Posts: 7,445
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
04-17-2025, 05:34 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-17-2025, 05:37 PM by tHEgLASSdOORS.)
Do you think women (as per this definition) are never at risk from other women in such spaces?
Having worked in women’s prisons, I can tell you women can be every bit as dangerous to other women as men can be.
If statistics showed that trans women were a greater risk to women in such spaces than the norm, you may have a point. But they don’t.
There is quite literally no change in harm reduction.
Posts: 7,714
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
As per this definition. Keep going. Fucking hilarious. You are Jolyon Maugham and I claim my dead fox.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
04-17-2025, 06:13 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-17-2025, 06:20 PM by Lurker#3.)
Unless I am missing a post somewhere, and if I have I apologise.
Not sure anybody has actually suggested that trans women are a threat to women? More the loophole of heinous, bad meaning, men self ID'ing as women to gain access to women only spaces is a risk that may be exploited and seems silly given the binary nature of biological sex and the small proportion of people who are trans women who may be affected by this definition.
(04-17-2025, 04:59 PM)Squid Wrote: (04-17-2025, 03:58 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: (04-17-2025, 03:37 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: This is the problem with political debate more generally. A lot of people want to drag people's opinions into a corner and make them very black and white. .
I personally struggle with 'Trans' as topic, as do many of my queer friends. Much of the literature is spurious surrounding the benefits of gender reassignment surgery, especially for younger people so most of the debate ends up being emotionally driven and closed off as people are scared of being labelled "right wing" or "transphobic".
One of said queer friends had been living as non-binary for a while now but for most of their childhood as a biological female suffering from body dysmorphia was offered all manner of reassignment options, but really no other interventions. She now, at 41, accepted she is a women. But it turns out she had drew the short straw reproductively and her body, hormonally was doing horrific things to her.
She recently had her womb and fallopian tubes removed in some major surgery is on HRT and she said for the first time she's started to feel feminine.
She always says how much she's glad she didn't get led down the trans path, that many in her community were advocating at the time based on their own almost obsession with identity choice. She now is glad she has the chance to be a woman now she's had the right medical intervention.
Just goes to show difficult balancing politics and personal identity can be.
Yet in some of the posts on here would be lumped in with the ridiculous notion that because some with gender identity challenges have committed crimes (shock) the whole community should be portrayed as a risk and treated accordingly. It’s the comfort with that mentality on parts of this thread that is truly disturbing
Ok. Let me clarify something for you.
Not all men are criminals. We know it is a minority of men who are violent or sexually abusive.
Yet we still have single sex spaces to protect women from the men who are abusive.
We also have separate sporting categories because there men have a clear physical advantage over women in some sporting categories.
All the above is pretty uncontentious and few claim that women are discriminating against men for this.
Then we had people saying, my gender identity is that of a woman therefore, I should be allowed into women's single sex spaces.
And increasing numbers of women said...we understand you want to live your lives in the way you see fit, but you are still male.
This means:
You commit male crimes (at the same level of offending as non-trans males)
I (and many women) physically read you as male and you have been raised as a male with male anatomy, which means that I wouldn't feel comfortable with you in women only refuges or hospital wards
You still retain advantages in sports, due to male puberty, so competing against you is unfair.
Also, de-facto self id, where any many can declare he is a women and access single sex spaces is green light to be abused by predatory males, whether trans or not. While self-ID was never officially the law in the UK, it was widely adopted in the NHS and the prison system.
Can you see? It is not about "discriminating against a small number of people", it is about ensuing that women have male free spaces when we need them. The law has spoken and males remain male whichever gender they identify with.
Amen to that, Squid.
Also, I never knew you were female. I apologise wholeheartedly for how many times I have probably called you "lad" in replies
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 11,926
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(04-17-2025, 10:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Not giving a shit about the subjugation of womens' rights is not a legitimate position to take these days.
I'll start with the decriminalisation of rape, the gender pay gap and institutional health inequalities before I get onto toilet cubicles.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 7,445
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Ah yes but the media isn’t whipping the bots up into an oh so transparent frenzy about the real gender issues. I guess you need to scratch beneath the algorithm to find those
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(04-17-2025, 06:34 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (04-17-2025, 10:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Not giving a shit about the subjugation of womens' rights is not a legitimate position to take these days.
I'll start with the decriminalisation of rape, the gender pay gap and institutional health inequalities before I get onto toilet cubicles.
It's not either/or. Our little lady brains can care about both.
However, with regards to your selected areas of concern:
Allowing males into female spaces actually led to rape and sexual assault occurring.
Allowing data to be collected on the basis of gender id, not sex has been really harmful for the veracity of government data:
https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/he...nment-data
Lots of women's healthcare including maternity care is atrocious, pretending biological sex isn't real won't help matters.
I have pointed out real things that have happened. How am I a bot?
Finally, I don't think you can quite understand how offensive it is to be told that there's no such thing as biological sex and any male is a woman because they say so. It reduces being a women to the thoughts in a man's head. And it isn't. I am a woman every day of my life all the time, whether I want to be or not.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
Without trying to drag this into a general Trans debate. But there are lots of different group celebrating this "victory".
Primarily, a large group of women's rights campaigners/feminists. Then lots of other groups of people with their own objections to self ID and it's over representation in public discourse, these range from foaming at the mouth gammons who deny any bloke should be wearing dresses, even though they loved Ziggy Stardust all the way through to "regular", moderate folk who are trying to look out for their kids in the way think is best.
I have my own concerns about the seismic shift we've had as a species in the last 100 years in terms of the way we organise ourselves as communities and the speed at which we have changed the social contract. This is a very small part, but many people have their own very small concern in this matter so it won't go away until we find balance.
So frankly, it is a massive subject, not just for women's right campaigners. As such it's getting a lot of traction.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
04-17-2025, 07:58 PM
(This post was last modified: 04-17-2025, 08:01 PM by Protheroe.)
(04-17-2025, 05:34 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Do you think women (as per this definition) are never at risk from other women in such spaces?
Having worked in women’s prisons, I can tell you women can be every bit as dangerous to other women as men can be.
If statistics showed that trans women were a greater risk to women in such spaces than the norm, you may have a point. But they don’t.
There is quite literally no change in harm reduction.
Jesus wept. This is like when I used to pay defend the indefensible with my dad.
(04-17-2025, 06:34 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (04-17-2025, 10:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Not giving a shit about the subjugation of womens' rights is not a legitimate position to take these days.
I'll start with the decriminalisation of rape, the gender pay gap and institutional health inequalities before I get onto toilet cubicles.
What a bizarre response.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(04-17-2025, 07:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote: (04-17-2025, 05:34 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Do you think women (as per this definition) are never at risk from other women in such spaces?
Having worked in women’s prisons, I can tell you women can be every bit as dangerous to other women as men can be.
If statistics showed that trans women were a greater risk to women in such spaces than the norm, you may have a point. But they don’t.
There is quite literally no change in harm reduction.
Jesus wept. This is like when I used to pay defend the indefensible with my dad.
(04-17-2025, 06:34 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: (04-17-2025, 10:34 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Not giving a shit about the subjugation of womens' rights is not a legitimate position to take these days.
I'll start with the decriminalisation of rape, the gender pay gap and institutional health inequalities before I get onto toilet cubicles.
What a bizarre response.
To be fair you’ve been defending the indefensible for most of your adult Tory supporting life
Posts: 6,720
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
Can't argue with that Dekka
Least worst, still winning, blah blah blah
|