Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(04-24-2025, 05:09 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (04-24-2025, 04:43 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Nestor convinces me when i listen to him but he is doing a lot of talking without delivering.
1 Wicky. Royally Fucking that up
2 somehow in his head he thinks it's OK to go from Wicky to Mowbray.
3 player recruitment is variable. But I would say just about in the positive.
4 The lack of break clause (if fact)
I'm not expecting miracles or immediate success but maybe I am using my ears more than my eyes when it comes to Nestor.
I still believe.
Disagree on recruitment. The only ones that haven't come off cost bobbins whereas Price, Styles, Heggem will all reap a decent profit should we cash in.
Largely agree with that but Armstrong I imagine would have cost us a fairly decent loan fee. Nestor certainly talks a good game and I feel we're making strides as a club but we do need to improve our hit ratio with our signings this summer. The ones which have come off have been excellent (and Johnston has been very good at times if not as effective as last season) but our loans have all been either terrible or not lived up to expectations at all and we need to be avoiding similar situations to the likes of Cole/Frabotta where we're bringing in players who the manager(s) clearly doesn't rate at all.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
It gets mentioned a lot but realistically no club is ever going to get better than a ~50% hit rate for signings coming in and being sold on for huge profit. Even the clubs held up as the benchmark for this sort of thing have poor windows every now and then, Brighton last summer had a bit of a mare by their standards.
On Frabotta and Cole, both were brought in as bodies to fill places in the squad. I feel there was probably a bit more hope for Frabotta with Nestor's Serie A connections but I can't imagine Carlos was under any illusions what he was getting with Cole and he has been used as such.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Ideally we wouldn't make signings like Cole, we'd have an academy graduate step up to try to earn a place from that position, but we're still not good at getting that pathway done.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
04-25-2025, 09:49 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-25-2025, 09:50 AM by Tom Joad.)
Couple of points here.
Wicky is still not managing anywhere (as far as I know). Maybe he ain't the next Pep?
Mowbray first time had a squad that should have walked the league. He lost to Derby in a play off scrap and we all know how good they were. He then said it was because he needed his own men in. Yes, we won the league but I couldn't help think back to that period when he was appointed 2nd time as we dont have the resources to build a comparable side this time around.
Further. Frabotta, Cole and Wildsmith. In no way to these detract from the positive signings we have made. They were all got in early, for little money, as even the owners weren't sure how our finances were going to be and we all thought we might struggle to put a team out. As the window progressed we got more leeway and made better signings. Yes, it could have been better, but overall our business beats this hypothetical 50% ratio hands down.
Posts: 2,927
Threads: 44
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation:
7
(04-25-2025, 08:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: It gets mentioned a lot but realistically no club is ever going to get better than a ~50% hit rate for signings coming in and being sold on for huge profit. Even the clubs held up as the benchmark for this sort of thing have poor windows every now and then, Brighton last summer had a bit of a mare by their standards.
On Frabotta and Cole, both were brought in as bodies to fill places in the squad. I feel there was probably a bit more hope for Frabotta with Nestor's Serie A connections but I can't imagine Carlos was under any illusions what he was getting with Cole and he has been used as such.
Well Cole hasn't been used at all really. It's all very well padding out the squad but utterly pointless bringing in players if there is no real intention of using them at all. He's done nothing (or been given the opportunity to do anything) which couldn't have been achieved by giving one of the kids a go.
Without the benefit of the parachute payments we really do need to be trying to ensure that every new addition improves the squad whether it be as a first team regular or more of a squad player. We've had far too many years of just trying to bring in as many players as possible and hope that some of them come off. You only have to look back the original squad Megson created in his first couple of years at the club. There were very few players brought in during that period who didn't add something to the squad. To a lesser extent we also did that with the restructure of the squad in 2007 under Mowbray although we were a little more hit and miss. When finances are that much tighter now we need to be as diligent as possible with who we're bringing in.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
If Cole is that bad why did we give him a 2 year contract? If you exclude penalties he was the leading scorer in Division One last year, but as his career had been spent in the lower divisions there was always concern about if he could make the step up and at his age little likelihood of a transfer fee.
As for "cheap" he is probably on 10k per week. That is a million over the course of his contract, that figure excludes signing on fee and agents fee. Our turnover is about £26 million per annum and probably falling, so 4-5% of it to a loss making club is hardly cheap.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(04-25-2025, 09:49 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Couple of points here.
Wicky is still not managing anywhere (as far as I know). Maybe he ain't the next Pep?
Mowbray first time had a squad that should have walked the league. He lost to Derby in a play off scrap and we all know how good they were. He then said it was because he needed his own men in. Yes, we won the league but I couldn't help think back to that period when he was appointed 2nd time as we dont have the resources to build a comparable side this time around.
Further. Frabotta, Cole and Wildsmith. In no way to these detract from the positive signings we have made. They were all got in early, for little money, as even the owners weren't sure how our finances were going to be and we all thought we might struggle to put a team out. As the window progressed we got more leeway and made better signings. Yes, it could have been better, but overall our business beats this hypothetical 50% ratio hands down.
What people forget with Mowbray first time round is the money he spent came in the main from the sale of players.
People seem to think that it's a piece of piss to substantially overhaul a squad in a summer transfer window and get immediate success the next season.
So for example we lost Kamara in that window who had scored 25 goals, replaced his goals by signing Bednar and Miller for less than half the fee we received for Kamara. That's great management, not something that a Sunday parks football manager could do.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
04-25-2025, 10:10 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-25-2025, 10:17 AM by Ted Maul.)
(04-25-2025, 09:49 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote: (04-25-2025, 08:45 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: It gets mentioned a lot but realistically no club is ever going to get better than a ~50% hit rate for signings coming in and being sold on for huge profit. Even the clubs held up as the benchmark for this sort of thing have poor windows every now and then, Brighton last summer had a bit of a mare by their standards.
On Frabotta and Cole, both were brought in as bodies to fill places in the squad. I feel there was probably a bit more hope for Frabotta with Nestor's Serie A connections but I can't imagine Carlos was under any illusions what he was getting with Cole and he has been used as such.
Well Cole hasn't been used at all really. It's all very well padding out the squad but utterly pointless bringing in players if there is no real intention of using them at all. He's done nothing (or been given the opportunity to do anything) which couldn't have been achieved by giving one of the kids a go.
Without the benefit of the parachute payments we really do need to be trying to ensure that every new addition improves the squad whether it be as a first team regular or more of a squad player. We've had far too many years of just trying to bring in as many players as possible and hope that some of them come off. You only have to look back the original squad Megson created in his first couple of years at the club. There were very few players brought in during that period who didn't add something to the squad. To a lesser extent we also did that with the restructure of the squad in 2007 under Mowbray although we were a little more hit and miss. When finances are that much tighter now we need to be as diligent as possible with who we're bringing in.
As Birdy said, it's something we've been really poor at for a number of years. I don't know enough about the U21s to say whether there's someone banging in the goals last season who'd warrant a semi-regular spot on our bench.
As for next season what is better for the likes of Heard, Diomande, Shaw, Mohammed, Nelson, Deeming, Whitwell, Bostock, Love - a season where they stay with the first time squad and maybe make 3-4 appearances, or a full year on loan whilst we pad out the squad with cheap, no risk signings who are brought in knowing exactly where they stand? There's not a right or wrong answer.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
04-25-2025, 10:22 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-25-2025, 10:23 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(04-25-2025, 10:10 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-25-2025, 09:49 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Couple of points here.
Wicky is still not managing anywhere (as far as I know). Maybe he ain't the next Pep?
Mowbray first time had a squad that should have walked the league. He lost to Derby in a play off scrap and we all know how good they were. He then said it was because he needed his own men in. Yes, we won the league but I couldn't help think back to that period when he was appointed 2nd time as we dont have the resources to build a comparable side this time around.
Further. Frabotta, Cole and Wildsmith. In no way to these detract from the positive signings we have made. They were all got in early, for little money, as even the owners weren't sure how our finances were going to be and we all thought we might struggle to put a team out. As the window progressed we got more leeway and made better signings. Yes, it could have been better, but overall our business beats this hypothetical 50% ratio hands down.
What people forget with Mowbray first time round is the money he spent came in the main from the sale of players.
People seem to think that it's a piece of piss to substantially overhaul a squad in a summer transfer window and get immediate success the next season.
So for example we lost Kamara in that window who had scored 25 goals, replaced his goals by signing Bednar and Miller for less than half the fee we received for Kamara. That's great management, not something that a Sunday parks football manager could do.
He only had to spend the biggest budget in a very poor league (look at the pts total to win the Championship that season), because he failed to get an incredibly strong squad up the previous year, with Prem quality players across the squad. The Derby playoff was one of the most depressing days supporting the club. Patronising and dismissing both Sunderland and I think Blues for not playing the ‘right way’ as they gained promotion at our expense.
It would have been a dereliction of duty not to get us up over those two seasons. He’s certainly not as bad a manager as some have said but his record is that of an average Champ manager and if we are to get out of this crap league with our current resources we need an exceptional one at this level.
Posts: 15,277
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
That is exactly the conundrum. If they stay here they may not play, but a few injuries they will and they may take the chance and make a position theirs. Or send them on loan for first team football hoping they come back good enough to challenge for a spot, but still with multiple players ahead of them.
It's a hard balance to stroke, we need to get better at it.
|