Rejoice Rejoice 31 March 1990
#1
The Poll  Tax demonstration.
The beginning of the end of Thatcher.
8 months later she was gone. Thank fuck.
Reply
#2
It was the mass non payment that killed that tax, 18 million refused to pay and Thatcher had to go.

Her flagship policy in ruins.
Reply
#3
(03-31-2025, 09:53 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: The Poll  Tax demonstration.
The beginning of the end of Thatcher.
8 months later she was gone. Thank fuck.

If you consider the absolute abortion that Council Tax has become - then perhaps those smashing up London that day would reconsider their opposition.

My 87 year old neighbour Ray is paying more than twice as much as the King does for the Royal Residence at Buckingham Palace this year.
Reply
#4
The Master Of False Equivalence
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#5
(04-01-2025, 09:49 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: The Master Of False Equivalence

How is that possibly false equivalence?

Charles pays about £1,800 per annum for the Royal Residence at Buckingham Palace.

Ray pays just less than £4,000 for a 4 bed detached in Hagley.
Reply
#6
The poll tax would still have been set by the local authority, Westminster would still have been able to set lower rates than Bromsgrove for the same reason it can set lower rates for council tax. All that would have happened is an 18 year old out of care and living in a HMO in Rubery would be paying the exact same as a millionaire living just outside Barnt Green or Hagley.

Despite council tax being incredibly regressive it's still more progressive than the "Community Charge".

Also Buck Palace pays business rates.
Reply
#7
(04-01-2025, 09:56 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-01-2025, 09:49 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: The Master Of False Equivalence

How is that possibly false equivalence?

Charles pays about £1,800 per annum for the Royal Residence at Buckingham Palace.

Ray pays just less than £4,000 for a 4 bed detached in Hagley.

You of all people should know how it is almost impossible to tax the super wealthy.

They spend enough money to make sure we all know that's the case.
Reply
#8
(04-01-2025, 10:05 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The poll tax would still have been set by the local authority, Westminster would still have been able to set lower rates than Bromsgrove for the same reason it can set lower rates for council tax. All that would have happened is an 18 year old out of care and living in a HMO in Rubery would be paying the exact same as a millionaire living just outside Barnt Green or Hagley.

Despite council tax being incredibly regressive it's still more progressive than the "Community Charge".

Also Buck Palace pays business rates.

Council Tax, as you've pointed out is exceptionally regressive and bears absolutely no relation to property values these days. I doubt anyone on the Poll Tax march would've wanted an even worse system than the Rates, but here we are. As an example I'm currently administering an Estate for a relative who sold their 3-storey NE London Victorian townhouse for £84,000 in 1991. That makes it a Band D house. Today it's worth £1.3m.

Buck House pays Business Rates, but Charles pays Council Tax on the Royal Residence at Buck House.
Reply
#9
(04-01-2025, 11:21 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(04-01-2025, 10:05 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The poll tax would still have been set by the local authority, Westminster would still have been able to set lower rates than Bromsgrove for the same reason it can set lower rates for council tax. All that would have happened is an 18 year old out of care and living in a HMO in Rubery would be paying the exact same as a millionaire living just outside Barnt Green or Hagley.

Despite council tax being incredibly regressive it's still more progressive than the "Community Charge".

Also Buck Palace pays business rates.

Council Tax, as you've pointed out is exceptionally regressive and bears absolutely no relation to property values these days. I doubt anyone on the Poll Tax march would've wanted an even worse system than the Rates, but here we are. As an example I'm currently administering an Estate for a relative who sold their 3-storey NE London Victorian townhouse for £84,000 in 1991. That makes it a Band D house. Today it's worth £1.3m.

Buck House pays Business Rates, but Charles pays Council Tax on the Royal Residence at Buck House.

And the poll tax wouldn't have discerned between Hugh Grosvenor and someone who lives in a HMO in Westminster and works 2 jobs to live paycheck-to-paycheck, and they'd both pay less than someone on a minimum wage job living in Tipton because Sandwell would need to set higher rates for the poll tax. It was even more regressive than Council Tax.
Reply
#10
Which is precisely the argument for replacing Council Tax, Business Rates, IHT and CGT with a Land Value Tax.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: