Posts: 1,816
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(04-21-2025, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-21-2025, 06:54 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Subjective Lurker.
When CC left we were 7th. The squad is 5th-10th, 5th if everything went our way and 10th if it didn’t. We’ve had a lot of injuries and quite a few decisions go the wrong way.
CC is a cut or two above this level and he was battling to make us top 6. Last season it took to the last game of the season and then Russell Martin had our pants down because the only way we could play was easy for him to counter. We lost our best 2 players and haven’t replaced them and this season we were struggling to keep up with the top 6. TM is a lesser manager than CC and whoever else we’ll get most likely will be too. Therefore the squad isn’t good enough.
Even if what you say is true, which I don’t agree with and your opinion is as subjective as mine, a managers job is to maximise points out of the squad at his disposal. Megson’s first promotion squad was nowhere near the quality of Wolves or many of the playoff contenders that season but GM compensated by making us hard to beat and better than the sum of our parts, this clearly didn’t happen under TM and there is no evidence it would ever have been possible under his management.
(04-21-2025, 07:19 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (04-21-2025, 05:25 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-21-2025, 05:21 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: In the 16 game run CC was on before he left:
W 3
D 10
L 3
19 points from 16 games. Thats a side heading straight for mid table, we all got fooled by winning 5 out the first 6. We’ve not shown anything like that since, under anyone. And we were 7th when he left.
It’s not just TM that’s a problem here.
For the first time since he’s been here he actually spoke sense post match. He talked about character and players failing to step up. He’s right, we lack leadership.
TM not working out doesn’t absolve the players of criticism, there’s a core that have done this to several managers and need moving on, whether TM stays is a different question.
Absolutely correct.
Some people think a change of manager and all is rosey in the World of Albion.
5 years of failure under the core of this squad.
Spot on Dumbo.
Furlong, Holgate , Bartley, Mowatt, Mulumby, Swift, Grady, Wallace, Ajai, Grant.
We were 7th when Carlos left .
It’s not just TM that should be off.
I driving up to Liverpool to take my lad to Uni on Saturday. I’d gladly take Holgate back…. He’s made Matt arbon look like Maldini.
Grant has been one of the best players this season
Fulong has been decent throughout his time with club even if there have been dips in form
Mowatt has been one of our most consistent players all season
Ajayi has been injured
Wallace was used instead of Fellows by TM
Molumby has been decent for most of the season, impetuous and daft sometimes but clearly good enough
We had a worse squad when we were 7th under Corberan and had an injured top scorer, and yet in the last three matches we win two against our play-off rivals comfortably. Contrast that with after CC left… it’s just excuses from those who fail to see past nostalgia.
No excuses just what I see with my own eyes.
Grant was one of the better players for the first third of the season yes but he is an average player.
Furlong has been a good pro but as all players do he has reached the point he won’t get any better.
Ajai, too many injuries I’m afraid needs replacing.
Mowatt, when he is on form he is an effective midfielder who chips in with the odd goal. Too often he doesn’t impact games as he should.
Wallace was only used by TM ahead of Fellows when Fellows was impacted by his Nan’s death. Poor example. Wallace is an honest pro whose legs have gone.
Mulumby, I do like his commitment but how many assists has he this year, he misses easy chances and can’t keep his cool. A squad player if anything for now..
Any comments on the others?
Out of the additions
Lankshear is a kid and was a gamble.
Armstrong failed
Bany, not fit enough , injured but there is a player there. As I’ve said before he is a Grady replacement.
Price is some player but still young.
We need another big refresh this summer.
The next manager will be key as always but we also need a leader on the pitch and we have not had one of those for a long time.
Posts: 17,077
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
04-21-2025, 08:31 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-21-2025, 08:58 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(04-21-2025, 08:18 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (04-21-2025, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-21-2025, 06:54 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Subjective Lurker.
When CC left we were 7th. The squad is 5th-10th, 5th if everything went our way and 10th if it didn’t. We’ve had a lot of injuries and quite a few decisions go the wrong way.
CC is a cut or two above this level and he was battling to make us top 6. Last season it took to the last game of the season and then Russell Martin had our pants down because the only way we could play was easy for him to counter. We lost our best 2 players and haven’t replaced them and this season we were struggling to keep up with the top 6. TM is a lesser manager than CC and whoever else we’ll get most likely will be too. Therefore the squad isn’t good enough.
Even if what you say is true, which I don’t agree with and your opinion is as subjective as mine, a managers job is to maximise points out of the squad at his disposal. Megson’s first promotion squad was nowhere near the quality of Wolves or many of the playoff contenders that season but GM compensated by making us hard to beat and better than the sum of our parts, this clearly didn’t happen under TM and there is no evidence it would ever have been possible under his management.
(04-21-2025, 07:19 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (04-21-2025, 05:25 PM)Dumbo Wrote: (04-21-2025, 05:21 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: In the 16 game run CC was on before he left:
W 3
D 10
L 3
19 points from 16 games. Thats a side heading straight for mid table, we all got fooled by winning 5 out the first 6. We’ve not shown anything like that since, under anyone. And we were 7th when he left.
It’s not just TM that’s a problem here.
For the first time since he’s been here he actually spoke sense post match. He talked about character and players failing to step up. He’s right, we lack leadership.
TM not working out doesn’t absolve the players of criticism, there’s a core that have done this to several managers and need moving on, whether TM stays is a different question.
Absolutely correct.
Some people think a change of manager and all is rosey in the World of Albion.
5 years of failure under the core of this squad.
Spot on Dumbo.
Furlong, Holgate , Bartley, Mowatt, Mulumby, Swift, Grady, Wallace, Ajai, Grant.
We were 7th when Carlos left .
It’s not just TM that should be off.
I driving up to Liverpool to take my lad to Uni on Saturday. I’d gladly take Holgate back…. He’s made Matt arbon look like Maldini.
Grant has been one of the best players this season
Fulong has been decent throughout his time with club even if there have been dips in form
Mowatt has been one of our most consistent players all season
Ajayi has been injured
Wallace was used instead of Fellows by TM
Molumby has been decent for most of the season, impetuous and daft sometimes but clearly good enough
We had a worse squad when we were 7th under Corberan and had an injured top scorer, and yet in the last three matches we win two against our play-off rivals comfortably. Contrast that with after CC left… it’s just excuses from those who fail to see past nostalgia.
No excuses just what I see with my own eyes.
Grant was one of the better players for the first third of the season yes but he is an average player.
Furlong has been a good pro but as all players do he has reached the point he won’t get any better.
Ajai, too many injuries I’m afraid needs replacing.
Mowatt, when he is on form he is an effective midfielder who chips in with the odd goal. Too often he doesn’t impact games as he should.
Wallace was only used by TM ahead of Fellows when Fellows was impacted by his Nan’s death. Poor example. Wallace is an honest pro whose legs have gone.
Mulumby, I do like his commitment but how many assists has he this year, he misses easy chances and can’t keep his cool. A squad player if anything for now..
Any comments on the others?
Out of the additions
Lankshear is a kid and was a gamble.
Armstrong failed
Bany, not fit enough , injured but there is a player there. As I’ve said before he is a Grady replacement.
Price is some player but still young.
We need another big refresh this summer.
The next manager will be key as always but we also need a leader on the pitch and we have not had one of those for a long time.
Armstrong failed because of TM’s tactics
Grant was dropped by TM despite having a good season
Furlong and the entire defence look poor after having TM managing them.
Posts: 612
Threads: 53
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
I keep banging on that a manager is everything and football players know a good coach to a bad coach.All players be it if there limited or not need guidance,discipline and a plan for each match they go into.I saw all of these things under Corberan but none unfortunately under Mowbray.
Take Furlong for example under Corberan’s tenure,he was solid ,positionally sound and it was obvious he had faith in the Corberan plan.In comes Mowbray and he’s like a little boy lost.Obviously there are always the ones who weren’t regulars under Corberan who spoke out like Wallace did about how regimented it was but I’d rather that than what I’ve witnessed since.
Posts: 1,816
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(04-21-2025, 08:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-21-2025, 08:18 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (04-21-2025, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-21-2025, 06:54 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Subjective Lurker.
When CC left we were 7th. The squad is 5th-10th, 5th if everything went our way and 10th if it didn’t. We’ve had a lot of injuries and quite a few decisions go the wrong way.
CC is a cut or two above this level and he was battling to make us top 6. Last season it took to the last game of the season and then Russell Martin had our pants down because the only way we could play was easy for him to counter. We lost our best 2 players and haven’t replaced them and this season we were struggling to keep up with the top 6. TM is a lesser manager than CC and whoever else we’ll get most likely will be too. Therefore the squad isn’t good enough.
Even if what you say is true, which I don’t agree with and your opinion is as subjective as mine, a managers job is to maximise points out of the squad at his disposal. Megson’s first promotion squad was nowhere near the quality of Wolves or many of the playoff contenders that season but GM compensated by making us hard to beat and better than the sum of our parts, this clearly didn’t happen under TM and there is no evidence it would ever have been possible under his management.
(04-21-2025, 07:19 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (04-21-2025, 05:25 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Absolutely correct.
Some people think a change of manager and all is rosey in the World of Albion.
5 years of failure under the core of this squad.
Spot on Dumbo.
Furlong, Holgate , Bartley, Mowatt, Mulumby, Swift, Grady, Wallace, Ajai, Grant.
We were 7th when Carlos left .
It’s not just TM that should be off.
I driving up to Liverpool to take my lad to Uni on Saturday. I’d gladly take Holgate back…. He’s made Matt arbon look like Maldini.
Grant has been one of the best players this season
Fulong has been decent throughout his time with club even if there have been dips in form
Mowatt has been one of our most consistent players all season
Ajayi has been injured
Wallace was used instead of Fellows by TM
Molumby has been decent for most of the season, impetuous and daft sometimes but clearly good enough
We had a worse squad when we were 7th under Corberan and had an injured top scorer, and yet in the last three matches we win two against our play-off rivals comfortably. Contrast that with after CC left… it’s just excuses from those who fail to see past nostalgia.
No excuses just what I see with my own eyes.
Grant was one of the better players for the first third of the season yes but he is an average player.
Furlong has been a good pro but as all players do he has reached the point he won’t get any better.
Ajai, too many injuries I’m afraid needs replacing.
Mowatt, when he is on form he is an effective midfielder who chips in with the odd goal. Too often he doesn’t impact games as he should.
Wallace was only used by TM ahead of Fellows when Fellows was impacted by his Nan’s death. Poor example. Wallace is an honest pro whose legs have gone.
Mulumby, I do like his commitment but how many assists has he this year, he misses easy chances and can’t keep his cool. A squad player if anything for now..
Any comments on the others?
Out of the additions
Lankshear is a kid and was a gamble.
Armstrong failed
Bany, not fit enough , injured but there is a player there. As I’ve said before he is a Grady replacement.
Price is some player but still young.
We need another big refresh this summer.
The next manager will be key as always but we also need a leader on the pitch and we have not had one of those for a long time.
Armstrong failed because of TM’s crap tactics
Grant was dropped by TM despite having a good season
Furlong and the entire defence look crap after having TM managing them because he can’t set a team up to defend and never has been able to,
This is a small part of a larger problem in my view.
Micro management worked in making us hard to beat but in my view we struggled more this season to create chances which is why we were drawing so many matches.
We can’t change the past let’s see where we go from here.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(04-21-2025, 09:04 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (04-21-2025, 08:31 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-21-2025, 08:18 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: (04-21-2025, 07:38 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (04-21-2025, 06:54 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: Subjective Lurker.
When CC left we were 7th. The squad is 5th-10th, 5th if everything went our way and 10th if it didn’t. We’ve had a lot of injuries and quite a few decisions go the wrong way.
CC is a cut or two above this level and he was battling to make us top 6. Last season it took to the last game of the season and then Russell Martin had our pants down because the only way we could play was easy for him to counter. We lost our best 2 players and haven’t replaced them and this season we were struggling to keep up with the top 6. TM is a lesser manager than CC and whoever else we’ll get most likely will be too. Therefore the squad isn’t good enough.
Even if what you say is true, which I don’t agree with and your opinion is as subjective as mine, a managers job is to maximise points out of the squad at his disposal. Megson’s first promotion squad was nowhere near the quality of Wolves or many of the playoff contenders that season but GM compensated by making us hard to beat and better than the sum of our parts, this clearly didn’t happen under TM and there is no evidence it would ever have been possible under his management.
(04-21-2025, 07:19 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: Spot on Dumbo.
Furlong, Holgate , Bartley, Mowatt, Mulumby, Swift, Grady, Wallace, Ajai, Grant.
We were 7th when Carlos left .
It’s not just TM that should be off.
I driving up to Liverpool to take my lad to Uni on Saturday. I’d gladly take Holgate back…. He’s made Matt arbon look like Maldini.
Grant has been one of the best players this season
Fulong has been decent throughout his time with club even if there have been dips in form
Mowatt has been one of our most consistent players all season
Ajayi has been injured
Wallace was used instead of Fellows by TM
Molumby has been decent for most of the season, impetuous and daft sometimes but clearly good enough
We had a worse squad when we were 7th under Corberan and had an injured top scorer, and yet in the last three matches we win two against our play-off rivals comfortably. Contrast that with after CC left… it’s just excuses from those who fail to see past nostalgia.
No excuses just what I see with my own eyes.
Grant was one of the better players for the first third of the season yes but he is an average player.
Furlong has been a good pro but as all players do he has reached the point he won’t get any better.
Ajai, too many injuries I’m afraid needs replacing.
Mowatt, when he is on form he is an effective midfielder who chips in with the odd goal. Too often he doesn’t impact games as he should.
Wallace was only used by TM ahead of Fellows when Fellows was impacted by his Nan’s death. Poor example. Wallace is an honest pro whose legs have gone.
Mulumby, I do like his commitment but how many assists has he this year, he misses easy chances and can’t keep his cool. A squad player if anything for now..
Any comments on the others?
Out of the additions
Lankshear is a kid and was a gamble.
Armstrong failed
Bany, not fit enough , injured but there is a player there. As I’ve said before he is a Grady replacement.
Price is some player but still young.
We need another big refresh this summer.
The next manager will be key as always but we also need a leader on the pitch and we have not had one of those for a long time.
Armstrong failed because of TM’s crap tactics
Grant was dropped by TM despite having a good season
Furlong and the entire defence look crap after having TM managing them because he can’t set a team up to defend and never has been able to,
This is a small part of a larger problem in my view.
Micro management worked in making us hard to beat but in my view we struggled more this season to create chances which is why we were drawing so many matches.
We can’t change the past let’s see where we go from here.
Micro management then should have been the starting position. If we had drawn those 5 defeats from the last 6 games we'd be in contention. There was huge arrogance in breezing in dissing the previous style (and our most improved player), then coming out with all that bollix about teaching the players to fall in love with football again.
You can always tell when a manager hasn't a clue. His post game interview bears no semblance to the game everyone else saw. And his subs make no sense. Did anyone at all know their position by the end of the game? Let alone what their job might have been?
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
04-21-2025, 09:28 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-21-2025, 09:29 PM by Squid.)
Not in the mood for Carlos Corberán slander.
Last home matches under him we beat Bristol and Coventry and barely needed to get out of first gear to do so. All players were fit, knew their jobs, worked as a team and were disciplined enough to get the occasional tactical yellow, without ever being close to a red.
But because had periods without scoring many goals, certain fans started belating like certain fans always do and now they want to rewrite history.
FWIW, I've been reading the forums of the teams we've been playing for months. Nearly all of them rate our players (at least pre-match) and most felt very nervous indeed about coming to the Hawthorns. We are absolutely not a mid table Championship side, hence why not a single team about us has taken six points from us these season.
Posts: 4,108
Threads: 50
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
13
(04-21-2025, 09:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Not in the mood for Carlos Corberán slander.
Last home matches under him we beat Bristol and Coventry and barely needed to get out of first gear to do so. All players were fit, knew their jobs, worked as a team and were disciplined enough to get the occasional tactical yellow, without ever being close to a red.
But because had periods without scoring many goals, certain fans started belating like certain fans always do and now they want to rewrite history.
FWIW, I've been reading the forums of the teams we've been playing for months. Nearly all of them rate our players (at least pre-match) and most felt very nervous indeed about coming to the Hawthorns. We are absolutely not a mid table Championship side, hence why not a single team about us has taken six points from us these season.
The evidence always suggests that a lot of fans who do nothing but watch football have absolutely no clue what they're watching.
This Jack Halford biff is Exhibit A.
Posts: 1,816
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(04-21-2025, 09:47 PM)AnelkasBeard Wrote: (04-21-2025, 09:28 PM)Squid Wrote: Not in the mood for Carlos Corberán slander.
Last home matches under him we beat Bristol and Coventry and barely needed to get out of first gear to do so. All players were fit, knew their jobs, worked as a team and were disciplined enough to get the occasional tactical yellow, without ever being close to a red.
But because had periods without scoring many goals, certain fans started belating like certain fans always do and now they want to rewrite history.
FWIW, I've been reading the forums of the teams we've been playing for months. Nearly all of them rate our players (at least pre-match) and most felt very nervous indeed about coming to the Hawthorns. We are absolutely not a mid table Championship side, hence why not a single team about us has taken six points from us these season.
The evidence always suggests that a lot of fans who do nothing but watch football have absolutely no clue what they're watching.
This Jack Halford biff is Exhibit A.
Wow….
I’ve been watching for 45 years now and know exactly what I’m watching.
Let me be very clear, I really rated CC go back and review my previous posts if you want to see evidence of this. With this group of players we were organised hard to beat but didn’t score enough goals even when Maja was fit. At no point have I slandered him as you suggest. What it does say is we were over achieving with his excellent coaching.
What pisses me off is how easily some and it is only some of the squad revert to type. It speaks volumes for their professionalism.
You can agree or not. Quite frankly I don’t give a toss what you think. Your superior attitude to those that may voice a different opinion on what is a forum speaks volumes.
|