I definitely don’t want TM hounded out
#31
(04-19-2025, 01:04 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: The reality is that he has to go.  If he wins the last 3 games it won’t save him from the fact we haven’t made the play-offs and people’s views of him. 

My defence of him as merely been that I don’t think he’s been given a a fair crack from the fans and the criticism and sticks to beat him with haven’t always been justified. Had CC done this there’d be much less criticism. 

Regardless of any of that it’s not worked and it’s best to part now.  I just hope whoever gets the job next meets with more peoples approval from the off otherwise we’ll turn into Watford.

There’s a few points here. The first is that CC wouldn’t have done this because it’s not just been the manner of the defeats but the complete lack of a coherent plan, which was never the issue under CC even when we weren’t winning games. The second is that CC had good will in the bank with us from when he initially took over and steadied the ship.

However, if we had seen the same performances and results in the past few games under CC then 100% the vast majority would be saying that he needs to go and he’s taken us as far as he can.
Reply
#32
Fans can forgive a manager if results are good.

Fans will give a manager more time if performances are good.

Fans will do neither of both results and performances are bad.
Reply
#33
(04-19-2025, 01:04 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: The reality is that he has to go.  If he wins the last 3 games it won’t save him from the fact we haven’t made the play-offs and people’s views of him. 

My defence of him as merely been that I don’t think he’s been given a a fair crack from the fans and the criticism and sticks to beat him with haven’t always been justified. Had CC done this there’d be much less criticism. 

Regardless of any of that it’s not worked and it’s best to part now.  I just hope whoever gets the job next meets with more peoples approval from the off otherwise we’ll turn into Watford.

Really? That might be true if you’re talking about Pulis or Pardew but certainly not TM.
Reply
#34
(04-19-2025, 12:18 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: He won’t be sacked, he will start next season with us, I suspect Nestor will cling to his data driven approach hoping it’ll be proven correct. Personally think it’s an incredibly narrow way to assess a manager.

With regards to his appointment, one of my biggest bugbears supporting WBA for over 40yrs was the messiah like status some of our fans placed on Mowbray and his achievements at the club. It was almost blasphemous to point out the flaws in our tactics, and TM’s managerial style and ahem ‘philosophy’. Achievements were never put into context, genuine and obvious weaknesses in tactics were shouted down, and over the top hype surrounded our West Brazil Albion approach. To be sceptical was to be a traitor, to question was to be shut down and to put things into context was ignored. Even this season we have fans suggesting fans are a disgrace for not buying into the appointment, angry and want to slap fellow fans for daring to be critical. If for nothing else this creates its own problems, that appointing a manager without a connection to the club would do. 

We needed a fresh start with a new, young manager without the baggage of history, without the hype and sentiment that surrounds TM, I don’t know the manager, I don’t want to know any of the players or managers outside of what they do on the pitch, it muddies the water as a supporter. Ultimately a manager will be judged by results and we aren’t getting good ones, with a decent and on the whole hard working squad.

This in spades Derek.

The  January love in made no sense to me whatsoever. It's as if people had forgotten his first time around. Or just wanted to believe......despite him achieving precisely fuck all in the 17 years in between. 

People can have different opinions, fair enough. But the titty babby and childish posts of a couple of people on here were ridiculous.
Reply
#35
(04-19-2025, 12:06 PM)Jacko Wrote: Managers with 2 year contracts don't resign. I still think he'll take the first game of 25/26.

Yep think you might be right. My worry is we do ok in the last 3 games and decide to keep him on. If we're going to change it's almost certainly better to do it at the start of the close season to give them a full pre season and the chance to bring a few players in than desperately scrambling round for someone in November
Reply
#36
I think so DH.

TM has been far, far from blameless but pre-held ideas have meant certain people have jumped on anything to have a pop and have continued this. Price at RB/RWB is the classic one. Ridiculous decision until we played well, now it’s a ridiculous decision again despite there being no alternative option and used against him. He’s played CM twice and both games we’ve been overrun, he’s actually had his better games pushed further up (although he’s never a false 9 ffs).

No allowance for our top scorer being out. Just that we’re a better squad now because we’ve got Lankshear to do that job. He may go on to have a decent career but right now the Championship is too high a level for him. So we’ve got Grant or Armstrong to play up top. And yet he gets slated for doing so.

I gave him some slack initially as we played twice weekly whilst he got to know the squad and who does what etc. so there was always going to be some different picks to CC. Molumby RM is inexcusable!

When he was announced I was unsure, from memory underwhelmed but I thought a relatively safe pair of hands, he’s failed. I’m happy to accept it hasn’t worked but do it fairly. My basis of a safe pair of hands is that his last few jobs (Cov, Sunderland, Blackburn & Blues) has seen him leave them in a better position than when he came in. He won’t get that opportunity here, nor does he deserve it tbh. I’m just dreading him staying and the team being booed off at half time on the first game of the season because it’s 0-0 v Stoke! We’re endangering 25/26 before this season is even over!

Too many people just want to be proven right on an anonymous fans forum - quite sad and pathetic really.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#37
Derby have the second worst away record in the league
Only Plymouth worst
We all know what’s going to happen
He really needs to go before Monday
Reply
#38
Well whatever the results of the final 3 games if he not gone a week after the final game then its pretty sure he'll be here at the start of next season .
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)