Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
04-28-2025, 09:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-28-2025, 09:57 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
You are aware of the concept of gearboxes, right? And that wind turbines have gearboxes, right?
They're not DC, they literally use wind turbines for grid black starts. I know, I supported a project where a wind farm literally did exactly that.
Posts: 162
Threads: 0
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
0
04-28-2025, 10:08 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-29-2025, 05:30 AM by KeithCurle'stoepoke.)
(04-28-2025, 09:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You are aware of the concept of gearboxes, right? And that wind turbines have gearboxes, right?
They're not DC, they literally use wind turbines for grid black starts. I know, I supported a project where a wind farm literally did exactly that.
Interesting. That's not the norm, otherwise you'd only be able to operate the turbine at a single speed corresponding to 50Hz output via the gearbox? I thought most opt for the flexibity of running the output through an inverter so you can run at a range of blade speeds, but it needs something to sync to. How do the ones mechanically linked to the grid work, and how do they manage to sync them all up, varying the load on the generator to keep a constant speed? Genuinely interested.
I could see the advantages in that in terms of inertia, but you're still stuck with not being able to dispatch the power when you need it if it isn't windy enough, plus the distortions on the grid due to geographical separation from the end user / rapid variation due to wind speed etc. Grids tend to instability and expense the more renewables you try and assimilate. I'd be surprised if this didn't play a significant part in Spain.
Posts: 7,444
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
I’ve ordered myself a turbine. Don’t have to buy any diesel that way.
Always winning.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
So that was a fun 12 hours…
About 12:30 everything just went black, and whilst phone signal held up for another 10 minutes or so, that died too. Fortunately it was a sunny day so most people started walking their dogs and sitting outside with a beer. The local shop started a “trust system” where you could buy things on the promise you’d return and pay when the card machine worked again if you had no cash.
A friend came over as he lives a couple roads away and his wife is a doctor so was on call in the hospital, and we drank a couple beers on the terrace and watched people wandering round on the street trying to get a phone connection.
I got a little analogue radio from an elderly neighbour as she had several, and the stories swirled about a cyber attack - but it was soon ruled out as no sensible terrorist would target Portugal
About 10ish the phone signal started to return intermittently and you heard random cheers as different neighbourhoods got power back. I was woken up about 1am when my lights came back on.
For an afternoon it was quite a pleasant disconnect, but I’d did make me realise how vulnerable I am here should something more ominous happen. I’ll be following the EU advice to have an emergency kit in the house!
Was supposed to fly to Belgium today but my flight has been cancelled, not due to the power outage but due to strikes there
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(04-28-2025, 10:08 PM)KeithCurle'stoepoke Wrote: (04-28-2025, 09:56 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: You are aware of the concept of gearboxes, right? And that wind turbines have gearboxes, right?
They're not DC, they literally use wind turbines for grid black starts. I know, I supported a project where a wind farm literally did exactly that.
Interesting. That's not the norm, otherwise you'd only be able to operate the turbine at a single speed corresponding to 50Hz output via the gearbox? I thought most opt for the flexibity of running the output through an inverter so you can run at a range of blade speeds, but it needs something to sync to. How do the ones mechanically linked to the grid work, and how do they manage to sync them all up, varying the load on the generator to keep a constant speed? Genuinely interested.
I could see the advantages in that in terms of inertia, but you're still stuck with not being able to dispatch the power when you need it if it isn't windy enough, plus the distortions on the grid due to geographical separation from the end user / rapid variation due to wind speed etc. Grids tend to instability and expense the more renewables you try and assimilate. I'd be surprised if this didn't play a significant part in Spain.
All wind turbines will output from the generator at AC, regardless of being fixed speed or variable speed. You're not pathing electron flow to induce a charge, you're turning a mechanism in a generator. DFIG which will have a gearbox to regulate frequency, synchronous will have convertors which go AC-DC-AC to regulate frequency.
The only ones that will output with DC will be either connected to a HVDC line (to reduce power loss) or a battery and they will go through a rectifier to convert from AC to DC first.
What seems to have happened in Spain is a local grid failure happened and because Spain's grid is basically isolated from the rest of Europe aside from one interconnector and that interconnector failed which meant that there was no backup to keep substations online, requiring a country-wide grid black start. Spain having a functionally isolated grid has helped keep energy costs down but this is the downside.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(04-29-2025, 06:03 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: So that was a fun 12 hours…
About 12:30 everything just went black, and whilst phone signal held up for another 10 minutes or so, that died too. Fortunately it was a sunny day so most people started walking their dogs and sitting outside with a beer. The local shop started a “trust system” where you could buy things on the promise you’d return and pay when the card machine worked again if you had no cash.
A friend came over as he lives a couple roads away and his wife is a doctor so was on call in the hospital, and we drank a couple beers on the terrace and watched people wandering round on the street trying to get a phone connection.
I got a little analogue radio from an elderly neighbour as she had several, and the stories swirled about a cyber attack - but it was soon ruled out as no sensible terrorist would target Portugal
About 10ish the phone signal started to return intermittently and you heard random cheers as different neighbourhoods got power back. I was woken up about 1am when my lights came back on.
For an afternoon it was quite a pleasant disconnect, but I’d did make me realise how vulnerable I am here should something more ominous happen. I’ll be following the EU advice to have an emergency kit in the house!
Was supposed to fly to Belgium today but my flight has been cancelled, not due to the power outage but due to strikes there 
That sounds like a class day. Also a great case study for the 'have a few beers, everything will sort itself out' approach to life. Well played, sir.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-29-2025, 07:14 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-29-2025, 06:03 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: So that was a fun 12 hours…
About 12:30 everything just went black, and whilst phone signal held up for another 10 minutes or so, that died too. Fortunately it was a sunny day so most people started walking their dogs and sitting outside with a beer. The local shop started a “trust system” where you could buy things on the promise you’d return and pay when the card machine worked again if you had no cash.
A friend came over as he lives a couple roads away and his wife is a doctor so was on call in the hospital, and we drank a couple beers on the terrace and watched people wandering round on the street trying to get a phone connection.
I got a little analogue radio from an elderly neighbour as she had several, and the stories swirled about a cyber attack - but it was soon ruled out as no sensible terrorist would target Portugal
About 10ish the phone signal started to return intermittently and you heard random cheers as different neighbourhoods got power back. I was woken up about 1am when my lights came back on.
For an afternoon it was quite a pleasant disconnect, but I’d did make me realise how vulnerable I am here should something more ominous happen. I’ll be following the EU advice to have an emergency kit in the house!
Was supposed to fly to Belgium today but my flight has been cancelled, not due to the power outage but due to strikes there 
That sounds like a class day. Also a great case study for the 'have a few beers, everything will sort itself out' approach to life. Well played, sir.
Now the dust is settling a bit and we’re hearing stories of people trapped in lifts for 6 hours, those stranded in train stations overnight, it’s certainly more sobering, and my friend’s wife who works as a doctor in the local hospital had a terrible 24 hours having to make big decisions based on a reduced capacity due to generators running things.
For me, I spent an afternoon with a friend and a few beers and have had to throw some food away that got ruined when the freezer packed in, so no harm done, but it has shown how vulnerable we are to something like this - within 48 hours I’d have been pretty fucked.
Probably didn’t help that this happened a couple days after I watched the cyberattack Black Mirror episode, but it has made me realise, have a battery powered AM/FM radio in the house, have a torch and spare batteries at all times, have a couple lighters and camping stove, and keep 3-4 days’ canned food somewhere safe. Also, have an escape plan that you and loved ones know, if something happens, agree to meet somewhere.
Posts: 9,641
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
04-29-2025, 07:44 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-29-2025, 07:47 AM by Josh1873.)
Just reading up on this now. My initial reaction was some form of cyber terrorist attack or other foul play, but apparently there's no evidence to support that.
Between this incident and the Heathrow incident it does seem too much of a coincidence to me. Then again, I love a good conspiracy! (I'm not a loon that believes them, I just enjoy reading the theories).
Shit happens and faults do occur. I'm just amazed there's no contingency plans for events like this and what we saw at Heathrow. That's the biggest concern to come out of these incidents. How reliant we are on energy and how woefully under prepared we are if something does happen.
I know these are exceptional circumstances, but you can't let cities and countries, and one of the world's busiest airport comes to a complete standstill due to electric faults. What are the contingency plans?
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(04-29-2025, 07:44 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Just reading up on this now. My initial reaction was some form of cyber terrorist attack or other foul play, but apparently there's no evidence to support that.
Between this incident and the Heathrow incident it does seem too much of a coincidence to me. Then again, I love a good conspiracy! (I'm not a loon that believes them, I just enjoy reading the theories).
Shit happens and faults do occur. I'm just amazed there's no contingency plans for events like this and what we saw at Heathrow. That's the biggest concern to come out of these incidents. How reliant we are on energy and how woefully under prepared we are if something does happen.
I know these are exceptional circumstances, but you can't let cities and countries, and one of the world's busiest airport comes to a complete standstill due to electric faults. What are the contingency plans?
I'm not sure what contingency plan you can have for something like this Josh - we'll probably never be told what really happened yesterday but essentially the power grid for 2 countries went down. Other than putting plans in place to try and prevent it from happening, I'm not sure you can have a back up for a whole country.
To give the Spanish their credit, they got things back running again quickly and the people were very relaxed about it - had this happened in the UK I imagine there'd have been full scale looting and panic within a couple hours!
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
04-29-2025, 07:56 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-29-2025, 07:57 AM by Ted Maul.)
(04-29-2025, 07:39 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (04-29-2025, 07:14 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-29-2025, 06:03 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: So that was a fun 12 hours…
About 12:30 everything just went black, and whilst phone signal held up for another 10 minutes or so, that died too. Fortunately it was a sunny day so most people started walking their dogs and sitting outside with a beer. The local shop started a “trust system” where you could buy things on the promise you’d return and pay when the card machine worked again if you had no cash.
A friend came over as he lives a couple roads away and his wife is a doctor so was on call in the hospital, and we drank a couple beers on the terrace and watched people wandering round on the street trying to get a phone connection.
I got a little analogue radio from an elderly neighbour as she had several, and the stories swirled about a cyber attack - but it was soon ruled out as no sensible terrorist would target Portugal
About 10ish the phone signal started to return intermittently and you heard random cheers as different neighbourhoods got power back. I was woken up about 1am when my lights came back on.
For an afternoon it was quite a pleasant disconnect, but I’d did make me realise how vulnerable I am here should something more ominous happen. I’ll be following the EU advice to have an emergency kit in the house!
Was supposed to fly to Belgium today but my flight has been cancelled, not due to the power outage but due to strikes there 
That sounds like a class day. Also a great case study for the 'have a few beers, everything will sort itself out' approach to life. Well played, sir.
Now the dust is settling a bit and we’re hearing stories of people trapped in lifts for 6 hours, those stranded in train stations overnight, it’s certainly more sobering, and my friend’s wife who works as a doctor in the local hospital had a terrible 24 hours having to make big decisions based on a reduced capacity due to generators running things.
For me, I spent an afternoon with a friend and a few beers and have had to throw some food away that got ruined when the freezer packed in, so no harm done, but it has shown how vulnerable we are to something like this - within 48 hours I’d have been pretty fucked.
Probably didn’t help that this happened a couple days after I watched the cyberattack Black Mirror episode, but it has made me realise, have a battery powered AM/FM radio in the house, have a torch and spare batteries at all times, have a couple lighters and camping stove, and keep 3-4 days’ canned food somewhere safe. Also, have an escape plan that you and loved ones know, if something happens, agree to meet somewhere.
Obviously there are those that have had to deal with the sharp end of the outage, but you've had a nice day listening to a bit of radio enjoying a few un-refrigerated beers with someones abuela.
I'm off to start work on the bunker.
|