Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
03-18-2025, 06:17 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-18-2025, 06:18 PM by Borin' Baggie.)
Right, so we've gone from disastrous to modest and you disagreeing with the data that shows bluntly that business investment flatlined after the 2016 vote in contrast to it's pre-vote upwards trend as outlined in that graph.
Really dispelling my point about you being blinkered over Brexit here, not.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
(03-18-2025, 06:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Right, so we've gone from disastrous to modest and you disagreeing with the data that shows bluntly that business investment flatlined after the 2016 vote in contrast to it's pre-vote upwards trend as outlined in that graph.
Really dispelling my point about you being blinkered over Brexit here, not.
No, that modest cut was just the latest round in a disastrous policy for productivity, wages and asset price inflation.
It's hardly surprising that investment would flatline response to such a change, and a quarter point rate cut is neither here nor there in terms of a policy response to that. Investment returned, and had nothing to do with Carney and everything to do with the fact that the effects of even a flawed Brexit have proved to be modest and manageable.
I'm not entirely sure why you're such a fanboy.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
That graph literally contradicts everything you put, there was linear growth in business investment from 2012 to the Brexit vote despite QE. The flatlining happened after the Brexit vote. Get real.
You are doing what you always do, you've found yourself backing a position and are ignoring all the evidence and trying to distort a narrative on the fly to fit your worldview because you refuse to admit you have no idea what you're on about.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1274...nvestment/
As you can plainly see something happened between June 2016 and COVID, as for your assertion that "investment returned", yes 5 years after the fact when Brexit was a known quantity but nowhere near to the extent it would have been if it had kept up with the trend prior to the vote.
And I'm not being a "fanboy", you're being a pathetic hater and ignoring all the facts because he hurt your precious feelings by calling out Brexit out as the stupid thing it is.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
That proves absolutely nothing about the policy prescription though does it? You're also guessing on what investment might have been after Covid, Ukraine and yes, Brexit friction.
It's hardly surprising there was a brake on business investment as businesses worked out what Brexit would mean for them. Money was already essentially "free", so making it even more free achieved nothing but to further inflate asset markets - like housing.
If I could be "hurt" by my views on Brexit, or indeed anything else for that matter then I wouldn't be posting on here. Gen Xers tend to be made of sterner stuff you see. I also care deeply about the effects of suppressed interest rates for the future of this country.
Posts: 6,720
Threads: 355
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation:
40
(03-19-2025, 06:46 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: That graph literally contradicts everything you put, there was linear growth in business investment from 2012 to the Brexit vote despite QE. The flatlining happened after the Brexit vote. Get real.
You are doing what you always do, you've found yourself backing a position and are ignoring all the evidence and trying to distort a narrative on the fly to fit your worldview because you refuse to admit you have no idea what you're on about.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/1274...nvestment/
As you can plainly see something happened between June 2016 and COVID, as for your assertion that "investment returned", yes 5 years after the fact when Brexit was a known quantity but nowhere near to the extent it would have been if it had kept up with the trend prior to the vote.
And I'm not being a "fanboy", you're being a pathetic hater and ignoring all the facts because he hurt your precious feelings by calling out Brexit out as the stupid thing it is.
ignoring all the evidence and trying to distort a narrative on the fly to fit your worldview
This is what cultists of all ilks do. As well as saying that they are never wrong, such is their unshakeable faith - irrespective of how irrational it is.
Hayek - what an ideology to hang your whole world view on. Hayek was a cunt.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
03-19-2025, 08:37 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-19-2025, 08:40 AM by Borin' Baggie.)
(03-19-2025, 08:12 AM)Protheroe Wrote: That proves absolutely nothing about the policy prescription though does it? You're also guessing on what investment might have been after Covid, Ukraine and yes, Brexit friction.
It's hardly surprising there was a brake on business investment as businesses worked out what Brexit would mean for them. Money was already essentially "free", so making it even more free achieved nothing but to further inflate asset markets - like housing.
If I could be "hurt" by my views on Brexit, or indeed anything else for that matter then I wouldn't be posting on here. Gen Xers tend to be made of sterner stuff you see. I also care deeply about the effects of suppressed interest rates for the future of this country.
Thanks for effectively saying that you didn't bother looking at the graph. Chart 4.8 only goes to 2019, look at it. I suppose ignoring even looking at the evidence is one way to pretend it doesn't directly contradict your argument, but to spell it out COVID and the war in Ukraine didn't happen in 2016 and wouldn't be shown on a graph that stops in 2019, would they?
And QE in 2012/2013 didn't cause business investment to flatline, so that argument makes no sense. How would the cause and effect of a much smaller round of QE be significantly more impactful than a much larger round on business investment?
People made of "sterner stuff" have the guts to accept they have no idea what they're on about when faced with the facts. You do not, even though the facts directly contradict your assertion and your opinions are based on what you want to have happened instead of what actually happened.
As for you caring about suppressed interest rates, you were the one who campaigned for no infrastructure investment - a policy that suppressed inflation and meant that the BoE couldn't raise interest rates - well after the effect was known. You don't get to externalise the effects of the policies you supported, that's not how this works.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
I did look at the chart. You're clearly interpreting it in a very different way to me.
I haven't ever argued that QE "caused business investment to flatline", I never campaigned for "no infrastructure investment" are you confusing me with someone else?
As you don't seem to understand my point - which is wholly about the chilling effect of the long term suppression of interest rates on productivity, wages and asset price inflation (which I don't believe is open to debate these days) then I'm not sure you can claim your chart "directly" contradicts my argument. Once again, you've decided what you believe my argument is - classic WBAunofficial.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-19-2025, 09:19 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I did look at the chart. You're clearly interpreting it in a very different way to me.
I haven't ever argued that QE "caused business investment to flatline", I never campaigned for "no infrastructure investment" are you confusing me with someone else?
As you don't seem to understand my point - which is wholly about the chilling effect of the long term suppression of interest rates on productivity, wages and asset price inflation (which I don't believe is open to debate these days) then I'm not sure you can claim your chart "directly" contradicts my argument. Once again, you've decided what you believe my argument is - classic WBAunofficial.
If after the best part of a decade of debating it no one seems to know what your argument is then perhaps it's a you problem, Proth.
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(03-19-2025, 09:19 AM)Protheroe Wrote: I did look at the chart. You're clearly interpreting it in a very different way to me.
I haven't ever argued that QE "caused business investment to flatline", I never campaigned for "no infrastructure investment" are you confusing me with someone else?
As you don't seem to understand my point - which is wholly about the chilling effect of the long term suppression of interest rates on productivity, wages and asset price inflation (which I don't believe is open to debate these days) then I'm not sure you can claim your chart "directly" contradicts my argument. Once again, you've decided what you believe my argument is - classic WBAunofficial.
How can you possibly interpret a graph that ends at 2019 as being the result COVID and the invasion of Ukraine?
You campaigned for low public investment as pushed for by the Conservatives, especially in 2015 and 2017, when increased public investment through borrowing for infrastructure investment would have pushed up inflation in-turn enabling rate rises because the average inflation rate between 2013 and 2020 was 1.4% and that's not high enough to enable rate rises when you're targeting 2% inflation, with deflation being economically disastrous.
And I fully get your point, that's why I brought up that 90% of QE (excluding inflation, otherwise it's more) being before Carney became BoE governor and that's why I have pointed out the effects of fiscal policy on low inflation. It's also why I brought up what the BoC was doing under Carney, which is literally exactly what you wanted - no QE and bold rate rises. It's not my fault that you have a grudge against Carney that means you don't want to countenance the facts.
|