How insulting and disrespectful dies this Labour want to be?
#41
It’s ok to just say “I got it wrong” Derek and celebrate these improvements
Reply
#42
(03-18-2025, 08:23 AM)Squid Wrote:
(03-17-2025, 10:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-17-2025, 09:34 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-17-2025, 08:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-17-2025, 07:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The increase from 360k people of working age in 2019 to 1.28M people in 2024 on disability benefits for Mental and Behavioural conditions is unsustainable Dekka, something has to be done. If nothing is done that figure is only going on one direction. What would you suggest is done to address that problem because simply throwing money at it isn't working.

Well for a start I’d start by trying to understand the reasons and addressing them. I’d also listen to experts rather than dubious think tanks and advisers and thirdly I wouldn’t dress the current austerity proposals up as anything other than what they are. 

Where are all these disability friendly jobs coming from? Where is the the support for businesses to employ people with disabilities? Job coaches fuck off, a few patronising pens are friends workers isn’t going to solve anything. All you do by cutting benefit is trap people in poverty. 

Labour supporters and activists can dress this up the cuts anyway you like these are right of centre Tory policies… Wes Streeting missing the point, as the benefit cut bought tank is parked on Tory lawns, the question is what is the point of Labour?

Kevin McGuire

So you agree it's unsustainable, you just disagree about how to fix it.

That Mirror article is filler (and nigh on unreadable as it's festooned with ads) which complains about the winter fuel allowance cut and WASPI women all in the same breath. Just saying "Look over there" isn't an answer.

Labour aren’t offering answers they are offering cuts the two aren’t the same thing. Where are the jobs for the disabled? Where are the employers willing to pay for their access? Where are the employers who are willing to take a chance in a long term mental health patient? 

There is a problem with young people not working, I’m not going to deny that or the fact and I’m sceptical about people saying they have anxiety or adhd or behavioural issues and can’t work etc. I said that last week. 

Where I have a problem when they offer no real solutions to the genuinely disabled as where and how they can get a job, cause unnecessary alarm and distress without the good grace to either confirm or deny reports about freezing PIP for the most disabled and sick.

My opinions align with Andy Burnham

He wrote: “I would share concerns about changing support and eligibility to benefits while leaving the top-down system broadly in place. It would trap too many people in poverty.

“And to be clear: there is no case in any scenario for cutting the support available to disabled people who are unable to work.”

Derek, you keep talking about the disabled. Are people recieving PIP for mental health/behavioural reasons disabled?

I am not a mental health expert so I don’t know, which is why experts should be consulted. My scepticism may well be misplaced.

(03-18-2025, 09:44 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: It’s ok to just say “I got it wrong” Derek and celebrate these improvements

I didn’t get anything wrong this entire thread was about not having the good grace to put people’s minds at rest when they could and should have. Do you think this was the original plan or do you think the report on ITV has galvanised a response against the proposal? That’s the crux of the issue.

The wider points still stand, where are the jobs that those deemed fit to work are going to get? Are there plans to make employers make their companies more accessible or employ a percentage of people that disabled? Will there be grants to make offices/homes more accessible to work in?

I agree that taking those who will never work out of the ludicrous and expensive assessment merry-go-round is a good idea. I have been banging on about this for years on here.
Reply
#43
That’s how these things work. Always have, always will. I’m more focused on outcomes (which are good) than 3 weeks of moral panics
Reply
#44
(03-18-2025, 09:54 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: That’s how these things work. Always have, always will. I’m more focused on outcomes (which are good) than 3 weeks of moral panics

With respect if you know people who haven’t been able to sleep properly through worry and stress because of these changes you might think differently. This hasn’t been three weeks it’s been months of briefings to the press. It still doesn’t as see the question whether they rowed back or it was never part of the plan. It was within the gift of the government to quash rumours three weeks ago, they didn’t, you can then draw your own conclusions what has happened.
Reply
#45
I pointed out above that the last time the government quashed rumours they tied themselves in knots with taxation. They have learned from that and stuck to the premise that they will announce the detail at the planned time. Your panic may have been misplaced based on believing everything in the press and the press had a vested interest in wanting answers before they were to be announced because it would give them clicks and a scoop.

Learn to read the room a bit more Dekka, and don’t turn into the next JOK or Chunk. And pack in the personal jibes as well.
Reply
#46
(03-18-2025, 10:01 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-18-2025, 09:54 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: That’s how these things work. Always have, always will. I’m more focused on outcomes (which are good) than 3 weeks of moral panics

With respect if you know people who haven’t been able to sleep properly through worry and stress because of these changes you might think differently. This hasn’t been three weeks it’s been months of briefings to the press. It still doesn’t as see the question whether they rowed back or it was never part of the plan. It was within the gift of the government to quash rumours three weeks ago, they didn’t, you can then draw your own conclusions what has happened.

My conclusions are the people you and I were concerned about are even more protected now than they were before. They no longer have to live under the cloud of needless reassessment and haven’t lost any uprating. No government announces the conclusion of the policy until it is ready. That’s life.
Reply
#47
As I understand they still haven't announced anything yet... Reducing/removing reassessment for a very small cohort while good is likely to be the thick end of the wedge. I'll be amazed if PIP isn't frozen for at least this year, with more frequent reassessments for the vast majority announced.

Reading between the lines those in the WRA group for ESA/UC may get a modest increase.
Reply
#48
Full of bad Tories on here Dekka. Keep the shoe going lad.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#49
PIP won’t be frozen. Reassessments will be more frequent but given most of the current outstanding reassessments are around a year overdue this is an area that needs tackling for two years just to stand still
Reply
#50
Shami chakrabati nailed them on this
And ain't it the truth?

https://bsky.app/profile/peterstefanovic...md6pa2es24
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)