Posts: 10,539
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
04-22-2025, 12:34 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-22-2025, 12:35 PM by Dumbo.)
(04-22-2025, 12:31 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: It's pretty clear that the former manager is the root cause of this shit show. No doubt about it. And the "Bottlejobs", "Lazy", "Toxic" bullshit arguments being banded about are largely a desperate attempt for people to hide behind as they either were fiercely defending Old Tony just a few weeks back, or they have so much nostalgic warm feelings for him that they can't see the reality.
Again…….
You can be of the opinion that Tony was an awful clueless appointment that failed spectacularly and question the size of the grapefruits of few our ‘seniors’.
(04-22-2025, 12:33 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:29 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Some fans and local media are just looking to blame the players because it’s easier than criticising the former manager because they liked him.
I’ve not seen a single person on here or online that has said the decision to relieve Mowbray of his duties was the incorrect one.
I’ve seen people rightly question the commitment, desire and integrity of a few of our long servers for their role in what’s petered out to be a dismal season.
Eh? Is there a word missing here?
Two letters more like  doh - edited
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
04-22-2025, 12:38 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-22-2025, 12:42 PM by Ted Maul.)
(04-22-2025, 12:32 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:25 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Can you not think it’s both?
I certainly do.
Mowbray was a disaster. He looked clueless, broken and tired. A really bad appointment.
But there are a current crop of 4/5 players that have been here a while that have seen off countless managers and are often found wanting when the going gets tough.
How come the going didn't get tough when we had a proper manager?
It did though didn’t it? Questions were started to be asked of Carlos and why we kept drawing games. Questions were asked after our no show in the play offs last season. Rightly or wrongly.
Also, Carlos is an entity we’re unlikely to get that calibre of manager again any time soon. Just look at what he’s done with the Spanish giant he now resides over.
I can’t wait for some young up and comer to come in and get told by Bart’s and the boys they’re not buying in to his methods or some unheard of foreigner to come in for Furlong to not understand what he’s putting across.
Results, yes, but at no stage did we have multiple threads per day on here and people all over Twitter questioning the application of the players.
There was a thread on here about sacking Carlos and there were a number of posts saying that the players were still giving their all for him.
They're not the greatest bunch of players but they are absolutely not the reason that Mowbray or Bruce got the sack.
Posts: 10,539
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(04-22-2025, 12:38 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:32 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:25 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Can you not think it’s both?
I certainly do.
Mowbray was a disaster. He looked clueless, broken and tired. A really bad appointment.
But there are a current crop of 4/5 players that have been here a while that have seen off countless managers and are often found wanting when the going gets tough.
How come the going didn't get tough when we had a proper manager?
It did though didn’t it? Questions were started to be asked of Carlos and why we kept drawing games. Questions were asked after our no show in the play offs last season. Rightly or wrongly.
Also, Carlos is an entity we’re unlikely to get that calibre of manager again any time soon. Just look at what he’s done with the Spanish giant he now resides over.
I can’t wait for some young up and comer to come in and get told by Bart’s and the boys they’re not buying in to his methods or some unheard of foreigner to come in for Furlong to not understand what he’s putting across.
Results, yes, but at no stage did we have multiple threads per day on here and people all over Twitter questioning the application of the players.
There was a thread on here about sacking Carlos and there were a number of posts saying that the players were still giving their all for him.
Fair. For me, personally, I’ve just seen enough from a few of our longer serving players that makes me question them when things get hard.
The recruitment of Bany, Price, Diakite gives me hope we can fully transition the squad over the next couple of years and fully rebuild our squad, identity and team attitude.
I must be the only person on here that thinks Bartley getting another year (appearance related I know) is not great. The news of Swift and Grady leaving is better though.
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Would be great if Mogga went back on Slaven's pod and gave his side of the story.
Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(04-22-2025, 12:14 PM)Squid Wrote: On social media, all the talk is of the players having seen off yet another manager, despite most of them not having been here that long.
However, one comment stood out for me. Apparently Furlong was seen arguing with Mark Venus in the dugout and this is apparently outrageous, because Furlong should know his place (I'm paraphrasing).
But actually, I don't blame Furlong for questioning what was happening, because presumably he, like anyone else with functioning eyesight could see that the set up of the team yesterday was a total mess and we were being overrun and out thought by Derby County.
And that maybe, Furlong saying something about it, as opposed to just watching silently is a sign that he cares. Overall, he's been a decent player for us. Good patches and bad (hence he's in the Championship), but rarely looks like he phones it in.
I get why people (including local media) are keener to point the finger at players as opposed to a departed manager who is beloved by many, but it really shouldn't be understated how badly Mowbray performed and how nonsensical his team selections and game management were.
Been having this exact debate on X myself. It's been clear for a while that many of the players have looked confused and uncomfortable with what's been asked of them. I'd expect the stronger in the group to question once a losing run takes hold.
However, what isn't acceptable is doing it in public, this should be thrashed out behind closed doors.
What is also unacceptable is stopping the effort. Yiu can still fight for the ball, track runners and play with some bollocks.
So manager and players have responsibility for the shocking end to the season.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
I think we are getting skewed here. Do we have some players who will down tools if not poked with a sharp stick from time to time? I'd say so.
Is Darnell Furlong one of them? Not a chance. The guy gives his all. He was the one given a stupid ball by Bartley at Cov (leading to the 2nd). He was the one angry at getting beaten (pushed, maybe), for the first yesterday. Anger, bewilderment and frustration do not make him a wrong 'un.
Posts: 10,539
Threads: 487
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
28
(04-22-2025, 12:47 PM)richbaggie Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:14 PM)Squid Wrote: On social media, all the talk is of the players having seen off yet another manager, despite most of them not having been here that long.
However, one comment stood out for me. Apparently Furlong was seen arguing with Mark Venus in the dugout and this is apparently outrageous, because Furlong should know his place (I'm paraphrasing).
But actually, I don't blame Furlong for questioning what was happening, because presumably he, like anyone else with functioning eyesight could see that the set up of the team yesterday was a total mess and we were being overrun and out thought by Derby County.
And that maybe, Furlong saying something about it, as opposed to just watching silently is a sign that he cares. Overall, he's been a decent player for us. Good patches and bad (hence he's in the Championship), but rarely looks like he phones it in.
I get why people (including local media) are keener to point the finger at players as opposed to a departed manager who is beloved by many, but it really shouldn't be understated how badly Mowbray performed and how nonsensical his team selections and game management were.
Been having this exact debate on X myself. It's been clear for a while that many of the players have looked confused and uncomfortable with what's been asked of them. I'd expect the stronger in the group to question once a losing run takes hold.
However, what isn't acceptable is doing it in public, this should be thrashed out behind closed doors.
What is also unacceptable is stopping the effort. Yiu can still fight for the ball, track runners and play with some bollocks.
So manager and players have responsibility for the shocking end to the season.
Hallelujah
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(04-22-2025, 12:45 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:38 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:32 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:25 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Can you not think it’s both?
I certainly do.
Mowbray was a disaster. He looked clueless, broken and tired. A really bad appointment.
But there are a current crop of 4/5 players that have been here a while that have seen off countless managers and are often found wanting when the going gets tough.
How come the going didn't get tough when we had a proper manager?
It did though didn’t it? Questions were started to be asked of Carlos and why we kept drawing games. Questions were asked after our no show in the play offs last season. Rightly or wrongly.
Also, Carlos is an entity we’re unlikely to get that calibre of manager again any time soon. Just look at what he’s done with the Spanish giant he now resides over.
I can’t wait for some young up and comer to come in and get told by Bart’s and the boys they’re not buying in to his methods or some unheard of foreigner to come in for Furlong to not understand what he’s putting across.
Results, yes, but at no stage did we have multiple threads per day on here and people all over Twitter questioning the application of the players.
There was a thread on here about sacking Carlos and there were a number of posts saying that the players were still giving their all for him.
Fair. For me, personally, I’ve just seen enough from a few of our longer serving players that makes me question them when things get hard.
The recruitment of Bany, Price, Diakite gives me hope we can fully transition the squad over the next couple of years and fully rebuild our squad, identity and team attitude.
I must be the only person on here that thinks Bartley getting another year (appearance related I know) is not great. The news of Swift and Grady leaving is better though.
Don't think that's too unreasonable. It's all the more frustrating Valencia came calling when they did because it actually did look like we'd turned a corner, we'd gone through a slump and had started to come out the other side. The performance against Bristol City at home was lightyears ahead of anything we've seen since. Whether you agree or disagree, modern football requires a far greater coaching input that just a rousing team talk. Hence why there was so much concern at the Wallace "everything is relaxed" interview, the "I'm not going to tell you where to pass" comments and the general disrespect that Mowbray showed towards his far superior predecessor.
Agree on some of the new additions and even Bartley. As a senior pro to mentor another younger first choice centre-half, Heggem (who has played his best games alongside Bartley) and Taylor I don't mind it. I will be revising my opinions of those in charge of our recruitment should Bartley be stood wearing the captains armband in our first game of next season however. It would be borderline gross negligence (or the injury crisis from hell) if he makes more than ten apps for us next year.
Posts: 8,006
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
The Furlong improvement under Corberan was dramatic, as has been his demise since he left. Suggests he's a player who responds well to one on one management and a clear plan. Just because he's a senior pro, does not mean he can go uncoached, so understand his frustration.
Let's be honest, none of the players improved under Mowbray, so it can't just be down to a few bad apples.
I do think certain old pros need to be moved on though, Bartley and Swift look lazy and disinterested and, for all his effort and personality, Jed's best days are behind him, whilst Grady has been on a steady decline and doesn't look happy.
Other than that, I think the rest, including Furlong, have enough redeeming features to be given another chance with a better coach. Just further endorses how important it is to get the next one right.
Posts: 945
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
(04-22-2025, 12:45 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:38 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:32 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (04-22-2025, 12:25 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Can you not think it’s both?
I certainly do.
Mowbray was a disaster. He looked clueless, broken and tired. A really bad appointment.
But there are a current crop of 4/5 players that have been here a while that have seen off countless managers and are often found wanting when the going gets tough.
How come the going didn't get tough when we had a proper manager?
It did though didn’t it? Questions were started to be asked of Carlos and why we kept drawing games. Questions were asked after our no show in the play offs last season. Rightly or wrongly.
Also, Carlos is an entity we’re unlikely to get that calibre of manager again any time soon. Just look at what he’s done with the Spanish giant he now resides over.
I can’t wait for some young up and comer to come in and get told by Bart’s and the boys they’re not buying in to his methods or some unheard of foreigner to come in for Furlong to not understand what he’s putting across.
Results, yes, but at no stage did we have multiple threads per day on here and people all over Twitter questioning the application of the players.
There was a thread on here about sacking Carlos and there were a number of posts saying that the players were still giving their all for him.
Fair. For me, personally, I’ve just seen enough from a few of our longer serving players that makes me question them when things get hard.
The recruitment of Bany, Price, Diakite gives me hope we can fully transition the squad over the next couple of years and fully rebuild our squad, identity and team attitude.
I must be the only person on here that thinks Bartley getting another year (appearance related I know) is not great. The news of Swift and Grady leaving is better though. You aren’t, I also think he should be gone sooner rather than later. One of our poorest CHs in a long time, no apparent signs of leadership or responsibility, absolutely no goal threat at set pieces despite often being the biggest player on the park and often too slow to mark his attacker.
|