Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
03-17-2025, 03:00 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-17-2025, 03:09 PM by SausEggBaton.)
"Abbott claims a 2% “wealth tax” on people with assets over £10 million would raise £24 billion a year."
"Challenged over whether such a move could have negative economic effects - for example, by encouraging wealthy people to leave the UK - she says it “shouldn’t have some massive effect”."
Let's rationalise the logic in this for a second here, if you will.
2% of £10M is 200K
£24Bn / 200K is 120K
By that assertion, there are over 120,000 people in the UK with over £10 Million in assets?
There are roughly 3.6 Million peope on PIP payments, so that means, Diane would like 0.03% (or there abouts) of the amount of people to pay for bill f 3.6 Million people?
In a recent study, people on PIP received on average £6,900 per year - by that factor, 3.6 Million people on average costs £24.8Bn per year in PIP payments.
Therefore - I see where Diane gets that £24Bn can be generated by people with over £10 Million, however considering the "Ultra-Wealthy" is about 10,000 people in the UK (based on research), how does Diane expect 10,000 people to pay for 3.6 Million people? Incidently meaning each of those 10,000 people would foot the bill of £2.48 Million per year for those 3.6 Million people, based on Diane's maths....
If her very silly suggestion comes to fruition, I'd imagine 10,000 of those 10,000 ultra-wealthy people will find somewhere else to reside on this planet, if they do not already.
Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(03-17-2025, 03:00 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: "Abbott claims a 2% “wealth tax” on people with assets over £10 million would raise £24 billion a year."
"Challenged over whether such a move could have negative economic effects - for example, by encouraging wealthy people to leave the UK - she says it “shouldn’t have some massive effect”."
Let's rationalise the logic in this for a second here, if you will.
2% of £10M is 200K
£24Bn / 200K is 120K
By that assertion, there are over 120,000 people in the UK with over £10 Million in assets?
There are roughly 3.6 Million peope on PIP payments, so that means, Diane would like 0.03% (or there abouts) of the amount of people to pay for bill f 3.6 Million people?
In a recent study, people on PIP received on average £6,900 per year - by that factor, 3.6 Million people on average costs £24.8Bn per year in PIP payments.
Therefore - I see where Diane gets that £24Bn can be generated by people with over £10 Million, however considering the "Ultra-Wealthy" is about 10,000 people in the UK (based on research), how does Diane expect 10,000 people to pay for 3.6 Million people? Incidently meaning each of those 10,000 people would foot the bill of £2.48 Million per year for those 3.6 Million people, based on Diane's maths....
If her very silly suggestion comes to fruition, I'd imagine 10,000 of those 10,000 ultra-wealthy people will find somewhere else to reside on this planet, if they do not already.
You've asked a moral question, not a mathematical one.
The Sunday Times Rich list indicates that billionaires (not the £10millionnaires mentioned) have a combined wealth of £795bn. 2% of which is £16bn. Presumably the rest is based on those with assets of £10m+.
So, the question is whether someone with £10m (the most deprived in the subject group) should be expected to pay £200k to stop the most struggling in society from struggling more.
For context, that's 4 months interest (at 6%) on £10m. Or, in the interests of balance, it is the cost of something that someone who has £10m hasn't bought yet - ie a shit yacht or a statue of themselves.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
How does a 2% tax translate to a fixed fee of £200k? That's not how percentages work.
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
(03-17-2025, 03:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How does a 2% tax translate to a fixed fee of £200k? That's not how percentages work.
Indeed, so how is Diane's 2% tax on 10,000 people with over £10 Million in assets, costing them £2.48 Million a year going work out for her?
Is she just going to rock up at their palatial mansion, knock the door and say, "Good morning you owe the government £2.48 Million, because you live in and own this massive house."
Posts: 7,717
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Probably need to take the word mathematics out of the title of this thread tbh...
Posts: 13,568
Threads: 492
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
40
(03-17-2025, 03:43 PM)SausEggBaton Wrote: (03-17-2025, 03:34 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: How does a 2% tax translate to a fixed fee of £200k? That's not how percentages work.
Indeed, so how is Diane's 2% tax on 10,000 people with over £10 Million in assets, costing them £2.48 Million a year going work out for her?
Is she just going to rock up at their palatial mansion, knock the door and say, "Good morning you owe the government £2.48 Million, because you live in and own this massive house."
Again, Saus, that's not how percentages work.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
I wish we'd leave the billionaires alone.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
Won’t someone think of the multimillionaires and Billionaires! They got there by hardwork, all by themselves without any help from others.
Posts: 11,928
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
(03-17-2025, 03:47 PM)Jacko Wrote: Probably need to take the word mathematics out of the title of this thread tbh...
It's like Rain Man has had a stroke.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
Discussing a wealth tax is a very sensible idea. Having Diane Abbott having any involvement probably isn’t.
|