How insulting and disrespectful dies this Labour want to be?
#31
‘You didn’t answer the question’ straight after being asked what you think is the reason for such a large increase and is it sustainable - the irony is not lost on most on here. My stance is the same, you’re moaning about something that hasn’t happened.
Reply
#32
(03-17-2025, 08:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: ‘You didn’t answer the question’ straight after being asked what you think is the reason for such a large increase and is it sustainable - the irony is not lost on most on here. My stance is the same, you’re moaning about something that hasn’t happened.

Let’s be honest if Kier kicked you in the nuts you’d say thank you.
Reply
#33
And that’s why people struggle to take you seriously. You get an idea and run with it no matter what the facts. You’ve spent years on here moaning about everything and not once provided a solution.
Reply
#34
(03-17-2025, 08:52 PM)baggy1 Wrote: And that’s why people struggle to take you seriously. You get an idea and run with it no matter what the facts. You’ve spent years on here moaning about everything and not once provided a solution.

I’m liking this playing to the gallery B1. You haven’t provided any facts or solutions you’ve regurgitated Labour Party spin. You don’t like people criticising Labour, I don’t like Labour becoming a Tory Party.
Reply
#35
(03-17-2025, 08:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-17-2025, 07:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The increase from 360k people of working age in 2019 to 1.28M people in 2024 on disability benefits for Mental and Behavioural conditions is unsustainable Dekka, something has to be done. If nothing is done that figure is only going on one direction. What would you suggest is done to address that problem because simply throwing money at it isn't working.

Well for a start I’d start by trying to understand the reasons and addressing them. I’d also listen to experts rather than dubious think tanks and advisers and thirdly I wouldn’t dress the current austerity proposals up as anything other than what they are. 

Where are all these disability friendly jobs coming from? Where is the the support for businesses to employ people with disabilities? Job coaches fuck off, a few patronising pens are friends workers isn’t going to solve anything. All you do by cutting benefit is trap people in poverty. 

Labour supporters and activists can dress this up the cuts anyway you like these are right of centre Tory policies… Wes Streeting missing the point, as the benefit cut bought tank is parked on Tory lawns, the question is what is the point of Labour?

Kevin McGuire

So you agree it's unsustainable, you just disagree about how to fix it.

That Mirror article is filler (and nigh on unreadable as it's festooned with ads) which complains about the winter fuel allowance cut and WASPI women all in the same breath. Just saying "Look over there" isn't an answer.
Reply
#36
And anyone that tries to point out the reality is ‘playing to the gallery’
Reply
#37
(03-17-2025, 09:34 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-17-2025, 08:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-17-2025, 07:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The increase from 360k people of working age in 2019 to 1.28M people in 2024 on disability benefits for Mental and Behavioural conditions is unsustainable Dekka, something has to be done. If nothing is done that figure is only going on one direction. What would you suggest is done to address that problem because simply throwing money at it isn't working.

Well for a start I’d start by trying to understand the reasons and addressing them. I’d also listen to experts rather than dubious think tanks and advisers and thirdly I wouldn’t dress the current austerity proposals up as anything other than what they are. 

Where are all these disability friendly jobs coming from? Where is the the support for businesses to employ people with disabilities? Job coaches fuck off, a few patronising pens are friends workers isn’t going to solve anything. All you do by cutting benefit is trap people in poverty. 

Labour supporters and activists can dress this up the cuts anyway you like these are right of centre Tory policies… Wes Streeting missing the point, as the benefit cut bought tank is parked on Tory lawns, the question is what is the point of Labour?

Kevin McGuire

So you agree it's unsustainable, you just disagree about how to fix it.

That Mirror article is filler (and nigh on unreadable as it's festooned with ads) which complains about the winter fuel allowance cut and WASPI women all in the same breath. Just saying "Look over there" isn't an answer.

Labour aren’t offering answers they are offering cuts the two aren’t the same thing. Where are the jobs for the disabled? Where are the employers willing to pay for their access? Where are the employers who are willing to take a chance in a long term mental health patient? 

There is a problem with young people not working, I’m not going to deny that or the fact and I’m sceptical about people saying they have anxiety or adhd or behavioural issues and can’t work etc. I said that last week. 

Where I have a problem when they offer no real solutions to the genuinely disabled as where and how they can get a job, cause unnecessary alarm and distress without the good grace to either confirm or deny reports about freezing PIP for the most disabled and sick.

My opinions align with Andy Burnham

He wrote: “I would share concerns about changing support and eligibility to benefits while leaving the top-down system broadly in place. It would trap too many people in poverty.

“And to be clear: there is no case in any scenario for cutting the support available to disabled people who are unable to work.”
Reply
#38
(03-17-2025, 10:24 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-17-2025, 09:34 PM)Squid Wrote:
(03-17-2025, 08:04 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-17-2025, 07:55 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The increase from 360k people of working age in 2019 to 1.28M people in 2024 on disability benefits for Mental and Behavioural conditions is unsustainable Dekka, something has to be done. If nothing is done that figure is only going on one direction. What would you suggest is done to address that problem because simply throwing money at it isn't working.

Well for a start I’d start by trying to understand the reasons and addressing them. I’d also listen to experts rather than dubious think tanks and advisers and thirdly I wouldn’t dress the current austerity proposals up as anything other than what they are. 

Where are all these disability friendly jobs coming from? Where is the the support for businesses to employ people with disabilities? Job coaches fuck off, a few patronising pens are friends workers isn’t going to solve anything. All you do by cutting benefit is trap people in poverty. 

Labour supporters and activists can dress this up the cuts anyway you like these are right of centre Tory policies… Wes Streeting missing the point, as the benefit cut bought tank is parked on Tory lawns, the question is what is the point of Labour?

Kevin McGuire

So you agree it's unsustainable, you just disagree about how to fix it.

That Mirror article is filler (and nigh on unreadable as it's festooned with ads) which complains about the winter fuel allowance cut and WASPI women all in the same breath. Just saying "Look over there" isn't an answer.

Labour aren’t offering answers they are offering cuts the two aren’t the same thing. Where are the jobs for the disabled? Where are the employers willing to pay for their access? Where are the employers who are willing to take a chance in a long term mental health patient? 

There is a problem with young people not working, I’m not going to deny that or the fact and I’m sceptical about people saying they have anxiety or adhd or behavioural issues and can’t work etc. I said that last week. 

Where I have a problem when they offer no real solutions to the genuinely disabled as where and how they can get a job, cause unnecessary alarm and distress without the good grace to either confirm or deny reports about freezing PIP for the most disabled and sick.

My opinions align with Andy Burnham

He wrote: “I would share concerns about changing support and eligibility to benefits while leaving the top-down system broadly in place. It would trap too many people in poverty.

“And to be clear: there is no case in any scenario for cutting the support available to disabled people who are unable to work.”

Derek, you keep talking about the disabled. Are people recieving PIP for mental health/behavioural reasons disabled?
Reply
#39
So it turns out things will improve for the most vulnerable as they will have re assessments scrapped altogether.

Why it’s best to wait for the facts rather than 3 weeks of guessing.
Reply
#40
(03-18-2025, 09:06 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: So it turns out things will improve for the most vulnerable as they will have re assessments scrapped altogether.

Why it’s best to wait for the facts rather than 3 weeks of guessing.

Let’s be clear Labour could have quashed the rumours at any time and chose not to. Also as Labour Peer Baroness Chakrabati said on Newsnight those within the government or advising them should not be briefing the press about proposals when they know full well what distress that will cause. Now you can call her a liar and you can call others liars for saying the government have rowed back on the PIP plans if you want but it changes little, either it was the plan and they’ve had to row back on it because they were alarmed at the push back or they simply didn’t have the good grace or empathy to put people’s mind at rest.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)