Posts: 559
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
Val has done absolutely nothing since he left, and barely did anything whilst he was here.
The bloke was an absolute fraud of a manager. Somehow he cost us £2m as well.
Posts: 5,323
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
And on the question of Dyche and Cooper.
Certainly not Dyche. He's spent so long fighting fires on the premiership, he has probably lost the ability to play consisting winning football, which is what you need to get promotion
Plus by the end of his tenure at Everton he looked beaten and exhausted.
Cooper would be a better bet. He whines too much about refs for my liking, but he did a fantastic job at Forest.
Would he take the job. He was sacked a matter of months after starting his last job. A job where patience was key because there was so much that needed to change. Would he want to take a job with a club who have just sacked their manager a matter of months after starting, where again patience was key. I would imagine he might have better options this summer.
Posts: 17,082
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
04-22-2025, 07:57 AM
(This post was last modified: 04-22-2025, 08:02 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(04-22-2025, 07:42 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-21-2025, 09:31 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: They’ll get us out this league with whatever they’re given.
I’ve never been one for the beautiful game bollox.
Win games and fans are happy. Lose games fans aren’t happy.
Our best managers in the modern era haven’t played lovely football as they didn’t have the players to do it and neither will an incoming manager.
Hodgson Megson Pulis - all got the last drip out of average players.
Dyche will.
Cooper will. Cooper also has a record of developing young talent.
I don’t want experiments
I don’t want glamourous trendy appointments.
I want someone who will win. These two will win more than they lose.
Not read thread, so this point may have already been made.
The implication is that Megson inherited an under performing squad of players and turned them into a promotion winning team.
That's not what happened. When we best Palace to clinch promotion only 2 players were at the club before Megson arrived. A massive turnover of players in just 2 years.
And in championship he didn't buy average players, he bought very good championship players, ones capable of being in a team that could be promoted.
Hard to compare players from different generations, but all things being equal, players like Balis, Clement, Moore, Gilchrist, Siggurdson, McIness were better than what we have today. Probably Hoult and Taylor too .
It's a fundamental misremembering of the first Megson promotion. He did have money to spend and he spent it wisely.
Completely disagree .
Take a look at our wage bill, our net spend it was nowhere near those in the top six, it was closer to 12th-15th in the league as far as my memory serves me.
Clement was a free after a loan from Chelsea.
Balis was a cheap import
Glichrist was a Champ player
Moore was decent and known
Siggurdson was a Champ player from Stoke
McInness was signed from the French league
Taylor was in the last few years of his career
None of these players cost anywhere near what Man City and Wolves were spending at the time. No one gave us a chance at the start of the season for promotion other than our own fans. That team was built on hard work and organisation rather than out spending the rest of the division which is what did in subsequent years.
Posts: 1,239
Threads: 76
Joined: Feb 2025
Reputation:
4
Megson said summat like he could go and get loads of footballers but what he wanted were winners.
Posts: 5,323
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(04-22-2025, 07:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-22-2025, 07:42 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-21-2025, 09:31 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: They’ll get us out this league with whatever they’re given.
I’ve never been one for the beautiful game bollox.
Win games and fans are happy. Lose games fans aren’t happy.
Our best managers in the modern era haven’t played lovely football as they didn’t have the players to do it and neither will an incoming manager.
Hodgson Megson Pulis - all got the last drip out of average players.
Dyche will.
Cooper will. Cooper also has a record of developing young talent.
I don’t want experiments
I don’t want glamourous trendy appointments.
I want someone who will win. These two will win more than they lose.
Not read thread, so this point may have already been made.
The implication is that Megson inherited an under performing squad of players and turned them into a promotion winning team.
That's not what happened. When we best Palace to clinch promotion only 2 players were at the club before Megson arrived. A massive turnover of players in just 2 years.
And in championship he didn't buy average players, he bought very good championship players, ones capable of being in a team that could be promoted.
Hard to compare players from different generations, but all things being equal, players like Balis, Clement, Moore, Gilchrist, Siggurdson, McIness were better than what we have today. Probably Hoult and Taylor too .
It's a fundamental misremembering of the first Megson promotion. He did have money to spend and he spent it wisely.
Completely disagree .
Take a look at our wage bill, our net spend it was nowhere near those in the top six, it was closer to 12th-15th in the league as far as my memory serves me.
Clement was a free after a loan from Chelsea.
Balis was a cheap import
Glichrist was a Champ player
Moore was decent and known
Siggurdson was a Champ player from Stoke
McInness was signed from the French league
Taylor was in the last few years of his career
None of these players cost anywhere near what Man City and Wolves were spending at the time. No one gave us a chance at the start of the season for promotion other than our own fans. That team was built on hard work and organisation rather than out spending the rest of the division which is what did in subsequent years.
I think you are being very unfair to Megson and his players.
The implication you make is that Megson wasted money on average players, he didn't.
But you are missing the main point. The OP seemed to imply that Megson inherited a squad of average players and made them better. He didn't, he realised the players he inherited weren't good enough, were never going to be good enough and replaced them.
Or are you going to pretend that didn't happen
Posts: 17,082
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-22-2025, 08:10 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-22-2025, 07:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-22-2025, 07:42 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-21-2025, 09:31 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: They’ll get us out this league with whatever they’re given.
I’ve never been one for the beautiful game bollox.
Win games and fans are happy. Lose games fans aren’t happy.
Our best managers in the modern era haven’t played lovely football as they didn’t have the players to do it and neither will an incoming manager.
Hodgson Megson Pulis - all got the last drip out of average players.
Dyche will.
Cooper will. Cooper also has a record of developing young talent.
I don’t want experiments
I don’t want glamourous trendy appointments.
I want someone who will win. These two will win more than they lose.
Not read thread, so this point may have already been made.
The implication is that Megson inherited an under performing squad of players and turned them into a promotion winning team.
That's not what happened. When we best Palace to clinch promotion only 2 players were at the club before Megson arrived. A massive turnover of players in just 2 years.
And in championship he didn't buy average players, he bought very good championship players, ones capable of being in a team that could be promoted.
Hard to compare players from different generations, but all things being equal, players like Balis, Clement, Moore, Gilchrist, Siggurdson, McIness were better than what we have today. Probably Hoult and Taylor too .
It's a fundamental misremembering of the first Megson promotion. He did have money to spend and he spent it wisely.
Completely disagree .
Take a look at our wage bill, our net spend it was nowhere near those in the top six, it was closer to 12th-15th in the league as far as my memory serves me.
Clement was a free after a loan from Chelsea.
Balis was a cheap import
Glichrist was a Champ player
Moore was decent and known
Siggurdson was a Champ player from Stoke
McInness was signed from the French league
Taylor was in the last few years of his career
None of these players cost anywhere near what Man City and Wolves were spending at the time. No one gave us a chance at the start of the season for promotion other than our own fans. That team was built on hard work and organisation rather than out spending the rest of the division which is what did in subsequent years.
I think you are being very unfair to Megson and his players.
The implication you make is that Megson wasted money on average players, he didn't.
But you are missing the main point. The OP seemed to imply that Megson inherited a squad of average players and made them better. He didn't, he realised the players he inherited weren't good enough, were never going to be good enough and replaced them.
Or are you going to pretend that didn't happen
I’m not implying that at all, Megson was and is the only manager in the last 30yrs I’d put on a pedestal above all others.
Those players were shrewd buys but they didn’t cost anywhere near what our rivals were paying for players that season and man for man our squad wasn’t as talented as others but its work rate and organisation was above and beyond all of our competitors that season. He got rid of some poor players and replaced with honest, talented and hardworking players but he got the very best out of a limited squad, to argue otherwise is incorrect.
You seem to be suggesting we bought the most sought after and talented players in that season we didn’t, GM put together a hardworking team that had talent but it was their willingness to put their bodies on the line and work as a team that made us succeed beyond the individual talent within the squad. You didn’t write for Grorty Dick did you?  He bought players in yes, but he didn’t buy success, he managed the rebuild on a relative shoestring even with the Egiogh (Spelling) money.
Posts: 8,006
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
Megson bought in players in his own image, who would work with his philosophy and approach. That never give in mentality, similar to Pulis. It was this mentality that allowed us to catch the shit. The football wasn't always great, but, technically, we were underdogs and all in it together, so who gave a shit. He really was exactly what we needed at that time. We went from a mid to lower table club with no genuine promotion prospects, to top 2 in no time at all. Even the play off defeat didn't derail us, if anything, it galvanised us.
That's what we need now, someone to pull all the parts together, players, owners, tea lady and, especially, us the fans. We need to start believing again.
I don't think Dyche is that man, he was to Burnley what Megson was to us and I can't see him having it in him to do it again.
Cooper's a bit different as his time at Forest was more fleeting, so maybe still has a point to prove.
What MUST happen, however, is for the powers that be to look at the players that will be left, what potential targets are lined up and what they want their strategy and philosophy to look like, and then find someone who fits the bill. It may not be a name we know, it may not be trendy, it may not even be universally popular, Megson was none of those things, but, boy, did we get that one right. We need those planets to align again.
Posts: 19,496
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Have said before on several threads, I don’t want someone who’s been there and done it before - other than Roy, who was a 1 in a million bloke - it has not worked for us. I want a manager who is chasing his first promotion, one who will be doing everything in his power to get this club into the PL, who has no “this is what worked previously” to fall back on.
Cooper probably would be a decent appointment, but we have to set parameters now. In the same way we walk away from potentially good signings on paper due to age or attitude, I want the same employed here. Our next manager has to be someone on the way up, someone who may make a mistake or two, but learns from it and will damn we’ll ensure that the players in our squad learn and adapt quickly too. No more pandering to older, experienced players.
Posts: 27,985
Threads: 1,168
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
64
(04-22-2025, 07:57 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-22-2025, 07:42 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (04-21-2025, 09:31 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: They’ll get us out this league with whatever they’re given.
I’ve never been one for the beautiful game bollox.
Win games and fans are happy. Lose games fans aren’t happy.
Our best managers in the modern era haven’t played lovely football as they didn’t have the players to do it and neither will an incoming manager.
Hodgson Megson Pulis - all got the last drip out of average players.
Dyche will.
Cooper will. Cooper also has a record of developing young talent.
I don’t want experiments
I don’t want glamourous trendy appointments.
I want someone who will win. These two will win more than they lose.
Not read thread, so this point may have already been made.
The implication is that Megson inherited an under performing squad of players and turned them into a promotion winning team.
That's not what happened. When we best Palace to clinch promotion only 2 players were at the club before Megson arrived. A massive turnover of players in just 2 years.
And in championship he didn't buy average players, he bought very good championship players, ones capable of being in a team that could be promoted.
Hard to compare players from different generations, but all things being equal, players like Balis, Clement, Moore, Gilchrist, Siggurdson, McIness were better than what we have today. Probably Hoult and Taylor too .
It's a fundamental misremembering of the first Megson promotion. He did have money to spend and he spent it wisely.
Completely disagree .
Take a look at our wage bill, our net spend it was nowhere near those in the top six, it was closer to 12th-15th in the league as far as my memory serves me.
Clement was a free after a loan from Chelsea.
Balis was a cheap import
Glichrist was a Champ player
Moore was decent and known
Siggurdson was a Champ player from Stoke
McInness was signed from the French league
Taylor was in the last few years of his career
None of these players cost anywhere near what Man City and Wolves were spending at the time. No one gave us a chance at the start of the season for promotion other than our own fans. That team was built on hard work and organisation rather than out spending the rest of the division which is what did in subsequent years.
Not disagreeing that we spent far less than our competitors but there are a few omissions here.
Roberts cost £2m (record signing at the time I think), Dichio was over £1m. Players like Hoult, Johnson, Appleton, Jordao, Gilchrist, Moore, Siggy, etc were all signed for six figure sums.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Cooper wouldn't be the end of the world, his record in the promotion season with Forest was outrageous.
P39 W23 D10 L6 Pts 79 - 2.02ppg worth 93 points over the course of a full season. I'd sooner him than Dyche certainly.
|