Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
What alarmed me was how swiftly the players' organisation and discipline evaporated after Corberan left.
Yes they may be being asked to adopt a different style, but the basics of tracking back, holding shape, staying with your man, etc should remain, if even by muscle memory. All of that went out the window remarkably quickly.
Posts: 8,006
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(04-22-2025, 01:08 PM)Duffers Wrote: What alarmed me was how swiftly the players' organisation and discipline evaporated after Corberan left.
Yes they may be being asked to adopt a different style, but the basics of tracking back, holding shape, staying with your man, etc should remain, if even by muscle memory. All of that went out the window remarkably quickly.
Maybe the Pompey game made their muscles think it was easier than it was! 
Seriously though, that result could well have been the catalyst, as it seemed to confirm Mowbray's theory that we just needed to take the handbrake off and let them fall in love again, when, in fact, Pompey were just utter dogshit (at the time). Then, instead of kicking on from it, through coaching and re-enforcing the good things we did, he just sat back thinking job done, easy money and then never got it back.
Posts: 9,644
Threads: 519
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-22-2025, 01:08 PM)Duffers Wrote: What alarmed me was how swiftly the players' organisation and discipline evaporated after Corberan left.
Yes they may be being asked to adopt a different style, but the basics of tracking back, holding shape, staying with your man, etc should remain, if even by muscle memory. All of that went out the window remarkably quickly.
Not sure it's that simple, Duffers. The defensive shape and structure comes from the work done in terms meetings. Understanding how the opponents set up, manage possession, move off the ball. Understanding the opponents individuals and their strengths and weaknesses.
When all that is done properly by the coaching staff, and a plan is put in place to counter act it. The on field stuff comes easier to the players because they have prepared properly.
Since ToMo had come in we seem to have completely disregarded there is another team playing and seem horrifically unorganised.
I haven't seen this from off in work rate that people are pointing it. The players have run as much as usual, sadly they are running around in a poor shape, without the work done to help them be efficient.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 439
Threads: 37
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(04-22-2025, 12:25 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Can you not think it’s both?
I certainly do.
Mowbray was a disaster. He looked clueless, broken and tired. A really bad appointment.
But there are a current crop of 4/5 players that have been here a while that have seen off countless managers and are often found wanting when the going gets tough.
+1
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(04-22-2025, 12:47 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:14 PM)Squid Wrote: On social media, all the talk is of the players having seen off yet another manager, despite most of them not having been here that long.
However, one comment stood out for me. Apparently Furlong was seen arguing with Mark Venus in the dugout and this is apparently outrageous, because Furlong should know his place (I'm paraphrasing).
But actually, I don't blame Furlong for questioning what was happening, because presumably he, like anyone else with functioning eyesight could see that the set up of the team yesterday was a total mess and we were being overrun and out thought by Derby County.
And that maybe, Furlong saying something about it, as opposed to just watching silently is a sign that he cares. Overall, he's been a decent player for us. Good patches and bad (hence he's in the Championship), but rarely looks like he phones it in.
I get why people (including local media) are keener to point the finger at players as opposed to a departed manager who is beloved by many, but it really shouldn't be understated how badly Mowbray performed and how nonsensical his team selections and game management were.
Been having this exact debate on X myself. It's been clear for a while that many of the players have looked confused and uncomfortable with what's been asked of them. I'd expect the stronger in the group to question once a losing run takes hold.
However, what isn't acceptable is doing it in public, this should be thrashed out behind closed doors.
What is also unacceptable is stopping the effort. Yiu can still fight for the ball, track runners and play with some bollocks.
So manager and players have responsibility for the shocking end to the season.
Spot on Rich. Look at Wallace when he came on yesterday, the contrast was massive between the effort he put in and some of the others on the pitch. Doesn't matter if you don't like the manager or don't agree with the setup it's your job as a player to give 100%.
Posts: 9,655
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
I don't get this criticism of the players at all. Just look at how we defended and threw bodies on the line during the last ten minutes of the recent Bristol defeat.
They may not process quality, but that's not the sign of players who are trying to get a manager sacked, or don't care about their performances, and whatever lazy analogy you want to throw out there.
Posts: 340
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
-2
04-22-2025, 01:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-22-2025, 01:42 PM by Sandking.)
(04-22-2025, 01:32 PM)TartanRug Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:47 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:14 PM)Squid Wrote: On social media, all the talk is of the players having seen off yet another manager, despite most of them not having been here that long.
However, one comment stood out for me. Apparently Furlong was seen arguing with Mark Venus in the dugout and this is apparently outrageous, because Furlong should know his place (I'm paraphrasing).
But actually, I don't blame Furlong for questioning what was happening, because presumably he, like anyone else with functioning eyesight could see that the set up of the team yesterday was a total mess and we were being overrun and out thought by Derby County.
And that maybe, Furlong saying something about it, as opposed to just watching silently is a sign that he cares. Overall, he's been a decent player for us. Good patches and bad (hence he's in the Championship), but rarely looks like he phones it in.
I get why people (including local media) are keener to point the finger at players as opposed to a departed manager who is beloved by many, but it really shouldn't be understated how badly Mowbray performed and how nonsensical his team selections and game management were.
Been having this exact debate on X myself. It's been clear for a while that many of the players have looked confused and uncomfortable with what's been asked of them. I'd expect the stronger in the group to question once a losing run takes hold.
However, what isn't acceptable is doing it in public, this should be thrashed out behind closed doors.
What is also unacceptable is stopping the effort. Yiu can still fight for the ball, track runners and play with some bollocks.
So manager and players have responsibility for the shocking end to the season.
Spot on Rich. Look at Wallace when he came on yesterday, the contrast was massive between the effort he put in and some of the others on the pitch. Doesn't matter if you don't like the manager or don't agree with the setup it's your job as a player to give 100%. In an ideal football world, yes. But in reality, players tend to play for the manager first and foremost, not the badge, shirt, or fans. When it works it's just a ripple effect.
It's been an utter shitshow under Mowbray.
We went from a manager who at his best micro-managed on a match day like he had a joystick in his hand playing a game of FC 25. Mowbray is the polar opposite. That's a big ask for any group of players.
This should have fully been taken into account before TM was appointed. Or TM should have paid more mind to what had preceded him. That simple for me.
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
04-22-2025, 01:43 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-22-2025, 01:48 PM by TartanRug.)
(04-22-2025, 01:36 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I don't get this criticism of the players at all. Just look at how we defended and threw bodies on the line during the last ten minutes of the recent Bristol defeat.
They may not process quality, but that's not the sign of players who are trying to get a manager sacked, or don't care about their performances, and whatever lazy analogy you want to throw out there.
Sorry but the performance and effort levels of some vs Cov and yesterday was unacceptable
(04-22-2025, 01:41 PM)Sandking Wrote: (04-22-2025, 01:32 PM)TartanRug Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:47 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:14 PM)Squid Wrote: On social media, all the talk is of the players having seen off yet another manager, despite most of them not having been here that long.
However, one comment stood out for me. Apparently Furlong was seen arguing with Mark Venus in the dugout and this is apparently outrageous, because Furlong should know his place (I'm paraphrasing).
But actually, I don't blame Furlong for questioning what was happening, because presumably he, like anyone else with functioning eyesight could see that the set up of the team yesterday was a total mess and we were being overrun and out thought by Derby County.
And that maybe, Furlong saying something about it, as opposed to just watching silently is a sign that he cares. Overall, he's been a decent player for us. Good patches and bad (hence he's in the Championship), but rarely looks like he phones it in.
I get why people (including local media) are keener to point the finger at players as opposed to a departed manager who is beloved by many, but it really shouldn't be understated how badly Mowbray performed and how nonsensical his team selections and game management were.
Been having this exact debate on X myself. It's been clear for a while that many of the players have looked confused and uncomfortable with what's been asked of them. I'd expect the stronger in the group to question once a losing run takes hold.
However, what isn't acceptable is doing it in public, this should be thrashed out behind closed doors.
What is also unacceptable is stopping the effort. Yiu can still fight for the ball, track runners and play with some bollocks.
So manager and players have responsibility for the shocking end to the season.
Spot on Rich. Look at Wallace when he came on yesterday, the contrast was massive between the effort he put in and some of the others on the pitch. Doesn't matter if you don't like the manager or don't agree with the setup it's your job as a player to give 100%. In an ideal football world, yes. But in reality, players tend to play for the manager first and foremost, not the badge, shirt, or fans. When it works it's just a ripple effect.
It's been an utter shitshow under Mowbray.
We went from a manager who at his best micro-managed on a match day like he had a joystick in his hand playing a game of FC 25. Mowbray is the polar opposite. That's a big ask for any group of players.
This should have fully been taken into account before TM was appointed. Or TM should have paid more mind to what had preceded him. That simple for me.
I don't think it's too much to ask for players to put in some effort. Look at Bartley ambling back for the 3rd goal, I know he's slow but he's not that slow - could have quite easily blocked the shot if he'd tried. Just think that a few of our players have questionable attitude. BTW none of this means that I think TM was anything other than a disaster.
Posts: 2,916
Threads: 33
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation:
11
I’ve read that you’ve won 5 out of 17 since Mowbray was officially in the dug out v Boro. But you’d only won 4 out of 22 before that game. Just how big has this drop off been and was it a shock considering the style of play/coaching between CC and TM?
Btw I’m actually amazed at those stats if true
Posts: 27,984
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(04-22-2025, 01:50 PM)KRO Wrote: I’ve read that you’ve won 5 out of 17 since Mowbray was officially in the dug out v Boro. But you’d only won 4 out of 22 before that game. Just how big has this drop off been and was it a shock considering the style of play/coaching between CC and TM?
Btw I’m actually amazed at those stats if true
Key difference is that we barely lost under Corberan either, just drew every week.
Mowbray we now just lose.
|