Posts: 1,403
Threads: 12
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(03-27-2025, 01:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (03-27-2025, 12:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-27-2025, 12:17 PM)Logic1 Wrote: (03-27-2025, 11:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-27-2025, 10:55 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The people you refer to aren’t losing their benefits or any of them Derek. Grow up.
Erm 250,000 people and 50,000 children plunged into poverty it says in the impact statement.
Impact
Perhaps see past the spreadsheets and realise these are people not statistics.
Does the impact analysis also determine how many of the 250,000 own a pet?
I have no idea.
Fixed that for you Dekka.
You’ve taken a statement and you’ve regurgitated it without checking its validity. It is clearly implying, I’d go as far as stating, that the impact assessment contains the wording that they estimate that 250,000 people, including 50,000 children, will be pushed below the poverty line.
I cannot see where the impact assessment says anything of that magnitude. It may be that they have extrapolated some figures and can conclude that, but that isn’t what is being said here. You have grasped it and reposted it because it fits your idea of what has happened - confirmation bias.
You’ve then linked two articles in the news that have done the same and because you are saying the same thing then it must be true, even if the source material is being misinterpreted or worse lied about to fit an agenda. This is where the saying that a lie will have made it half way round the world before the truth has put its boots on comes from.
Or alternatively - read the actual impact assessment
'The potential impact of these reforms on poverty projections has been estimated using a static microsimulation model. Using this model, we estimate there will be an additional 250,000 people (including 50,000 children) in relative poverty after housing costs in 2029/30 as a result of modelled changes to social security, compared to the baseline projections.'
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk...mpacts.pdf
Well that's me for another 6 months then - bye
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
03-27-2025, 01:26 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2025, 01:31 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(03-27-2025, 01:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (03-27-2025, 12:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-27-2025, 12:17 PM)Logic1 Wrote: (03-27-2025, 11:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-27-2025, 10:55 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The people you refer to aren’t losing their benefits or any of them Derek. Grow up.
Erm 250,000 people and 50,000 children plunged into poverty it says in the impact statement.
Impact
Perhaps see past the spreadsheets and realise these are people not statistics.
Does the impact analysis also determine how many of the 250,000 own a pet?
I have no idea.
Fixed that for you Dekka.
You’ve taken a statement and you’ve regurgitated it without checking its validity. It is clearly implying, I’d go as far as stating, that the impact assessment contains the wording that they estimate that 250,000 people, including 50,000 children, will be pushed below the poverty line.
I cannot see where the impact assessment says anything of that magnitude. It may be that they have extrapolated some figures and can conclude that, but that isn’t what is being said here. You have grasped it and reposted it because it fits your idea of what has happened - confirmation bias.
You’ve then linked two articles in the news that have done the same and because you are saying the same thing then it must be true, even if the source material is being misinterpreted or worse lied about to fit an agenda. This is where the saying that a lie will have made it half way round the world before the truth has put its boots on comes from.
B1, I was answering Logic bizarre Daily Mail-esque pet question.
You can be a Labour apologist if you want those figures have only been disputed by the appalling chancellor in so much as apparently all those jobs they will create in mitigation.
Where is the lie? Don’t gaslight people like you did before when you declared with all certainty that Reeves never said what I quoted because you didn’t here or see it on Radio 4.
(03-27-2025, 01:18 PM)strawman Wrote: (03-27-2025, 01:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (03-27-2025, 12:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-27-2025, 12:17 PM)Logic1 Wrote: (03-27-2025, 11:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Erm 250,000 people and 50,000 children plunged into poverty it says in the impact statement.
Impact
Perhaps see past the spreadsheets and realise these are people not statistics.
Does the impact analysis also determine how many of the 250,000 own a pet?
I have no idea.
Fixed that for you Dekka.
You’ve taken a statement and you’ve regurgitated it without checking its validity. It is clearly implying, I’d go as far as stating, that the impact assessment contains the wording that they estimate that 250,000 people, including 50,000 children, will be pushed below the poverty line.
I cannot see where the impact assessment says anything of that magnitude. It may be that they have extrapolated some figures and can conclude that, but that isn’t what is being said here. You have grasped it and reposted it because it fits your idea of what has happened - confirmation bias.
You’ve then linked two articles in the news that have done the same and because you are saying the same thing then it must be true, even if the source material is being misinterpreted or worse lied about to fit an agenda. This is where the saying that a lie will have made it half way round the world before the truth has put its boots on comes from.
Or alternatively - read the actual impact assessment
'The potential impact of these reforms on poverty projections has been estimated using a static microsimulation model. Using this model, we estimate there will be an additional 250,000 people (including 50,000 children) in relative poverty after housing costs in 2029/30 as a result of modelled changes to social security, compared to the baseline projections.'
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk...mpacts.pdf
Well that's me for another 6 months then - bye
Arf, was this on Radio 4 with Nick Robinson? If not it was never said or written.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
03-27-2025, 01:41 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2025, 01:49 PM by baggy1.)
(03-27-2025, 01:18 PM)strawman Wrote: Or alternatively - read the actual impact assessment
'The potential impact of these reforms on poverty projections has been estimated using a static microsimulation model. Using this model, we estimate there will be an additional 250,000 people (including 50,000 children) in relative poverty after housing costs in 2029/30 as a result of modelled changes to social security, compared to the baseline projections.'
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk...mpacts.pdf
Well that's me for another 6 months then - bye
Thanks SM that's what I was asking - was that the document linked to the original article because that isn't where it took me.
Which leads me onto the context of that statement, the next paragraph: "There are important limitations to this analysis. This estimate does not include the impact of the £1 billion annual funding, by 2029/30, for measures to support those with disabilities and long-term health conditions into employment, which we expect to mitigate the poverty impact among people it supports into work."
Or the following paragraph: 'Furthermore, the analysis does not take into account new protections for those with severe lifelong conditions that the government intends to bring forward."
This is exactly what I am trying to get across Dekka, I'm not making excuses, I'm trying to take away the confirmation bias and put some context in where clickbait ignores it.
(03-27-2025, 01:26 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-27-2025, 01:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: (03-27-2025, 12:51 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-27-2025, 12:17 PM)Logic1 Wrote: (03-27-2025, 11:14 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Erm 250,000 people and 50,000 children plunged into poverty it says in the impact statement.
Impact
Perhaps see past the spreadsheets and realise these are people not statistics.
Does the impact analysis also determine how many of the 250,000 own a pet?
I have no idea.
Fixed that for you Dekka.
You’ve taken a statement and you’ve regurgitated it without checking its validity. It is clearly implying, I’d go as far as stating, that the impact assessment contains the wording that they estimate that 250,000 people, including 50,000 children, will be pushed below the poverty line.
I cannot see where the impact assessment says anything of that magnitude. It may be that they have extrapolated some figures and can conclude that, but that isn’t what is being said here. You have grasped it and reposted it because it fits your idea of what has happened - confirmation bias.
You’ve then linked two articles in the news that have done the same and because you are saying the same thing then it must be true, even if the source material is being misinterpreted or worse lied about to fit an agenda. This is where the saying that a lie will have made it half way round the world before the truth has put its boots on comes from.
B1, I was answering Logic bizarre Daily Mail-esque pet question.
You can be a Labour apologist if you want those figures have only been disputed by the appalling chancellor in so much as apparently all those jobs they will create in mitigation.
Where is the lie? Don’t gaslight people like you did before when you declared with all certainty that Reeves never said what I quoted because you didn’t here or see it on Radio 4.
Gaslighting again because I ask you to support a statement?
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
03-27-2025, 01:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2025, 02:00 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
No, you said Reeves didn’t say what was quoted because you didn’t hear it. However you were certain in your reply she hadn’t.
Then you asked about the figures, and Strawman has given you them from the report. I answered Logics weird question and you went and replied anyway, after latching on to the wrong end of the stick.
You’re having a mare, or Reeves as it’s now commonly known.
Posts: 613
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
2
I don't understand why my comment has been interpreted as "Daily Mail esque"
According to this website... 57% of households own a pet: https://www.statista.com/statistics/3082...ingdom-uk/
According to this website, the cost of owning a dog is about 15k over its lifetime: https://www.pdsa.org.uk/pet-help-and-adv...ning-a-dog
On what basis therefore, should anyone get child benefit? Or benefits to supplement working?
I appreciate that not every household that gets benefits owns a pet, but why should my taxes subsidise pet ownership?
Incidentally, we have a cat. However, we don't get any benefits.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
03-27-2025, 02:48 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2025, 02:49 PM by baggy1.)
@ Dekka - Not exactly but I'm giving up the will here. You've reached the level of delusion that you can't listen to an alternative view. I've contextualised each of the statements and you still ignore everything because it isn't what you want to hear.
To be clear the BBC attributed the quote to Darren Jones and said Reeves said it was clumsy and he apologised for that. I took that at face value and will always accept when I have got it wrong. In her interview with LBC she answered a question with the quote you see on the LBC site but LBC have ignored this part of the full quote, omitted from the middle of the statement "I know that's not the right analogy" so the pearl clutching is a bit over the top.
And the figures and Strawman's quote are not taking into account the full statement are they - which I have added above.
You are running the risk of KKK levels of hysteria to prove your point but to add a bit more context for you about the benefit changes the government are bringing forward protections for the most vulnerable.
Posts: 7,726
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(03-27-2025, 02:40 PM)Logic1 Wrote: I don't understand why my comment has been interpreted as "Daily Mail esque"
According to this website... 57% of households own a pet: https://www.statista.com/statistics/3082...ingdom-uk/
According to this website, the cost of owning a dog is about 15k over its lifetime: https://www.pdsa.org.uk/pet-help-and-adv...ning-a-dog
On what basis therefore, should anyone get child benefit? Or benefits to supplement working?
I appreciate that not every household that gets benefits owns a pet, but why should my taxes subsidise pet ownership?
Incidentally, we have a cat. However, we don't get any benefits.
I dont think even this Labour government would announce a means tested pet euthanasia policy, but still, best not give them ideas...
Posts: 613
Threads: 47
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
2
(03-27-2025, 02:51 PM)Jacko Wrote: (03-27-2025, 02:40 PM)Logic1 Wrote: I don't understand why my comment has been interpreted as "Daily Mail esque"
According to this website... 57% of households own a pet: https://www.statista.com/statistics/3082...ingdom-uk/
According to this website, the cost of owning a dog is about 15k over its lifetime: https://www.pdsa.org.uk/pet-help-and-adv...ning-a-dog
On what basis therefore, should anyone get child benefit? Or benefits to supplement working?
I appreciate that not every household that gets benefits owns a pet, but why should my taxes subsidise pet ownership?
Incidentally, we have a cat. However, we don't get any benefits.
I dont think even this Labour government would announce a means tested pet euthanasia policy, but still, best not give them ideas... I'm not advocating that haha, but people can transition out from owning their pets and anyone thinking of getting a pet would have to think carefully - it's not going to be subsidised by the child benefit. Obviously this is not good for the veterinary industry, but overtime those economic resources can be re-calibrated in to the defence industry in order to make weapons. Why kill pets, when you can kill people.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
03-27-2025, 04:04 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2025, 04:10 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(03-27-2025, 02:48 PM)baggy1 Wrote: @ Dekka - Not exactly but I'm giving up the will here. You've reached the level of delusion that you can't listen to an alternative view. I've contextualised each of the statements and you still ignore everything because it isn't what you want to hear.
To be clear the BBC attributed the quote to Darren Jones and said Reeves said it was clumsy and he apologised for that. I took that at face value and will always accept when I have got it wrong. In her interview with LBC she answered a question with the quote you see on the LBC site but LBC have ignored this part of the full quote, omitted from the middle of the statement "I know that's not the right analogy" so the pearl clutching is a bit over the top.
And the figures and Strawman's quote are not taking into account the full statement are they - which I have added above.
You are running the risk of KKK levels of hysteria to prove your point but to add a bit more context for you about the benefit changes the government are bringing forward protections for the most vulnerable.
I did put that context into my reply earlier with regards Reeves arguing the figures are wrong because they are going to get people into work, through their ‘work coach’ plans that they are spending a billion pounds on. I’ve also asked where all these jobs are coming from? If those people cannot find work through not fault of their own then what? Disabled people who are capable of work, want to, but employers don’t or can’t employ them. Unless the government puts significant money into incentivising employers to employ disabled people, this simply won’t work and those figures will not be far off.
As for the what she said, I heard the interview it was crass to say the least.
Here are some people behind these the stats and the crass analogies…
Reality for many people
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Another reality: The government are bringing forward protections for the most vulnerable
|