Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Some believe the government’s aim to tackle the ballooning welfare bill betrays Labour’s roots. But those who forged the Labour Party and the welfare state it created — Labour’s founder Keir Hardie and the great 1945-51 Attlee government — took a far stronger stance on requiring welfare recipients to seek work than is commonly understood now.
Hardie’s 1893 maiden speech as an MP championed help for the unemployed, distinguishing between “loafers” and “bona fide working” people. Hardie’s focus was the “moral degradation of enforced idleness” caused by the cyclical unemployment of unfettered capitalism. He sought opportunities for all to work and support for those who could not, not state welfare paid by workers for those who could work but did not wish to.
The modern welfare state was forged by Labour’s postwar government. Herbert Morrison, the deputy prime minister, framed its domestic programme. He knew that for working-class voters, the belief that hard work and playing by the rules should pay off was strongly held. He told MPs in 1946: “The doctrine that any citizen, even a working-class citizen, has an unconditional right to withdraw money from the state without question [is] contrary to the self-respecting and upright principles of socialism itself.”
For Morrison, the new welfare state was a delicate edifice requiring the buy-in of the majority of voters, who saw themselves as payers-in as well as on occasion takers-out: “The social security state cannot endure,” he told Labour’s 1948 conference, “unless it is also a state of social responsibility.”
A year earlier he had criticised “the drones … useless mouths” and the “defiantly antisocial. We have no hands or brains to waste, and no resources to fritter away on those who don’t contribute to our national effort. Let us point the figure of public scorn at those who make themselves comfortable at the expense of the community.”
Morrison’s targets were not just the aristocrats who consumed but did not produce, and the black-marketeers of the era. In 1937 he had been blunter: “Everybody will be expected to work. Society should be entitled to say to a person who could work but will not work, ‘neither shall he eat’”.
Morrison saw the welfare state and Labour’s full-employment pledge as part of the same virtuous cycle: that those who wanted benefit but did not want to work undermined the potential generosity of the system for those in genuine need.
That is historic Labour, not defending an ever-rising welfare bill come what may.
GREG ROSEN
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-21-2025, 12:06 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-21-2025, 09:39 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: (03-21-2025, 08:43 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-21-2025, 07:41 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Absolutely right SR but if the opposition is anything like the current contenders, they’ll win again. With a reduced majority, inevitably
It will be a hung parliament at best for Labour the massive xxxxx I know that I’m never voting for them again, I just cannot justify kicking the most vulnerable hardest to spare an awful chancellors and PMs blushes.
Labour doesn’t need ‘re-educating’ it needs to remind itself who and what it is supposed to represent and it’s certainly not bullying disabled.
Given the alternatives, do you ever stop and think that Labour are the ones likely to punch downwards with the least force? A genuine question I can't believe I've had to ask, but such is the state of politics in this country.
There are only two parties going to win the next election, if you're not voting for one, then you're enabling the other.
I am sadly only too aware of this but I cannot and will not vote Labour again. This goes beyond least worst, I can’t vote for a party that has stigmatised, traumatised and financially put the boot into the mist vulnerable in society, simply to save the blushes of robotic chancellor and dough faced, conviction free vacuum for a ‘leader’.
There at least was an honesty with Tory’s they almost rejoiced in their nastiness at times (waves at IDS) but Labour pretend to be something they’re clearly not and that is compassionate, caring and decent, when in reality they are the opposite of those things.
Disclaimer I realise there a decent people in both parties but sadly they get drowned out and sidelined by the loudest, sharpest elbowed in the respective parties.
Abysmal state of politics in this country.
You do realise the result of not voting for Labour means under the current system, you'll get the Tories (or Reform). Presume you'll be fine to take that on here if that's the case?
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(03-21-2025, 12:45 PM)Pontificator Wrote: Some believe the government’s aim to tackle the ballooning welfare bill betrays Labour’s roots. But those who forged the Labour Party and the welfare state it created — Labour’s founder Keir Hardie and the great 1945-51 Attlee government — took a far stronger stance on requiring welfare recipients to seek work than is commonly understood now.
Hardie’s 1893 maiden speech as an MP championed help for the unemployed, distinguishing between “loafers” and “bona fide working” people. Hardie’s focus was the “moral degradation of enforced idleness” caused by the cyclical unemployment of unfettered capitalism. He sought opportunities for all to work and support for those who could not, not state welfare paid by workers for those who could work but did not wish to.
The modern welfare state was forged by Labour’s postwar government. Herbert Morrison, the deputy prime minister, framed its domestic programme. He knew that for working-class voters, the belief that hard work and playing by the rules should pay off was strongly held. He told MPs in 1946: “The doctrine that any citizen, even a working-class citizen, has an unconditional right to withdraw money from the state without question [is] contrary to the self-respecting and upright principles of socialism itself.”
For Morrison, the new welfare state was a delicate edifice requiring the buy-in of the majority of voters, who saw themselves as payers-in as well as on occasion takers-out: “The social security state cannot endure,” he told Labour’s 1948 conference, “unless it is also a state of social responsibility.”
A year earlier he had criticised “the drones … useless mouths” and the “defiantly antisocial. We have no hands or brains to waste, and no resources to fritter away on those who don’t contribute to our national effort. Let us point the figure of public scorn at those who make themselves comfortable at the expense of the community.”
Morrison’s targets were not just the aristocrats who consumed but did not produce, and the black-marketeers of the era. In 1937 he had been blunter: “Everybody will be expected to work. Society should be entitled to say to a person who could work but will not work, ‘neither shall he eat’”.
Morrison saw the welfare state and Labour’s full-employment pledge as part of the same virtuous cycle: that those who wanted benefit but did not want to work undermined the potential generosity of the system for those in genuine need.
That is historic Labour, not defending an ever-rising welfare bill come what may.
GREG ROSEN
This.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
(03-21-2025, 12:45 PM)Pontificator Wrote: Some believe the government’s aim to tackle the ballooning welfare bill betrays Labour’s roots. But those who forged the Labour Party and the welfare state it created — Labour’s founder Keir Hardie and the great 1945-51 Attlee government — took a far stronger stance on requiring welfare recipients to seek work than is commonly understood now.
Hardie’s 1893 maiden speech as an MP championed help for the unemployed, distinguishing between “loafers” and “bona fide working” people. Hardie’s focus was the “moral degradation of enforced idleness” caused by the cyclical unemployment of unfettered capitalism. He sought opportunities for all to work and support for those who could not, not state welfare paid by workers for those who could work but did not wish to.
The modern welfare state was forged by Labour’s postwar government. Herbert Morrison, the deputy prime minister, framed its domestic programme. He knew that for working-class voters, the belief that hard work and playing by the rules should pay off was strongly held. He told MPs in 1946: “The doctrine that any citizen, even a working-class citizen, has an unconditional right to withdraw money from the state without question [is] contrary to the self-respecting and upright principles of socialism itself.”
For Morrison, the new welfare state was a delicate edifice requiring the buy-in of the majority of voters, who saw themselves as payers-in as well as on occasion takers-out: “The social security state cannot endure,” he told Labour’s 1948 conference, “unless it is also a state of social responsibility.”
A year earlier he had criticised “the drones … useless mouths” and the “defiantly antisocial. We have no hands or brains to waste, and no resources to fritter away on those who don’t contribute to our national effort. Let us point the figure of public scorn at those who make themselves comfortable at the expense of the community.”
Morrison’s targets were not just the aristocrats who consumed but did not produce, and the black-marketeers of the era. In 1937 he had been blunter: “Everybody will be expected to work. Society should be entitled to say to a person who could work but will not work, ‘neither shall he eat’”.
Morrison saw the welfare state and Labour’s full-employment pledge as part of the same virtuous cycle: that those who wanted benefit but did not want to work undermined the potential generosity of the system for those in genuine need.
That is historic Labour, not defending an ever-rising welfare bill come what may.
GREG ROSEN
This is all very well.
But we are living in an era where there has been a massive transference of wealth from Govts/ordinary joe public to the already very wealthy.
An unintended consequence of well meant govt spending during covid was that the very wealthy saw big increases in their wealth, for example Musk saw his wealth increase by 400% in 2020, whilst many govts oversaw massive increases in the level of their debt.
The ordinary guy at the same time saw their wealth flatline, and then severely erode in the face of the inevitable inflation that followed the ending of the covid lockdown and the Ukranian war.
I don't think it is unreasonable for govts to seek their money back from the super wealthy in the form of at least a one off wealth tax.
As an aside i am always suspicious of politicians who wax lyrical about the dignity of work. How little they know. There is very little dignity in much work that has to be done. And it reminds too much of the slogan above the gates at concentration camps in Nazi Germany...'work will make you free'. Well that was only true if freedom equated to death.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
There hasn't been any transfer of wealth "from governments or ordinary joes" to anyone. What has happened is rampant credit creation, the summoning of money from thin air by institutions to lend at pretty much zero interest rates. If you were in a position to borrow you didn't look a gift horse in the mouth.
So I wonder why it's "fair" to tax that wealth?
Posts: 7,444
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
03-23-2025, 10:30 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-23-2025, 10:31 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
When you have gaslighting as blatant as this from the Chancellor, I’m not surprised…
"What we've seen in these last few months of a Labour gov't is a sustained increase in living standards. Next month people on the national living wage will see a 6.7% increase in wages, only possible because of the stability we've returned to the economy"
Bills are going up, recruitment numbers down, thousands cut from the NHS, callous cuts to the vulnerable sick and disabled, no exemption in NI increases for hospices ffs and don’t we have increased bankruptcies?
Posts: 7,444
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
I don’t imagine anyone going bankrupt is doing so because of what’s happened in half a year
Reeves is a bit autistic and not the greatest to put in front of the media for sure
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
03-23-2025, 11:02 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-23-2025, 11:08 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(03-23-2025, 10:36 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I don’t imagine anyone going bankrupt is doing so because of what’s happened in half a year
Reeves is a bit autistic and not the greatest to put in front of the media for sure
She’s bloody awful and she is throwing people under a bus to save her own blushes.
With regards to bankruptcies, increasing NICs and wages for small businesses in the medium term isn’t going to help anyone. They may need more of these fabled job coaches to miraculously make the disabled, young people and former NHS staff into trainee hod carriers and brickies… or combat drone operatives. That’s about the sum total of Labours ambition or imagination it seems for the U.K. oh that and allowing AI to nick the creative sectors work for nothing.
Posts: 11,922
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(03-23-2025, 09:54 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: https://www.stourbridgenews.co.uk/news/2...arty-week/
Another one bites the dust
Didn’t he used to be Dungeonmaster off the 80s to show of the same name?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
|