Trump vs Global Economics
#51
@BB - sorry not been clear. Some reported lists show Iran and some don’t, which one are you using? And none of them mention other sanction countries such as Cuba, North Korea or Belarus either.
Reply
#52
(04-03-2025, 11:11 AM)baggy1 Wrote: @BB I don’t see where Iran, Russia or Cuba (all sanctioned) as specifically listed in the full list. Where are you looking?

Edit - different publications are showing or not showing Iran. Guardian - No, LBC - yes

And the quote from the White House press secretary is US sanctions on Moscow already “preclude any meaningful trade”

Iran is on the list published by the office of the President.

The White House press secretary is also a partisan position, I'm not sure why you're referencing their words? No shit they'd defend Trump.
Reply
#53
Thanks BB, although it’s probably because the US do trade with Iran. And he has threatened further sanctions on anyone that trades with Russia if they don’t get the ceasefire in place.
Reply
#54
(04-03-2025, 11:42 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-03-2025, 10:48 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It's not concise or decent, it fails to account for the reason it was banned in the UK in the 1990s (issues with poor welfare being covered up, dormancy instead of removal of germs - both reasons why the US has a much higher rate of food poisoning) and it also ignores the problem of choice in respect to where the consumer doesn't know and doesn't choose - like restaurants - which is why we have regulated markets in the first place. 

Which is why I said properly labelled. "Poor welfare" is just a weak value judgement, as is a vague non-specific contention that the US "has a much higher rate of food poisoning".

I'm pro choice and education like any good liberal. Consumers are capable of their own rational choice and their own value judgements, which is why egg production has vastly better welfare than it did just 20 years ago.

The very last line of this reasonably balanced RSPCA article is at the heart of this and other food standards issues:
https://www.rspcaassured.org.uk/farmed-a...d-chicken/

"While we don’t have any chlorinated chicken in the UK at the moment, the best way to support British farmers, now and in the future, and to be sure you are buying higher welfare meat, fish, eggs and dairy"

It's not a weak value judgement, animal welfare can be measured and the conditions that result in the need for chlorine washing meat due to poor welfare result in higher incidences of disease. That's measurable, that's why we banned chlorine washing meat in the 1990s - to stop poor welfare practices from increasing incidents of diseases and make it harder to cover up poor welfare by causing dormancy in germs.

38.4 million people in the US suffer from foodbourne illnesses annually using WHO methodology, the equivalent for Europe (which covers Greenland, Turkey and all the former Soviet Union states) is 33 million using the exact same methodology. That's 5.4 million more per year for a population nearly 3 times less.

The reason why is spelled out in your link:

"Chlorinated chicken is banned in both the UK and the EU due to concerns over animal welfare and its potential to mask poor hygiene standards. Less stringent welfare standards used by American farmers during rearing can lead to unsavoury conditions which chlorine washing then compensates for." 

Those poor hygiene standards mean higher incidences of disease and chlorine washing does not sufficiently kill germs to remove the risk which is why there's an order of 1000 difference in food poisoning incidents in the EU vs the US.

As for your egg example, we literally do not sell US eggs that have been chlorine washed (all commercially produced US eggs are washed with a chlorine solution of 100ppm).

I have no issue with selling US meat that meets our welfare standards, meat that doesn't poses a significantly higher health risk as poorer welfare standards means higher disease incidences for both spread and treatment. That's literally the exact reason liberalism in the 19th century advanced regulated markets with respect to food, the landmark food safety regulation of Victorian Britain (1860 Adulteration of Food Act) was brought into law by a Liberal government precisely because it's not an informed and consensual choice to eat foods that are a risk to health.
Reply
#55
The day of the week must have a "Y" in it because BoringBaggie is shoeing Protheroe.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#56
(04-03-2025, 01:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: "Chlorinated chicken is banned in both the UK and the EU due to concerns over animal welfare and its potential to mask poor hygiene standards. Less stringent welfare standards used by American farmers during rearing can lead to unsavoury conditions which chlorine washing then compensates for." 

And in the same article is another value judgement "While US chlorine-washing methods can help manage pathogens like salmonella and campylobacter, the EU argues that poorer hygiene standards elsewhere in the process are a health concern, and chlorine-washing is being used to cover up for lower production standards on the whole."

I have a concern over the shoddy build quality, terrible paint jobs and potentially fatal software flaws in a Tesla. Do I want to buy one? No. Do I want to ban their import? No.

I also pretty certain you're not arguing that the incidence of food poisoning in the US is solely down to chicken husbandry are you?

And I never even mentioned eggs from the US.
Reply
#57
(04-03-2025, 01:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-03-2025, 01:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: "Chlorinated chicken is banned in both the UK and the EU due to concerns over animal welfare and its potential to mask poor hygiene standards. Less stringent welfare standards used by American farmers during rearing can lead to unsavoury conditions which chlorine washing then compensates for." 

And in the same article is another value judgement "While US chlorine-washing methods can help manage pathogens like salmonella and campylobacter, the EU argues that poorer hygiene standards elsewhere in the process are a health concern, and chlorine-washing is being used to cover up for lower production standards on the whole."

I have a concern over the shoddy build quality, terrible paint jobs and potentially fatal software flaws in a Tesla. Do I want to buy one? No. Do I want to ban their import? No.

I also pretty certain you're not arguing that the incidence of food poisoning in the US is solely down to chicken husbandry are you?

And I never even mentioned eggs from the US.

If you want an analogue with the automotive industry, we have restrictions on the sale and use of vehicles that don't meet our road safety regulations whether that be to people inside the car or outside the car. One of the most famous recent car models to fall foul of this is a Tesla.

And I'm arguing that chicken is one of the biggest culprits given Campylobacter, Salmonella and E-Coli are the 3 most common bacteria for causing food poisoning and all three are carried by poultry. Because chlorine washing doesn't get rid of them, it just makes levels low enough to be undetectable and then they multiply after the fact to dangerous levels. The best way to stop that from happening is better welfare standards to prevent those issues from occurring. Even when including Russia, Belarus and the Stan countries Europe still has a lower foodbourne illnesses occurrence in nominal terms than the US, not even accounting for rates because the population of the WHO Europe region is nearly 3 times more than the population of the US.

https://journals.asm.org/doi/full/10.1128/mbio.00540-18 - literature on why chlorine washing should not be relied on - and can cause more problems - and why welfare standards are important to prevent disease if you care to read it. That's why we banned chlorine washed poultry, not because of an aversion to the chlorine wash.
Reply
#58
(04-03-2025, 01:30 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-03-2025, 01:08 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: "Chlorinated chicken is banned in both the UK and the EU due to concerns over animal welfare and its potential to mask poor hygiene standards. Less stringent welfare standards used by American farmers during rearing can lead to unsavoury conditions which chlorine washing then compensates for." 

And in the same article is another value judgement "While US chlorine-washing methods can help manage pathogens like salmonella and campylobacter, the EU argues that poorer hygiene standards elsewhere in the process are a health concern, and chlorine-washing is being used to cover up for lower production standards on the whole."

I have a concern over the shoddy build quality, terrible paint jobs and potentially fatal software flaws in a Tesla. Do I want to buy one? No. Do I want to ban their import? No.

I also pretty certain you're not arguing that the incidence of food poisoning in the US is solely down to chicken husbandry are you?

And I never even mentioned eggs from the US.

Americans can have unreal arrogance about where they are as world leaders in XYZ. 

Unquestionably, despite the rise in obesity here, they are on a different level and the no 1 cause is the low standards of food not fit for human consumption they allow their population to feast on.

A friend of mine returned from Boston a few weeks ago and told me how he'd been in a town just outside one day during his stay and he was genuinely taken aback by the state of the people in this sad town.

He said he lost count of the number of people he saw whose level of morbid obesity was on a jaw dropping scale, describing people the width of a pavement who could barely move.

I was told by an American recently the cost of fresh fruit and veg is twice what we pay.

There's a level of entitlement and arrogance the myopic Americans have which does not fit into modern life. They have been overtaken in many areas and their values of money before everything stinks.

It is a great shame for the multimillions of decent ones, but it is a country really on the ropes and I can see civil war there before long.
Reply
#59
(04-03-2025, 09:33 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: [Image: bafkreidm7it3ftpdggb5l5d4ob2t5fknfkwknlo...qdzym@jpeg]

The above is bollox BTW and clearly James Surowiecki had had a glass of wine or two.
Reply
#60
(04-03-2025, 02:53 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote:
(04-03-2025, 09:33 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: [Image: bafkreidm7it3ftpdggb5l5d4ob2t5fknfkwknlo...qdzym@jpeg]

The above is bollox BTW and clearly James Surowiecki had had a glass of wine or two.

https://www.ft.com/content/85d73172-936a...1e17cb74df

Looks like it's not bollocks. The formula genuinely appears to be (Exports-Imports)/(4*(1/4)*Imports) which simplifies to (Trade Deficit)/(Imports).
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)