I’m keeping it simple: Cooper or Dyche
#11
Pulis.....ffs. If that fecker is the answer, what's the question?

Who would want to see that type of football again?

Dyche comes across as a good bloke, but his football is awful. Like Pulis, too long trying to keep a team up, forgets how to get a team promoted.
Reply
#12
Neither please.  There's no point in getting up by the skin of our teeth if we are lucky, and being fucked over week-in wee-out like Southampton.  And that's what you would get with either of these or the other journeymen managers who specialise in doing just that. 

I'd rather look abroad for someone who can build a team that plays half decent football and has an identity.  It might take a year or three but just getting up playing Dyche style football only to come down again battered and bruised is not progress. 

If you think Dyche is a good coach take a look at his Everton results and then take a look at David Moyes' results.
Reply
#13
For both it would be a step down and they are typical of the type of managers who we have had here.

We need a young manager on the way up, ideally one who has some experience of League One

Look at Edwards or Mousinho
Reply
#14
I'd prefer Gruffer voice to Cooper.

What I want, what I really really want, is a "young foreigner unknown" with an impressive short record and modern techniques and isn't frightened to call Bartley a cnut and he's dropped cause he's shit.
Reply
#15
Neither, thanks.
Reply
#16
Either & ASAP thanks!!.
Reply
#17
Neither, surely we are looking for a coach rather than a traditional manager? All this talk of manager moulding their own teams is bobbins, they will have input I imagine but Nestor and Pearce will e in charge of recruitment. I read and listen to people say managers need tine to build their own team, whilst scratching my head at the disconnect with regards to how we as a club are now set-up and the fact it’ll never be a case of ‘their team’, whoever comes in will have to accept they are head coach not a manager and I don’t see Dyche particularly in that role.
Reply
#18
Dyche is also very much an "old pro's" type of manager too. Guarantee his first signing would be someone like Ashley Barnes. I really do think Bilkul want to see a steady stream of youth coming through.

I'd favour Cooper in that respect. He won the U17 world cup with England but even then I'm struggling to remember his club sides and how many youngsters he bought through....

I think we will see a Wicky type appointment personally.
Reply
#19
(04-21-2025, 09:31 PM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: They’ll get us out this league with whatever they’re given. 

I’ve never been one for the beautiful game bollox. 

Win games and fans are happy. Lose games fans aren’t happy. 

Our best managers in the modern era haven’t played lovely football as they didn’t have the players to do it and neither will an incoming manager. 

Hodgson Megson Pulis - all got the last drip out of average players. 

Dyche will. 
Cooper will. Cooper also has a record of developing young talent. 

I don’t want experiments 
I don’t want glamourous trendy appointments. 

I want someone who will win. These two will win more than they lose.

Not read thread, so this point may have already been made.

The implication is that Megson inherited an under performing squad of players and turned them into a promotion winning team.

That's not what happened. When we best Palace to clinch promotion only 2 players were at the club before Megson arrived. A massive turnover of players in just 2 years.

And in championship he didn't buy average players, he bought very good championship players, ones capable of being in a team that could be promoted.

Hard to compare players from different generations, but all things being equal, players like Balis, Clement, Moore, Gilchrist, Siggurdson, McIness were better than what we have today. Probably Hoult and Taylor too .

It's a fundamental misremembering of the first Megson promotion. He did have money to spend and he spent it wisely.
Reply
#20
If Cooper or Dyche rocked up soon 
It would be an enormous boon
Happy days 
And to coin a phrase 
I’d be over the f*****g moon
Being brutally honest 
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: