question Dekka - how many people were that affected by the WFA allowance being cut couldn’t fuel their homes last winter?
It doesn’t matter, it’s what people believe… have you not learned anything from the last decade be it Brexit or Trump?
The optics of taking money from the elderly and disabled, and raising costs on small business’s, care homes and hospices and at the same time failing to get a grip on the perceived threat of immigration, allowing the very rich to carry on regardless isn’t a good look for a party as it alienates both the left of the Labour Party and millions of those ‘hard working’ voters they are apparently on the side of.
As I said and you prove the point, it isn't about what they do it's about social media and the panic it causes. Look at Chunk last year - the poor lad lost his mind about people dying because of the WFA cut, he only got that perception from social media, not reality. The same is being played out with PIP with the same results.
If you want to change something look at the reality and promote that instead of the 'perception' as perceived by those receiving the information from social media sources that want to manipulate you (successfully as is very apparent).
NHS waiting lists down: https://www.england.nhs.uk/2025/03/nhs-s...-year-low/ , https://www.bma.org.uk/advice-and-suppor...a-analysis
Fixing the Junior Doctors strike, Increase in GPs meaning decrease in patient to GP ratio, National Minimum Wage increase. Whilst dealing with the shit show left from the last couple of decades.
Or we could go down the route that you suggest - A government that will say and give the electorate everything that they want to keep their votes. I can't think where that has been tried before and I'm struggling to remember who was the most vocal critic of this, lets call it, popularism.
You don’t understand that politics has changed you still want it to be played by Queensberry Rules when your opponent has a knuckleduster.
It’s what people believe that matters and what drives their vote as we saw with Brexit. Most people are worse off financially than they were a decade ago and any increase in wages has gone on bills, town centres they use are a shadow of their former seives with antisocial behaviour rife. Migration is an issue in some areas and causing prohlems, dumping people in communities no matter how small in working class areas (invariably) causes resentment and mistrust rightfully or wrongly. Cuts to PIP and heating allowances are issues for thousands of people no matter how much you play them down, say they aren’t that bad or you’re all gullible idiots who believe anything you read on SM.
Those things are what matter to people, they aren’t feeling better off, their experiences with health and social care aren’t feeling better, they don’t feel safe in their own towns or streets, they see people getting away with antisocial behaviour constantly and they are then divided into ludicrous categories like ‘working people’ so deserving and those who aren’t working so non-deserving and of no consequence.
What many believe is things aren’t better, things aren’t changing for the better for them or their families. Patience has ran out, and people wanted to see change now not in four years time. It isn’t fair, I was hardly a fan of the last Tory government so I realise what a mess they created but political rules have changed but your party offer yet more of the same as under the last Tory government.
The rules of engagement have changed, it’s not fair and it’s certainly not ethical but unless people see change quickly then expect snake oil salesmen and women offer simple solutions to complex problems and win elections whilst the middle aged centrists complain and condescend how unfair and stupid it all is.
Good post, Dekka.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 2,414
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
19
Is it a good post? is this what we've come to? Deliver the moon on a stick in 6 months or it's your own fault that you get beaten by a bunch of grifting charlatans. Fuck me. You get what you deserve I suppose.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(05-02-2025, 11:07 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Is it a good post? is this what we've come to? Deliver the moon on a stick in 6 months or it's your own fault that you get beaten by a bunch of grifting charlatans. Fuck me. You get what you deserve I suppose.
<best Proth voice>
Ahem, this is what some of us have been saying for years.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
I can understand why people would want to protest vote at the moment, but choosing the most far-right of the "core" parties that contemptible values is completely baffling, even before you add in their leader being a Trump mini-me who spends more time prostrating himself at the orange one's altar than he does serving his constituents in Clacton.
A growing number of people are supposed to want closer ties with the EU and a large percentage of the public are concerned about climate change...erm who should my protest vote be for? I know - a party that wants to be as far away from Europe as possible and wants to do nothing about climate change.
Reform is a hateful, twisted party which couldn't govern its way out of a paper bag, and which attracts all manner of unpleasant people as candidates. Voting for them is pitiful IMO, regardless of what people might think is a sufficient justification. All I can hope for at this point is that them having more power will make it even more obvious just how incompetent and bat-shit crazy they are.
Posts: 13,569
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
Everyone talking about Labour here, meanwhile the "natural party of government" are being eaten alive. Not helped by being essentially irrelevant on the national stage.
Posts: 7,448
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
05-02-2025, 11:34 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-02-2025, 11:36 AM by tHEgLASSdOORS.)
(05-02-2025, 11:32 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Everyone talking about Labour here, meanwhile the "natural party of government" are being eaten alive. Not helped by being essentially irrelevant on the national stage.
They’re spent. The further right will be absorbed into reform and the centrists will either defect to Labour or Lib Dem or create a glidepath to Texas
(05-02-2025, 11:07 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Is it a good post? is this what we've come to? Deliver the moon on a stick in 6 months or it's your own fault that you get beaten by a bunch of grifting charlatans. Fuck me. You get what you deserve I suppose.
Agreed. It’s an analysis of what’s wrong but not founded in any other realities of how difficult dealing with that is and will be for everyone
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(05-02-2025, 10:32 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-02-2025, 07:43 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (05-02-2025, 07:23 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (05-02-2025, 07:02 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Simple question Dekka - how many people were that affected by the WFA allowance being cut couldn’t fuel their homes last winter?
It doesn’t matter, it’s what people believe… have you not learned anything from the last decade be it Brexit or Trump?
The optics of taking money from the elderly and disabled, and raising costs on small business’s, care homes and hospices and at the same time failing to get a grip on the perceived threat of immigration, allowing the very rich to carry on regardless isn’t a good look for a party as it alienates both the left of the Labour Party and millions of those ‘hard working’ voters they are apparently on the side of.
As I said and you prove the point, it isn't about what they do it's about social media and the panic it causes. Look at Chunk last year - the poor lad lost his mind about people dying because of the WFA cut, he only got that perception from social media, not reality. The same is being played out with PIP with the same results.
If you want to change something look at the reality and promote that instead of the 'perception' as perceived by those receiving the information from social media sources that want to manipulate you (successfully as is very apparent).
NHS waiting lists down: https://www.england.nhs.uk/2025/03/nhs-s...-year-low/ , https://www.bma.org.uk/advice-and-suppor...a-analysis
Fixing the Junior Doctors strike, Increase in GPs meaning decrease in patient to GP ratio, National Minimum Wage increase. Whilst dealing with the shit show left from the last couple of decades.
Or we could go down the route that you suggest - A government that will say and give the electorate everything that they want to keep their votes. I can't think where that has been tried before and I'm struggling to remember who was the most vocal critic of this, lets call it, popularism.
You don’t understand that politics has changed you still want it to be played by Queensberry Rules when your opponent has a knuckleduster.
It’s what people believe that matters and what drives their vote as we saw with Brexit. Most people are worse off financially than they were a decade ago and any increase in wages has gone on bills, town centres they use are a shadow of their former seives with antisocial behaviour rife. Migration is an issue in some areas and causing prohlems, dumping people in communities no matter how small in working class areas (invariably) causes resentment and mistrust rightfully or wrongly. Cuts to PIP and heating allowances are issues for thousands of people no matter how much you play them down, say they aren’t that bad or you’re all gullible idiots who believe anything you read on SM.
Those things are what matter to people, they aren’t feeling better off, their experiences with health and social care aren’t feeling better, they don’t feel safe in their own towns or streets, they see people getting away with antisocial behaviour constantly and they are then divided into ludicrous categories like ‘working people’ so deserving and those who aren’t working so non-deserving and of no consequence.
What many believe is things aren’t better, things aren’t changing for the better for them or their families. Patience has ran out, and people wanted to see change now not in four years time. It isn’t fair, I was hardly a fan of the last Tory government so I realise what a mess they created but political rules have changed but your party offer yet more of the same as under the last Tory government.
The rules of engagement have changed, it’s not fair and it’s certainly not ethical but unless people see change quickly then expect snake oil salesmen and women offer simple solutions to complex problems and win elections whilst the middle aged centrists complain and condescend how unfair and stupid it all is.
Excellent post.
Posts: 7,718
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(05-02-2025, 11:12 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: I can understand why people would want to protest vote at the moment, but choosing the most far-right of the "core" parties that contemptible values is completely baffling, even before you add in their leader being a Trump mini-me who spends more time prostrating himself at the orange one's altar than he does serving his constituents in Clacton.
A growing number of people are supposed to want closer ties with the EU and a large percentage of the public are concerned about climate change...erm who should my protest vote be for? I know - a party that wants to be as far away from Europe as possible and wants to do nothing about climate change.
Reform is a hateful, twisted party which couldn't govern its way out of a paper bag, and which attracts all manner of unpleasant people as candidates. Voting for them is pitiful IMO, regardless of what people might think is a sufficient justification. All I can hope for at this point is that them having more power will make it even more obvious just how incompetent and bat-shit crazy they are.
Again, the people you're talking about aren't the ones electing Reform candidates. Until you can get your (collective) heads around who actually is then you'll never a) understand it or b) prevent it from happening again.
|