Tom Fellows
#21
I've no idea. But I've no idea why we wouldn't! Especially when he was the one banging the drum about taking the hand breaks off the players and telling us to be more offensively minded!

(04-13-2025, 04:17 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 03:59 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 02:00 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 09:09 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: He was bombed out by TM. Let that sink in.

More nonsense.
Let the fact that your post is baseless and without merit sink in.

He's been in the squad the last few weeks but hasn't been given the starting position or much game time, despite match situations desperately crying out for what Tomm offers. Instead we've had to endure Molumby and Price stuck out at the right wing and out of position, amongst other alternatives.

I wholehearted understand the issue with his nan, horrible loss. But the fact he's in the squad tells me he's available and willing to play. If there's concrete evidence to the contrary then fair enough, but if his name is listed in the match day squad he should be starting. 

The fact is that Mowbray has chosen to not play him, and instead has chosen to play players out of their natural position, while ignoring our most talented and creative player, until he had no other option but to try something else as his current selections weren't working. It is my opinion, and feel free to respectfully disagree rather than resorting to petty responses, that Fellows has suddenly appeared in the starting XI yesterday, pretty much for the same reason as Griffiths has - desperation because Plan A, B and C haven't worked for Tony. 

I've defended Mowbray's tactics and how we've played, so this isn't some sort of Vendetta I have against him. But his selections have been utterly baffling and inexcusable. 

If he had reasonable selections and Fellows was the exception, I could believe the excuses being offered up. But it's not, and it's a recurring theme. A theme that stretches back to his last stint here! It was an omission that has cost us dearly.
When Fellows plays like he did yesterday, he not only unplayable, he’s undroppable. He wasn’t playing like that though, he was struggling a bit and that’s why he lost his place.
Hopefully he’s now back to his best and will be first name on the team sheet for the rest of the season.

No, I agree, he wasn't at his best. But I'd argue that he would have played through that, I'd also argue a out of form Fellows is still a threat and is certainly a better selection for the right wing position than Price and Molumby!
Reply
#22
(04-13-2025, 04:17 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: I've no idea. But I've no idea why we wouldn't! Especially when he was the one banging the drum about taking the hand breaks off the players and telling us to be more offensively minded!

(04-13-2025, 04:17 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 03:59 PM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 02:00 PM)rsbaggy2 Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 09:09 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: He was bombed out by TM. Let that sink in.

More nonsense.
Let the fact that your post is baseless and without merit sink in.

He's been in the squad the last few weeks but hasn't been given the starting position or much game time, despite match situations desperately crying out for what Tomm offers. Instead we've had to endure Molumby and Price stuck out at the right wing and out of position, amongst other alternatives.

I wholehearted understand the issue with his nan, horrible loss. But the fact he's in the squad tells me he's available and willing to play. If there's concrete evidence to the contrary then fair enough, but if his name is listed in the match day squad he should be starting. 

The fact is that Mowbray has chosen to not play him, and instead has chosen to play players out of their natural position, while ignoring our most talented and creative player, until he had no other option but to try something else as his current selections weren't working. It is my opinion, and feel free to respectfully disagree rather than resorting to petty responses, that Fellows has suddenly appeared in the starting XI yesterday, pretty much for the same reason as Griffiths has - desperation because Plan A, B and C haven't worked for Tony. 

I've defended Mowbray's tactics and how we've played, so this isn't some sort of Vendetta I have against him. But his selections have been utterly baffling and inexcusable. 

If he had reasonable selections and Fellows was the exception, I could believe the excuses being offered up. But it's not, and it's a recurring theme. A theme that stretches back to his last stint here! It was an omission that has cost us dearly.
When Fellows plays like he did yesterday, he not only unplayable, he’s undroppable. He wasn’t playing like that though, he was struggling a bit and that’s why he lost his place.
Hopefully he’s now back to his best and will be first name on the team sheet for the rest of the season.

No, I agree, he wasn't at his best. But I'd argue that he would have played through that, I'd also argue a out of form Fellows is still a threat and is certainly a better selection for the right wing position than Price and Molumby!
Well, yes, there’s no argument there I suppose.
Reply
#23
(04-13-2025, 10:18 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 09:09 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: He was bombed out by TM. Let that sink in.
Alternatively...he was not playing at his best, for a while.
He was rested and came back at his best.
The manager... managed him.
This is not a computer game, where players are always at the top of their form.

Not true - facts do not support that 

Fellows (ridiculous) treatment is partly to do with the kind of football Mowbray wants to play. Possession based and not counter attacking, which doesn't suit Fellows 

It’s why we seen so much of Swift - Mowbray wants keep ball not us creating chances in transition 

When Furlong got sent off against QPR it was Fellows who despite being our best player got substituted (he created the pen and our only other good chance) 

The coach has preferred Price both at right FB & wide right. He also picked Armstrong wide right against Bristol on Tues 

Fellows has assisted in over 25% of every single goal we’ve scored. His treatment has been extremely damaging given our results 

Yes he did have 2 or 3 poorer games (by his standards) but you don’t then treat your stand out most effective player like Mowbray has. He’s been treated like a reserve for weeks. I don’t think any other team in our division does that, but our coach still doesn’t know his best team after 3 months, which again doesn’t reflect well on him

You only have to see his influence yesterday (and when he came on to appreciate see how Fellows’s treatment made no sense.

(04-13-2025, 12:22 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: When Tom’s form dipped he was regularly being marked out of the game by 2 defenders. Watford didn’t double up on him, which was clearly a factor in his performance yesterday.

Exactly right ….he’ll have 2 on him against Cov
Reply
#24
(04-13-2025, 05:20 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 10:18 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 09:09 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: He was bombed out by TM. Let that sink in.
Alternatively...he was not playing at his best, for a while.
He was rested and came back at his best.
The manager... managed him.
This is not a computer game, where players are always at the top of their form.

Not true - facts do not support that 

Fellows (ridiculous) treatment is partly to do with the kind of football Mowbray wants to play. Possession based and not counter attacking, which doesn't suit Fellows 

It’s why we seen so much of Swift - Mowbray wants keep ball not us creating chances in transition 

When Furlong got sent off against QPR it was Fellows who despite being our best player got substituted (he created the pen and our only other good chance) 

The coach has preferred Price both at right FB & wide right. He also picked Armstrong wide right against Bristol on Tues 

Fellows has assisted in over 25% of every single goal we’ve scored. His treatment has been extremely damaging given our results 

Yes he did have 2 or 3 poorer games (by his standards) but you don’t then treat your stand out most effective player like Mowbray has. I don’t think any other team in our division does that but Mow ray still doesn’t know his best team after 3 months 

Only have to see his influence yesterday (and when he came on to appreciate see how Fellows’s treatment made no sense

Agreed, Mowbray is obsessed with tedious tippy tappy possession football and it doesn’t suit Fellows as we camp in the oppositions half, creating next to no space for Fellows to create chances in. We played counter attacking football yesterday and were far more effective. I imagine we will go back to possession for possession sake football sooner rather later.
Reply
#25
(04-13-2025, 01:15 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 09:09 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: He was bombed out by TM. Let that sink in.

No he wasn’t.

He was off form. His Nan was ill and then died. He is 21 years old. Use your brain and let that sink in. He’s a human with feelings. I wouldn’t put 100% reliance on any of my employees yet alone one so young when they were going through a difficult time. It’s called man management.

He’s now in really good form and let’s hope it continues as when he is on form he is a class above.
Would be true and I’d agree if it was a couple of weeks but Fellows has been treated like a reserve not our most effective player since mid Feb, when Wallace got picked . Price, Diangana & Armstrong also selected ahead of him since then 

More  to do with Mowbray wanting to play possession based football 

Fellows’s treatment has been ridiculous

(04-13-2025, 05:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 05:20 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 10:18 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 09:09 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: He was bombed out by TM. Let that sink in.
Alternatively...he was not playing at his best, for a while.
He was rested and came back at his best.
The manager... managed him.
This is not a computer game, where players are always at the top of their form.

Not true - facts do not support that 

Fellows (ridiculous) treatment is partly to do with the kind of football Mowbray wants to play. Possession based and not counter attacking, which doesn't suit Fellows 

It’s why we seen so much of Swift - Mowbray wants keep ball not us creating chances in transition 

When Furlong got sent off against QPR it was Fellows who despite being our best player got substituted (he created the pen and our only other good chance) 

The coach has preferred Price both at right FB & wide right. He also picked Armstrong wide right against Bristol on Tues 

Fellows has assisted in over 25% of every single goal we’ve scored. His treatment has been extremely damaging given our results 

Yes he did have 2 or 3 poorer games (by his standards) but you don’t then treat your stand out most effective player like Mowbray has. I don’t think any other team in our division does that but Mow ray still doesn’t know his best team after 3 months 

Only have to see his influence yesterday (and when he came on to appreciate see how Fellows’s treatment made no sense

Agreed, Mowbray is obsessed with tedious tippy tappy possession football and it doesn’t suit Fellows as we camp in the oppositions half, creating next to no space for Fellows to create chances in. We played counter attacking football yesterday and were far more effective. I imagine we will go back to possession for possession sake football sooner rather later.
He’s been pissed about since mid Feb, Wallace, Diangana, Price & even Armstrong bizarrely played ahead of him on the right
Reply
#26
(04-13-2025, 05:20 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 10:18 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 09:09 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: He was bombed out by TM. Let that sink in.
Alternatively...he was not playing at his best, for a while.
He was rested and came back at his best.
The manager... managed him.
This is not a computer game, where players are always at the top of their form.

Not true - facts do not support that 

Fellows (ridiculous) treatment is partly to do with the kind of football Mowbray wants to play. Possession based and not counter attacking, which doesn't suit Fellows 

It’s why we seen so much of Swift - Mowbray wants keep ball not us creating chances in transition 

When Furlong got sent off against QPR it was Fellows who despite being our best player got substituted (he created the pen and our only other good chance) 

The coach has preferred Price both at right FB & wide right. He also picked Armstrong wide right against Bristol on Tues 

Fellows has assisted in over 25% of every single goal we’ve scored. His treatment has been extremely damaging given our results 

Yes he did have 2 or 3 poorer games (by his standards) but you don’t then treat your stand out most effective player like Mowbray has. He’s been treated like a reserve for weeks. I don’t think any other team in our division does that, but our coach still doesn’t know his best team after 3 months, which again doesn’t reflect well on him

You only have to see his influence yesterday (and when he came on to appreciate see how Fellows’s treatment made no sense.

(04-13-2025, 12:22 PM)Johnny akes Wrote: When Tom’s form dipped he was regularly being marked out of the game by 2 defenders. Watford didn’t double up on him, which was clearly a factor in his performance yesterday.

Exactly right ….he’ll have 2 on him against Cov

This is a very good assessment.

The way Tom has been treated by ToMo is ridiculous, and probably hastened his exit.
Reply
#27
Absolutely spot on. That’s what makes Tony’s appointment even more disturbing. Our squad is best suited to counter attacking football with a strong CF linking and creating space for two good wingers. We are not and never were going to be a successful possession based team. I would have hoped Nestor and co would have appreciated this. Tony’s post match comments support his philosophy on the game. He’s either going to have to rip up his play manual he’s had for years or continue to try and enforce his views on the players. I fear the latter will only end in tears.
Reply
#28
Very good player.

Made a notable difference when he came off the bench Tuesday and I see he got 2 Assists yesterday- 13 for the season is very good. £10m-15m or higher?.

Can play two out and out wingers with the right structure around IMO ie Full Backs and 3 in CM. Bit trickier with 2 in CM or an older school 4-4-2, certainly from a front foot dominance angle.

If you are still a Championship side, might not hold onto him?
Reply
#29
(04-13-2025, 05:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 05:20 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 10:18 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(04-13-2025, 09:09 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: He was bombed out by TM. Let that sink in.
Alternatively...he was not playing at his best, for a while.
He was rested and came back at his best.
The manager... managed him.
This is not a computer game, where players are always at the top of their form.

Not true - facts do not support that 

Fellows (ridiculous) treatment is partly to do with the kind of football Mowbray wants to play. Possession based and not counter attacking, which doesn't suit Fellows 

It’s why we seen so much of Swift - Mowbray wants keep ball not us creating chances in transition 

When Furlong got sent off against QPR it was Fellows who despite being our best player got substituted (he created the pen and our only other good chance) 

The coach has preferred Price both at right FB & wide right. He also picked Armstrong wide right against Bristol on Tues 

Fellows has assisted in over 25% of every single goal we’ve scored. His treatment has been extremely damaging given our results 

Yes he did have 2 or 3 poorer games (by his standards) but you don’t then treat your stand out most effective player like Mowbray has. I don’t think any other team in our division does that but Mow ray still doesn’t know his best team after 3 months 

Only have to see his influence yesterday (and when he came on to appreciate see how Fellows’s treatment made no sense

Agreed, Mowbray is obsessed with tedious tippy tappy possession football and it doesn’t suit Fellows as we camp in the oppositions half, creating next to no space for Fellows to create chances in. We played counter attacking football yesterday and were far more effective. I imagine we will go back to possession for possession sake football sooner rather later.
Mowbray’s interview on the club website is interesting in that yesterday was different to his preferred approach to possession-based football, and that we were playing more on the break: “it’s food for thought moving forward for me”. Perhaps the penny has dropped?
Reply
#30
(04-13-2025, 05:50 PM)Sheffieldbaggie Wrote: Absolutely spot on. That’s what makes Tony’s appointment even more disturbing. Our squad is best suited to counter attacking football with a strong CF linking and creating space for two good wingers. We are not and never were going to be a successful possession based team. I would have hoped Nestor and co would have appreciated this. Tony’s post match comments support his philosophy on the game. He’s either going to have to rip up his play manual he’s had for years or continue to try and enforce his views on the players. I fear the latter will only end in tears.

To defend Nestor, that wasn’t exactly Mowbray’s playbook at Sunderland or Blackburn. At Sunderland they finished 6th playing the style of football we played yesterday using Diallo, Clarke and Roberts on the turnover with a big man in Stewart or Simms up top, and at Blackburn Armstrong was at his most effective when he was being used alongside Danny Graham and Gallagher. 

Whilst at the time it felt like a fantastic homecoming, the 5-1 against Pompey is where it all went wrong. The way we played through them lulled Tony into a false sense of security excitement we could recreate the side that won promotion all those years ago, and gave him the false hope and faith that Swift and Grady could contribute beyond the odd flash in the pan cameo. Add the Armstrong signing to the mix and he’s gone off on some bizarre possession tangent forgetting what made him successful more recently. 

All that being said, even with how crap we’ve been, we’d probably have 4-5 more points if he’d not decided to persist with Wildshit for so long.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)