Worst appointment ever?
#31
I despise Pardew but I would put this on a par.

Both clueless and looked like they had no idea what to do to improve things.
Reply
#32
(04-21-2025, 04:48 PM)Mullers Wrote:
(04-21-2025, 04:43 PM)HLS Wrote: If Fat Sam had the entire season, we'd have had a chance of staying up. We looked competitive after we'd signed a few in Jan.

I remember reading a very detailed rumour (emphasis on rumour) that rather than Big Sam galvanising the players, it was Maitland-Niles who called a team meeting very early on into his short tenure. After this, performances and results picked up. Again, this was just a rumour, and I think it was from the other site, but I do question how much of our improved form was actually Big Sam’s doing.

It wasn't a rumour, it was openly reported in the Athletic, back in the days when they covered the Albion properly.

Pardew will always be worse, as he got a decent team relegated, and we haven't recovered from that since.

Mowbray sadly much, much worse than Bruce though. He's dismantled a well-functioning team and made us worse on every level.
Reply
#33
(04-21-2025, 09:11 PM)Squid Wrote:
(04-21-2025, 04:48 PM)Mullers Wrote:
(04-21-2025, 04:43 PM)HLS Wrote: If Fat Sam had the entire season, we'd have had a chance of staying up. We looked competitive after we'd signed a few in Jan.

I remember reading a very detailed rumour (emphasis on rumour) that rather than Big Sam galvanising the players, it was Maitland-Niles who called a team meeting very early on into his short tenure. After this, performances and results picked up. Again, this was just a rumour, and I think it was from the other site, but I do question how much of our improved form was actually Big Sam’s doing.

It wasn't a rumour, it was openly reported in the Athletic, back in the days when they covered the Albion properly.

Pardew will always be worse, as he got a decent team relegated, and we haven't recovered from that since.

Mowbray sadly much, much worse than Bruce though. He's dismantled a well-functioning team and made us worse on every level.

Yep, it did happen.

Big Sam was a failure, but he did point out everything wrong at the club and it was all spot on.
Reply
#34
Little was horrendous, but Burkinshaw deserves an honorable mention for being the most depressing black hole shit pit of human misery, ever.

Pardew though, I hate to think how many years it will take to repair the damage he did.


Shite. I just remembered Talbot. Christ.
Reply
#35
Talbot started well ("Talbot is our man" etc)
Reply
#36
Lots of posts applying hindsight.

I disliked Pardew as much as anyone but when he was appointed, I was curious and wondered how he would do. Admittedly, I didn't know how obnoxious he was.
With Gould, Little and Mowbray it was " Oh FFS, no, what a disaster".
Reply
#37
(04-21-2025, 04:36 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: Struggling to think of a worse appointment than Mowbray. There's been a few headscratchers - Irvine, Pardew for example.

Fat Sam was a gamble, although sceptical, I was happy to live with it.

I wasn't delighted by Bruce but was happy to see how he got on, given the number of promotions that he'd achieved.

The only 2 other manager appointments where I've thought " he's shit and won't last 5 minutes" are Gould and Little.

A poverty of ambition is what I said about Mowbray. Worse than the fact that he has inevitably failed, is that we have another year in this shit league and another years delay to Nestor's masterpiece being realised.

Ultimately, this is on Nestor. Mowbray is just being himself.

Worst appointment? Robson and Gould and boy, there are so many more.....
Reply
#38
As much as Robson was clueless he did somehow jaxy his way to The Great Escape and therefore doesn't warrant inclusion in the top 5.

I'll wait until calmer heads have considered their opinion but, tonight, Mowbray2.0 feels worse than Pardew and Bruce but slightly better than Barmy Bobby... but that might be on personality alone.  Mowbray's dismantling of a functional team has been astounding, very few could have predicted it being this bad.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#39
Managers you could forsee would be an absolute disaster:

Robson.....appointed on sentiment with an awful managerial CV

Gould....we all knew, didn't we?

Fat Sam....Never turns a team around quickly and the season stats don't lie.
Reply
#40
You are right about Robson. He had to be rescued at Boro...was it by El Tel? But I didn't think it would be disaster like the other 3 I named. You are right though, sentimentality meant I had hope for him.

Fair play to Fat Sam for having a go. made it clear that the club had no ambition and he wasn't going to stay. I didn't think that he would be a disaster.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)