How insulting and disrespectful dies this Labour want to be?
#61
Sorry mate, still lost. You said “it doesn’t seem like it’s been dropped” - what were you referring to?
Reply
#62
(03-18-2025, 01:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Sorry mate, still lost. You said “it doesn’t seem like it’s been dropped” - what were you referring to?

The threat to restrict access to PIP who, under a Tory government, have been deemed ill enough to warrant it.  The paper references the need for claimants to be able to score 4 to qualify but, as far as I can see, doesn't describe how someone reaches a 4.  And, even if it did, anyone with experience of working in the public sector will tell you it's less about what is written but how the technocrats and bureaucrats interpret the words, often under the direction of the relevant secretary of state.

The threat has been leaked to the press, it has caused a partial climbdown thanks to some within the party who remain true to ethos of leftism, but the threat is still there and, only through application, will either of us be proved right or wrong.  £5bn says I'm right.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#63
(03-18-2025, 01:52 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: £5bn says I'm right.

If the proposed reforms save half that I'll be amazed.
Reply
#64
(03-18-2025, 01:58 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-18-2025, 01:52 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: £5bn says I'm right.

If the proposed reforms save half that I'll be amazed.

Quite.  And at what cost £2.5bn?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#65
(03-18-2025, 01:52 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(03-18-2025, 01:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Sorry mate, still lost. You said “it doesn’t seem like it’s been dropped” - what were you referring to?

The threat to restrict access to PIP who, under a Tory government, have been deemed ill enough to warrant it.  The paper references the need for claimants to be able to score 4 to qualify but, as far as I can see, doesn't describe how someone reaches a 4.  And, even if it did, anyone with experience of working in the public sector will tell you it's less about what is written but how the technocrats and bureaucrats interpret the words, often under the direction of the relevant secretary of state.

The threat has been leaked to the press, it has caused a partial climbdown thanks to some within the party who remain true to ethos of leftism, but the threat is still there and, only through application, will either of us be proved right or wrong.  £5bn says I'm right.

Don't need to be in the public sector, I work with them and it's so annoying having to rewrite stuff to meet the seemingly arbitrary criteria used by DESNZ, oftentimes a lot of public investment into infrastructure is tied up into this crap.

Keeping on PIP, I can forsee that the people who know how to game the system will be fine but the people who are in genuine need are honest will struggle which is already the case.
Reply
#66
(03-18-2025, 02:10 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-18-2025, 01:52 PM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(03-18-2025, 01:41 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Sorry mate, still lost. You said “it doesn’t seem like it’s been dropped” - what were you referring to?

The threat to restrict access to PIP who, under a Tory government, have been deemed ill enough to warrant it.  The paper references the need for claimants to be able to score 4 to qualify but, as far as I can see, doesn't describe how someone reaches a 4.  And, even if it did, anyone with experience of working in the public sector will tell you it's less about what is written but how the technocrats and bureaucrats interpret the words, often under the direction of the relevant secretary of state.

The threat has been leaked to the press, it has caused a partial climbdown thanks to some within the party who remain true to ethos of leftism, but the threat is still there and, only through application, will either of us be proved right or wrong.  £5bn says I'm right.

Don't need to be in the public sector, I work with them and it's so annoying having to rewrite stuff to meet the seemingly arbitrary criteria used by DESNZ, oftentimes a lot of public investment into infrastructure is tied up into this crap.

Keeping on PIP, I can forsee that the people who know how to game the system will be fine but the people who are in genuine need are honest will struggle which is already the case.

And that last point is key.  My wife (mah wiiiife) does the DLA/PIP assessment forms for our daughter and it's clear to me that your a) education level b) level of English c) degree of perseverance d) ability to interpret what assessors are looking for - all of which are linked to class/income - go a long way to determining whether your application is successful or not.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#67
I would suggest it’s as much aimed at rejecting a larger portion of the current (new application) backlog than anything.

They are a year behind with current reviews - 1m so that’s about 3m to get through in 2 years

That’s the mess that was left to pick up
Reply
#68
Looking at the proposals. This will not be complete in this Parliament imo. It will take at least a decade to merge ESA and JSA, supposed to be two now almost entirely contributory benefits but there are still over 600k people in receipt of ESA(IR) which muddies the waters. There were after all still people in receipt of IB some 15 years after it was replaced...

The DWP are not good with change, they never have been. The Universal Credit rollout was an architectural failure for years and years, they were working the claims out in excel because the bespoke IT system didn't work.

Pleased I was wrong and PIP will be uprated as usual. The change to scoring, you currently only need 8 points across the full range of 10 activities. Now you will only need 4, but in at least one of the activities. This isn't the sweeping reform it sounds like and reaching 4 points in one activity is easily gamed. I just don't see that this is going to reduce the numbers on the scale they want.

The removal of incapacity uplift (premium) to UC for under 23s is an interesting move and if it can be coded quickly could make a difference, however, are they going to remove it from under 23s that already receive it (ie reduce their benefit)? Or is it for future claims?

The right to try work scheme. Again it's more the technical side that will be the issue, people regularly lose UC payments if the month has 5 part time work paydays in it as opposed to 4. Is this workable within the current system? Again if this needs to be done clerically it'll be bedlam in the Benefit Centres.

The whole thing looks a bit of a mess to me, at the very least logistically if not holistically and I'm glad it's no longer on my plate, as it were.
Reply
#69
So, a 19 year old with a severe disability doesn't get UC uplift even though they may have left FTE? Wouldn't that reduce the chance of studying or employment (travel, meals etc)? What if they've left home and can't get support from their family? Doesn't sound very 'enabling'.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#70
As said above, it’ll be a 5 year plus fuck about sorting this out, by which time we’ll probably be on to a new PM and a new policy. The welfare system is like the shittest game of pass the parcel ever
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)