Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
If mentality is down to the manager then we are mental. Mowbray has done things before and during the last two games that have cost us 5 points. We could and should have won both of them. Managers do and say things that fans see as daft, don't players see it as well? Isn't that what takes that edge off? I think decisions also affect the mentality of the oppostion. I reckon Hull must have been delighted that Price was right back and Norwich delighted that he was on the bench.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(03-31-2025, 08:48 AM)wba13 Wrote: (03-30-2025, 06:45 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: (03-30-2025, 03:07 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (03-30-2025, 01:14 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (03-30-2025, 11:40 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: A good manager.
Who was the last good manager we had then?
If it's Corberan and he is a "future Champions League Manager" and Mowbray is matching him, how can he be a bad one?
I really do worry that some people will become so entrenched in their disdain for Mowbray, who didn't oust CC by the way, he just applied for a job because he fucked off, that, if we do get promoted they will not fully enjoy it because they will have continue with a "we did it despite Mowbray" rhetoric.
We are 6th with 8 games to go, so I'm in, and will enjoy the ride, until the maths, results or the play off trophy says it's over. Only then will the post mortem take place.
I think the difference is that CC inherited a side that was unfit, wholly unbalanced and only going in one direction, and with very little financial wiggle room he pulled the side out of the relegation spiral it was stuck in, and then ensured comfortable playoff form for close to 2 seasons despite the club almost going out of business.
Mowbray inherited a well organised, well trained squad without any of the off the field issues, and was backed heavily in his first window. If Carlos had had Price, Bany, Armstrong, Lankshear and a fit Dike I’d wager we’d have seen more points from the last 10 or so games.
Carlos also had game plans, and even thought it didn’t always work, you knew what we were trying to do in the main, and at full time he would give an assessment the vast majority of fans understood and agreed with. Yes, the long term effects are that players lost a sense of individuality and we had some very tough watches, but generally we were an efficient machine.
Since Mowbray came in I’ve got no idea what we are trying to do or be. He appears to pick names out of a hat before kick off and his in game management has been sketchy.
I’d love it to work out for Tony as he gave us 2 fantastic seasons last time round, and after the Robson debacle he made us fun to support again, but I’m really not seeing much so far to suggest he’s going to have the same impact this time round.
Great post and my feelings exactly
This love in for Corberan is sad, remember he left us and Mowbray has a virtually equal record.Corberan also had Palmer, Maja and Styles who he didn’t use until injury.also Ajayi.
Our best player under Corberan is out until at least the play offs we also lost Furlong for three matches. Carlos’s game plan was to defend. I didn’t want Corberan to leave and Mowbray wasn’t my choice but the criticism of Mowbray is wrong against Corberan because to be honest now we try to create more but don’t defend as well.
It doesn't need to be Corberan v Mowbray. It doesnt matter what came before, i want to see a plan now. For me I can only judge on what I see. Baffling team selection, ignoring players that have done a really good job, sticking with Armstrong in a role he's not suited to and the confusion introducing 4 subs late on brings to a game we are dominating. That game at Norwich was there for the taking.
Posts: 113
Threads: 12
Joined: Mar 2025
Posts: 1,816
Threads: 69
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
5
(03-31-2025, 01:52 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: (03-31-2025, 08:48 AM)wba13 Wrote: (03-30-2025, 06:45 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: (03-30-2025, 03:07 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (03-30-2025, 01:14 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Who was the last good manager we had then?
If it's Corberan and he is a "future Champions League Manager" and Mowbray is matching him, how can he be a bad one?
I really do worry that some people will become so entrenched in their disdain for Mowbray, who didn't oust CC by the way, he just applied for a job because he fucked off, that, if we do get promoted they will not fully enjoy it because they will have continue with a "we did it despite Mowbray" rhetoric.
We are 6th with 8 games to go, so I'm in, and will enjoy the ride, until the maths, results or the play off trophy says it's over. Only then will the post mortem take place.
I think the difference is that CC inherited a side that was unfit, wholly unbalanced and only going in one direction, and with very little financial wiggle room he pulled the side out of the relegation spiral it was stuck in, and then ensured comfortable playoff form for close to 2 seasons despite the club almost going out of business.
Mowbray inherited a well organised, well trained squad without any of the off the field issues, and was backed heavily in his first window. If Carlos had had Price, Bany, Armstrong, Lankshear and a fit Dike I’d wager we’d have seen more points from the last 10 or so games.
Carlos also had game plans, and even thought it didn’t always work, you knew what we were trying to do in the main, and at full time he would give an assessment the vast majority of fans understood and agreed with. Yes, the long term effects are that players lost a sense of individuality and we had some very tough watches, but generally we were an efficient machine.
Since Mowbray came in I’ve got no idea what we are trying to do or be. He appears to pick names out of a hat before kick off and his in game management has been sketchy.
I’d love it to work out for Tony as he gave us 2 fantastic seasons last time round, and after the Robson debacle he made us fun to support again, but I’m really not seeing much so far to suggest he’s going to have the same impact this time round.
Great post and my feelings exactly
This love in for Corberan is sad, remember he left us and Mowbray has a virtually equal record.Corberan also had Palmer, Maja and Styles who he didn’t use until injury.also Ajayi.
Our best player under Corberan is out until at least the play offs we also lost Furlong for three matches. Carlos’s game plan was to defend. I didn’t want Corberan to leave and Mowbray wasn’t my choice but the criticism of Mowbray is wrong against Corberan because to be honest now we try to create more but don’t defend as well.
It doesn't need to be Corberan v Mowbray. It doesnt matter what came before, i want to see a plan now. For me I can only judge on what I see. Baffling team selection, ignoring players that have done a really good job, sticking with Armstrong in a role he's not suited to and the confusion introducing 4 subs late on brings to a game we are dominating. That game at Norwich was there for the taking.
It does seem like it though doesn’t it.
The same issue with subs was very prevalent on the board with Carlos. The same 3 subs every game at 60 minutes regardless.
The fact is as we enter April at the business end of the season we are 6th.
This is despite losing our best defender pre-season and an excellent keeper in Jan that the defence had faith in.
With the owners having an obvious plan to recruit younger players with re-sale value with a restricted budget I’m happy to play the waiting game.
Next season, will hopefully see Whitwell, Bany, Mohammed, Griffith and Taylor make a step up. If we bring in more hidden gems we need a manager who can bring on these players.
Our issue throughout this season is we don’t score enough goals. I’d like to see AA play off Dike but I do wonder if the medical team are reticent in letting him go full pelt yet.
All we can do is get behind the team and wait and see.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
03-31-2025, 10:02 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-31-2025, 10:03 PM by Spandaubaggie.)
Whilst I parodied this post earlier, I think it only fair to say I didn’t think anything is missing mentally as a separate quality needed compared to any other aspect of where we are now.
Last season the squad, containing many of the same players managed to get top 6. It means that we have some experience that have been there. This should help in the next few weeks.
Ultimately I just think we’re weaker, especially with Kipre and Palmer gone.
We are a competitive but less than spectacular squad who are where we are because that’s as good as we are.
There’s a hairs breadth between 10 or so clubs in the division.
We are one of them.
Like last year the top few are a step above. We don’t have that quality.
|