Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
03-26-2025, 09:09 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2025, 03:18 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
If you support cuts that make the poorest and most vulnerable in society even poorer including children you’re a xxxt. I can put it no more bluntly that.
I am genuinely appalled at this government, they are callous, nasty, cowards and beyond that they are incompetent.
Reeves decision to raise tax via NI was stupid and was bound to harm growth as small business can’t afford to pay the increases and it will push up inflation/cost of living.
The fiscal rules are a straight jacket that will continue to bite her and it looks like the disabled on the arse.
As for her cuts, it will increase pressure on social services that they’ve kicked into the long grass, it will see more people in hospital and it won’t make the disabled any fitter for work. They are cuts, they are not reforms that’s weasel words from a weasely government. There is no details about how they are going to get people back into work and they are putting cuts first reforms second how incompetent or disingenuous of them, actually I imagine it’ll be both.
They came into power talking the country down, they offered no hope but promised change. The only change they’ve made is to make the most vulnerable more vulnerable, 50,000 at least children poorer and kicked the support away from the sick and disabled. What’s legacy for a Labour government.
They have left people terrified, some are likely to die due to these cuts and centrist dads can rejoice that the ‘grown ups’ are in charge and slap their able bodied backs declaring well done Labour.
Unforgivable policies to save the blushes of an appalling chancellor.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
03-26-2025, 09:32 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-26-2025, 09:34 PM by Protheroe.)
(03-26-2025, 06:32 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: I didn't but you appear to have forgotten how incompetent and out of their depth your heroes of 2010 -24 were and how low they had sunk.
My "heroes?"
Hmm. Perhaps you should read some of my posts form most of that time when I was complaining about much the same issues I'm complaining about today.
Much like the current government the Tories came to power in 2010 and 2015 promising to sort shit out. Much like the current lot them had a tendency to make a bad situation worse.
(03-26-2025, 08:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: (03-26-2025, 08:26 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Whats the point of building so many new homes now?
No one will be able to afford them as not exactly affordable are they
All that will do is cause the housing market to crash & negative equity
Just like 1992 all over again
Never fucking learn, the well educated ones that know whats best for us
We need to build 380,000 houses a year just to stop house prices rising higher than inflation, what the hell are you on about?
This.
Negative Equity was never actually anything other than a minority sport for about 12 months in this country and meant nothing anyway if you weren't in an immediate need to sell your house or remortgage. It's never reappear unless we have something like a global pandemic....
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
(03-26-2025, 09:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If you support cuts that make the poorest and most vulnerable in society even poorer including children you’re a xxxt. I can put it no more bluntly that.
I am genuinely appalled at this government, they are callous, nasty, cowards and beyond that they are incompetent.
Reeves decision to raise tax via NI was stupid and was bound to harm growth as small business can’t afford to pay the increases and it will push up inflation/cost of living.
The fiscal rules are a straight jacket that will continue to bite her and it looks like the disabled on the arse.
As for her cuts, it will increase pressure on social services that they’ve kicked into the long grass, it will see more people in hospital and it won’t make the disabled any fitter for work. They are cuts, they are not reforms that’s weasel words from a weasely government. There is no details about how they are going to get people back into work and they are putting cuts first reforms second how incompetent or disingenuous of them, actually I imagine it’ll be both.
They came into power talking the country down, they offered no hope but promised change. The only change they’ve made is to make the most vulnerable more vulnerable, 50,000 at least children poorer and kicked the support away from the sick and disabled. What’s legacy for a Labour government.
They have left people terrified, some are likely to die due to these cuts and centrist dads can rejoice that the ‘grown ups’ are in charge and slap their able bodied backs declaring well done Labour.
Unforgivable policies to save the blushes of an appalling chancellor.
I think you’ll find Dekka that no-one is defending the decisions, you appear to be arguing with yourself on this one. We all knew the country was fucked and we are massively overspending with the highest tax burden already in place so what were the alternatives to cuts?
Your only solution offered is a vague notion of a wealth tax. I’ll ask a simple question, and by the way this isn’t me defending anything, it’s asking how it would work - how would you measure wealth?
I’ve explained why the fiscal rules are needed - without them and any increased spending increases debt and therefore interest which in itself reduces the amount to spend on services.
The solutions I can see are sort out our trading relationship with the EU, the downside to that is the damage that would cause with our trading relationship with the US but I think the positives would outweigh the negatives there fiscally.
The other solution I can see is abandon the increase in defence spending and just hope that it isn’t needed. By doing that we would effectively be giving up on Ukraine and throwing them to the wolves.
No-one on here is a cunt as you put it (not certain why you need to blank it out btw), we just don’t see a solution and we knew it was coming.
Posts: 7,448
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
03-27-2025, 08:44 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2025, 08:46 AM by Protheroe.)
Reeves on R4 Today absolutely breathtaking this morning at 8:10 relying wholly on the bullshit forecasts of the OBR. It's going to be a long 5 years.
She even stated that planning reform is going to ride to the rescue apparently. Because everyone knows we have enough tradesmen, development finance and materials.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(03-27-2025, 07:44 AM)baggy1 Wrote: (03-26-2025, 09:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: If you support cuts that make the poorest and most vulnerable in society even poorer including children you’re a xxxt. I can put it no more bluntly that.
I am genuinely appalled at this government, they are callous, nasty, cowards and beyond that they are incompetent.
Reeves decision to raise tax via NI was stupid and was bound to harm growth as small business can’t afford to pay the increases and it will push up inflation/cost of living.
The fiscal rules are a straight jacket that will continue to bite her and it looks like the disabled on the arse.
As for her cuts, it will increase pressure on social services that they’ve kicked into the long grass, it will see more people in hospital and it won’t make the disabled any fitter for work. They are cuts, they are not reforms that’s weasel words from a weasely government. There is no details about how they are going to get people back into work and they are putting cuts first reforms second how incompetent or disingenuous of them, actually I imagine it’ll be both.
They came into power talking the country down, they offered no hope but promised change. The only change they’ve made is to make the most vulnerable more vulnerable, 50,000 at least children poorer and kicked the support away from the sick and disabled. What’s legacy for a Labour government.
They have left people terrified, some are likely to die due to these cuts and centrist dads can rejoice that the ‘grown ups’ are in charge and slap their able bodied backs declaring well done Labour.
Unforgivable policies to save the blushes of an appalling chancellor.
I think you’ll find Dekka that no-one is defending the decisions, you appear to be arguing with yourself on this one. We all knew the country was fucked and we are massively overspending with the highest tax burden already in place so what were the alternatives to cuts?
Your only solution offered is a vague notion of a wealth tax. I’ll ask a simple question, and by the way this isn’t me defending anything, it’s asking how it would work - how would you measure wealth?
I’ve explained why the fiscal rules are needed - without them and any increased spending increases debt and therefore interest which in itself reduces the amount to spend on services.
The solutions I can see are sort out our trading relationship with the EU, the downside to that is the damage that would cause with our trading relationship with the US but I think the positives would outweigh the negatives there fiscally.
The other solution I can see is abandon the increase in defence spending and just hope that it isn’t needed. By doing that we would effectively be giving up on Ukraine and throwing them to the wolves.
No-one on here is a cunt as you put it (not certain why you need to blank it out btw), we just don’t see a solution and we knew it was coming.
You’re labouring under the illusion that cutting money to the sick and disabled is going to save money, it will just push problems into others areas of the economy notably health, social care and local government.
If you can no longer afford to look after your disabled mother, child, who is going to pick up the bill? If people can no longer feed themselves or pay the rent who is going to house them? It a child see’s his family skint because one of their parents has to look after the other meaning neither can work, and he’s see’s an opportunity to make a lot of quick money through county lines etc, who picks up the bill?
Making sick and vulnerable people worse off doesn’t solve any problems it just heaps more problems on poor areas struggling with now 15yrs of cuts to services.
Where are these jobs that Reeves and co keep banging on about? If you listen to those with disabilities they will tell you they’ve applied for hundreds of jobs but employers do t want the ‘hassle’ of making their companies accessible or can’t afford to.
Reeves is sparing her own blushes and those of her cabinets on the backs of the most vulnerable and poorest in society. You can dress it up anyway you, you can try and rationalise it, you can ask a random poster on an obscure football message board for the solutions but it’s wrong morally and it doesn’t even make any financial sense over the medium to long term. I don’t like the word I used but to those who defend these cuts then I think the word is sadly appropriate.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
I'm not labouring under any illusion, not dressing it up, and not trying to rationalise it. Tell me your solution and ffs stop quoting quotes upon quotes
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(03-27-2025, 10:06 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm not labouring under any illusion, not dressing it up, and not trying to rationalise it. Tell me your solution and ffs stop quoting quotes upon quotes
Answer the question how those disabled and sick people who are struggling to make ends meet now are going to manage when they lose hundreds if not thousands of pounds in support? A caveat don’t use the weasel words of the Labour cabinet and talk about jobs because many can’t work or won’t be able to find jobs.
Two or three weeks ago you played down the impact of these cuts, accusing the media and those like myself of scaremongering. You never questioned who may have leaked the information, you ignored the warnings of charities and experts, you ignored members of your own or former party, but now you’re saying it’s terrible/shit but there’s nothing that can be done e about it.
You are defending the indefensible and the incompetent, because they’re your party and not the Tories. From where I’m standing they look very similar but at least one party didn’t pretend to be on the side of the poor and vulnerable and then subsequently throw them under a bus as soon as they got into power.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(03-27-2025, 10:06 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm not labouring under any illusion, not dressing it up, and not trying to rationalise it. Tell me your solution and ffs stop quoting quotes upon quotes
If we knew the solutions we wouldn't be wasting our time on here.
But I think it's fair to say that the solutions aren't going to be found with this current Govt.
Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
03-27-2025, 10:40 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-27-2025, 10:47 AM by baggy1.)
Answer what question, I don't agree with punishing those who need it most, in this case the disabled. What am I supposed to be answering here? My view on the policy is that it is heavy handed and intended to remove those that are abusing the system but will no doubt punish the wrong people in amongst that. It doesn't help when I read yesterday someone saying that people would just start by claiming for more severe disabilities - how does that work, surely they just claim for what they have?
You've completely gone off full KKK and assumed because everyone isn't shouting loudly about this that they must agree with it. I don't but what is the alternative?
(03-27-2025, 10:38 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: (03-27-2025, 10:06 AM)baggy1 Wrote: I'm not labouring under any illusion, not dressing it up, and not trying to rationalise it. Tell me your solution and ffs stop quoting quotes upon quotes
If we knew the solutions we wouldn't be wasting our time on here.
But I think it's fair to say that the solutions aren't going to be found with this current Govt.
Whinging about something that is wrong without an option is pointless. Dekka turned his nose up at the only real change offered in 2017 and now is complaining that we've got much the same. I'm also being attacked for voting for the government as if they are my football team - I voted for Corbyn and saw that no matter how his principles stood up he wasn't going to get elected but the alternative of more Tory years was not palatable to me so I did something about it.
The argument that they are just the same is not valid, because voting Tory this time would have pushed us further to the right - we're now just holding the middle ground whilst we have time to work out the next steps in getting things better. Allowing that shift to the right would have put us further back than we are.
|