A Bullshit Statement
#21
(03-26-2025, 04:17 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Why is it naive? We are spoon fed this line and just accept it, without stopping to think what this means if it is actually true.

I'll tell you what's naive. It's naive to think you'll get growth by loading massive costs on business at the point you really need them to expand.

It's also naive to think that capital isn't mobile. It goes to the jurisdictions that it is subject to the least tax. Which is why you need to tax LAND FFS!

(03-26-2025, 04:28 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I sincerely disagree with that, they only picked up 33% of the vote. They have a majority that's a mile wide but an inch deep, a small shift away could have massively shifted things and resulted in a hung parliament.

You may sincerely disagree with that, but remind me - were your lot honest enough to say they'd reverse Hunt's Bear Trap?
Reply
#22
Is "tax land" the new "buy gold"?
Reply
#23
No, because they were also shit scared of losing votes with 2015 still fresh on the mind.

Ultimately the issue here is the Tories deciding to fuck things by playing these stupid games.

(03-26-2025, 04:37 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Is "tax land" the new "buy gold"?

No, that would be the pie in the sky nonsense Magic Grandpa came up with.
Reply
#24
(03-26-2025, 04:37 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: Is "tax land" the new "buy gold"?

If you'd bought gold at any point I tipped it you'd be sitting rather pretty now. Pity I sold out a few months back.

Just a few notes on a "Wealth Tax" from John Stepek, one of the more rational commentators:

I've been thinking about a wealth tax and the more I think about it, the dafter it gets. We do tax wealth in the UK already, and in a pretty comprehensive manner, surprising as that might seem to some. Here's a quick list:

1) Capital gains tax: if you buy an asset - eg shares or an investment property, then sell it for a profit, you'll pay CGT.

2) Inheritance tax: if you die with over £1m (or less in some circumstance) your estate will have to hand over 40% of the excess.

3) Stamp duty on both houses and equities: if you buy a house or UK-listed shares, you have to pay a fee whether or not you eventually make a profit on the sale.

4) Tax on dividend, bond coupons, and savings income: you get charged on income generated by shares or bonds, and interest paid on cash.

5) Corporation tax: corporation tax is an interesting one. The economic incidence (who pays it) is debated. But let's say it falls on employees, consumers, and shareholders equally. In that case you could argue that about a third of the corporation tax take is a wealth tax.

6) I've left out VAT, which some argue has elements of a wealth tax, because beyond "wealthy people buy more stuff and so pay more in absolute terms", it's too much of a fudge. But you can make the case if you really want to.

Anyway, the point is we already tax wealth a) when it pays an income; and b) when a profit is crystallised - ie an asset is sold (which is the only realistic way to charge it - charging an annual fee on fluctuating paper profits seems completely unworkable).

You may take issue with the exact details of some of these taxes, such as the exemptions involved (which usually came about because some past government thought that encouraging a specific type of investment was a good idea). But adding a new one seems impractical.

You might get away with a "one-off" wealth tax (effectively a windfall profits tax for individuals), but that's a troubling precedent to set. It's amazing how one-offs become regular cash grabs, as any "windfall profit"-prone sector knows only too well.

In practical terms (putting aside desirability) the only space I can see for an added annual wealth tax would be some sort of residential property tax, probably linked to council tax reform. But I suspect that would be even less popular than extending CGT to residential home sales.
Reply
#25
I see the tax planning around all assets and the increasing use of trusts these days and the thought that a wealth tax would solve all of our problems is naive in my opinion. I can't see how it would work unless an individual has all of their wealth sitting in a bank account. Then there is the measurement of that wealth, which valuation would you take and is there a rebate if share wealth takes a hit, what valuation on properties? 1991 as with council tax?
Reply
#26
Proth you are spot on about these delusional forecasts from the OBR and the BoE. The reality is, the one thing that will get the economy moving - trade deals with the EU and reversing Brexit is completely off the table. Until that changes, we will have 1 percent growth for the foreseeable future, that means if we are going to continue to invest in health, education and defence, there have to be cuts from elsewhere and the only option for that is the welfare budget. Reeves is clearly hoping that inflation will be under control soon and interest rates will start falling. However, that is entirely dependent on the impact of a trade war from the loony Americans. Who knows what will happen. Reeves is basically fugged of she sticks to her fiscal rules.
Reply
#27
(03-26-2025, 02:55 PM)Protheroe Wrote: You must have been asleep for most of the last couple of decades to have missed the slew of absolute bullshit from the Treasury, BoE & OBR. 

After voting for completely undefined "change" last July, one thing that hasn't changed is the stench emanating from the these three institutions. 

After halving the growth forecast for the next year from 2% to 1%, we are apparently supposed to believe that growth is going to be greater for the rest of the Parliament, and the OBR has uprated it. One what premise? 

Planning reform.

That's right, all the additional growth predicted by the terminally inaccurate OBR is going to come from the planning reforms we have not yet seen on paper let alone in action.

And that is how Rachel balances her books, keeps her wafer thin headroom and stays within her confected Ironclad Fiscal Rules.

Planning reform.

We are fucked.

(03-26-2025, 04:08 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-26-2025, 04:00 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: "I have no idea whatsoever where the growth we need is going to come from"

Nor does Rach.

But we can relax in the knowledge that she is keeping everything crossed

She also misrepresented the OBR's growth upgrades for future years as overall, the OBR judges the cumulative growth in potential output between 2023 and 2029 to be 0.5 per cent lower than it thought last October - even after it's swallowed the fatuous Treasury guesses on the effects of planning reform.

It's a truly dreadful outlook.

(03-26-2025, 04:03 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote: "how low we've sunk. They're out of their depth."

That 14 year amnesia on display again

Did you miss the very first line of this thread?

I didn't but you appear to have forgotten how incompetent and out of their depth your heroes of 2010 -24 were and how low they had sunk.

I never thought that Blair and Co would be something to look back upon nostalgically. But that's a possibility now that we up to 14 and half years of shit show.
Reply
#28
Whats the point of building so many new homes now?

No one will be able to afford them as not exactly affordable are they

All that will do is cause the housing market to crash & negative equity

Just like 1992 all over again

Never fucking learn, the well educated ones that know whats best for us
Reply
#29
(03-26-2025, 08:26 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Whats the point of building so many new homes now?

No one will be able to afford them as not exactly affordable are they

All that will do is cause the housing market to crash & negative equity

Just like 1992 all over again

Never fucking learn, the well educated ones that know whats best for us

We need to build 380,000 houses a year just to stop house prices rising higher than inflation, what the hell are you on about?
Reply
#30
(03-26-2025, 08:30 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-26-2025, 08:26 PM)Pipkins Wrote: Whats the point of building so many new homes now?

No one will be able to afford them as not exactly affordable are they

All that will do is cause the housing market to crash & negative equity

Just like 1992 all over again

Never fucking learn, the well educated ones that know whats best for us

We need to build 380,000 houses a year just to stop house prices rising higher than inflation, what the hell are you on about?

Dave down the pub has had his arse handed to him on a plate with a doily on it.

Look up supply and demand Dave.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: