A counter opinion to the current wave of player blame
#1
On social media, all the talk is of the players having seen off yet another manager, despite most of them not having been here that long.

However, one comment stood out for me. Apparently Furlong was seen arguing with Mark Venus in the dugout and this is apparently outrageous, because Furlong should know his place (I'm paraphrasing).

But actually, I don't blame Furlong for questioning what was happening, because presumably he, like anyone else with functioning eyesight could see that the set up of the team yesterday was a total mess and we were being overrun and out thought by Derby County. 

And that maybe, Furlong saying something about it, as opposed to just watching silently is a sign that he cares. Overall, he's been a decent player for us. Good patches and bad (hence he's in the Championship), but rarely looks like he phones it in.

I get why people (including local media) are keener to point the finger at players as opposed to a departed manager who is beloved by many, but it really shouldn't be understated how badly Mowbray performed and how nonsensical his team selections and game management were.
Reply
#2
Absolutely. Don't know how many times it needs pointing out before the penny drops, but we never, ever had these sort of threads when Carlos was in charge.
Reply
#3
Can you not think it’s both?

I certainly do.

Mowbray was a disaster. He looked clueless, broken and tired. A really bad appointment.

But there are a current crop of 4/5 players that have been here a while that have seen off countless managers and are often found wanting when the going gets tough.
Reply
#4
Some fans and local media are just looking to blame the players because it’s easier than criticising the former manager because they liked him.
Reply
#5
(04-22-2025, 12:25 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Can you not think it’s both?

I certainly do.

Mowbray was a disaster. He looked clueless, broken and tired. A really bad appointment.

But there are a current crop of 4/5 players that have been here a while that have seen off countless managers and are often found wanting when the going gets tough.

How come the going didn't get tough when we had a proper manager?
Reply
#6
(04-22-2025, 12:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Some fans and local media are just looking to blame the players because it’s easier than criticising the former manager because they liked him.

I’ve not seen a single person on here or online that has said the decision to relieve Mowbray of his duties was the incorrect one. 

I’ve seen people rightly question the commitment, desire and integrity of a few of our long servers for their role in what’s petered out to be a dismal season.
Reply
#7
(04-22-2025, 12:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Some fans and local media are just looking to blame the players because it’s easier than criticising the former manager because they liked him.

100% this. The love for Mowbray bemused and still bemuses me. Lovely man that he is, look at 5 wins in 18 games, look at what he has won over the past 17 years, talk to Celtic or Blackburn fans about him.

The players haven't helped him much though tbh. Tho they were certainly helping him at Leeds and Burnley away.
Reply
#8
It's pretty clear that the former manager is the root cause of this shit show. No doubt about it. And the "Bottlejobs", "Lazy", "Toxic" bullshit arguments being banded about are largely a desperate attempt for people to hide behind as they either were fiercely defending Old Tony just a few weeks back, or they have so much nostalgic warm feelings for him that they can't see the reality.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#9
(04-22-2025, 12:27 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(04-22-2025, 12:25 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Can you not think it’s both?

I certainly do.

Mowbray was a disaster. He looked clueless, broken and tired. A really bad appointment.

But there are a current crop of 4/5 players that have been here a while that have seen off countless managers and are often found wanting when the going gets tough.

How come the going didn't get tough when we had a proper manager?

It did though didn’t it? Questions were started to be asked of Carlos and why we kept drawing games. Questions were asked after our no show in the play offs last season. Rightly or wrongly. 

Also, Carlos is an entity we’re unlikely to get that calibre of manager again any time soon. Just look at what he’s done with the Spanish giant he now resides over. 

I can’t wait for some young up and comer to come in and get told by Bart’s and the boys they’re not buying in to his methods or some unheard of foreigner to come in for Furlong to not understand what he’s putting across.
Reply
#10
(04-22-2025, 12:29 PM)Dumbo Wrote:
(04-22-2025, 12:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Some fans and local media are just looking to blame the players because it’s easier than criticising the former manager because they liked him.

I’ve not seen a single person on here or online that has said the decision to relieve Mowbray of his duties was the correct one. 

I’ve seen people rightly question the commitment, desire and integrity of a few of our long servers for their role in what’s petered out to be a dismal season.

Eh?  Is there a word missing here?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)