Diangoner and a Swift exit
#21
(04-22-2025, 11:56 AM)Squid Wrote: I think people are being harsh on Grady. No, he wasn't worth what we paid for him, but we were run by idiots at the time, so that has to be taken into account.

In his favour:

1)Instrumental in getting us promoted under Bilic.

2)Decent performer under Corberán. Scored several important goals and when he played well, the team general did do well.

I'd also note, more than any other player in the team there's a massive difference between what people online say about him and what fans in the stands do. Always a popular player at the Hawthorns.

Very fair.

I’ve always felt peoples opinions on Grady are a good barometer of what they know about football. Some people have a real hatred for him and fail to see that he’s actually a very good player that offers a lot both defensively and in attack and, for all his injuries, is consistently one of our most threatening players when on the pitch, but some people cannot see past his fee.

I fully expect he will go elsewhere and do well, under the right manager I wouldn’t be adverse to keeping him as I do think he offers something no one else in our squad does, and if he can stay fit, he can offer 20goals/assists in a season. 

Swift has been a huge disappointment, I was really excited by his signing and though we finally had the goal scoring midfielder we’d lacked since Morrison but he’s just never delivered.
Reply
#22
(04-22-2025, 12:05 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-22-2025, 11:56 AM)Squid Wrote: I think people are being harsh on Grady. No, he wasn't worth what we paid for him, but we were run by idiots at the time, so that has to be taken into account.

In his favour:

1)Instrumental in getting us promoted under Bilic.

2)Decent performer under Corberán. Scored several important goals and when he played well, the team general did do well.

I'd also note, more than any other player in the team there's a massive difference between what people online say about him and what fans in the stands do. Always a popular player at the Hawthorns.

Very fair.

I’ve always felt peoples opinions on Grady are a good barometer of what they know about football. Some people have a real hatred for him and fail to see that he’s actually a very good player that offers a lot both defensively and in attack and, for all his injuries, is consistently one of our most threatening players when on the pitch, but some people cannot see past his fee.

I fully expect he will go elsewhere and do well, under the right manager I wouldn’t be adverse to keeping him as I do think he offers something no one else in our squad does, and if he can stay fit, he can offer 20goals/assists in a season. 

Swift has been a huge disappointment, I was really excited by his signing and though we finally had the goal scoring midfielder we’d lacked since Morrison but he’s just never delivered.

If you book in advance they cover most areas  Big Grin Big Grin
Reply
#23
Grady is very talented.

We pay too much for what he offers, he makes way too many mistakes compared to his output, I don't think he's lazy mind, just a generally frustrating player.

Happy to see him go, sad to have made such a loss on him, but hope he does well wherever he ends up, but reckon he'll get a lot of the same comments there too.
Reply
#24
(04-22-2025, 02:06 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Grady is very talented.

We pay too much for what he offers, he makes way too many mistakes compared to his output, I don't think he's lazy mind, just a generally frustrating player.

Happy to see him go, sad to have made such a loss on him, but hope he does well wherever he ends up, but reckon he'll get a lot of the same comments there too.

Nailed it. Frustrating is the key word when I think of Grady. All the talent in the world but doesn't produce enough. The most frustrating part to his game is him constantly trying to dribble in tight areas rather than pop off a quick pass and losing possession.

He'll get himself a decent move but will be a bench player if he gets a Prem move. Talk of Leeds and Dingles.
Reply
#25
I've always thought Grady could be a premier League player. I wonder whether West ham might give him a go?
He's affordable for a newly promoted/ bottom half squad.
But I agree with the above - a bench warmer most likely.
Reply
#26
(04-22-2025, 02:45 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I've always thought Grady could be a premier League player. I wonder whether West ham might give him a go?
He's affordable for a newly promoted/ bottom half squad.
But I agree with the above - a bench warmer most likely.

I can see him at Brentford and see him doing quite well there.
Reply
#27
I don’t think either Grady or Swift will get an upgrade on us
Both to inconsistent
Swift maybe Oxford or Derby
Grady maybe Stoke or Norwich
Reply
#28
(04-22-2025, 03:50 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: I don’t think either Grady or Swift will get an upgrade on us
Both to inconsistent
Swift maybe Oxford or Derby
Grady maybe Stoke or Norwich

I think you could be surprised with Grady good age free I think a newly promoted side or he could go abroad.
Swift two good choices there.
Reply
#29
Grady will disappear abroad for a season, then come back to be a bit part player. £18m was a complete joke. He's got talent but alas only displays it for 5 mins per game.
Swift a luxury player who has 1 good game in 10. Sores 2 world class goals a season and then flatters to deceive the rest of the time.
Unfortunately we are not good enough to carry luxury players so replacing them with roll your sleeves up and fight for points players are what we need.
Goodbye to both of them.
Reply
#30
I like both of them and some of the vitriol poured down on them elsewhere on SM has been appalling. They've frustrated me often but they're also very good footballers technically who can create chances. There's nobody else in our squad who can look after the ball in tight spaces like them and they do provide some exquisite moments. I think they both need clubs where they can get a bit of love. Good luck to both.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: