Just back (ratings)
#1
Wildsmith 6 cost us 2 points, earned us 1.
Barts 6 spends too much time berating team mates, then being out of position 
Heggo 5 worst game he’s had for us
Hols 5 stop with the flash shit ans do the simple well
MJ 5 no end product, no shots
Price 7 great goal, no wide man though
Mows 6 passenger
Swift 5 poor, corners absolutely dreadful
Molumby 6 not in anyone’s head today
AA 4 more anonymous than anything else
Grant 6 confidence he had under CC had disappeared 
Fellows 6 looks shot under TM
Diang 5 normal no show
Dike 5 no impact
Lang 5 see above

TM 
For all the love of the Leeds and Burnley results, he’s got this horrendously wrong.
I’d be surprised if we make the playoffs with this busted flush in charge. And if we do, we’ll be beat by 2 legs by anyone currently in the playoff mix.
Reply
#2
I think you mean Wildsmith cost us 2 points, not 3!

Wildsmith - 5
Price - 8
Holgate - 5
Bartley - 4
Heggem - 6
Grant - 6
Mowatt - 6
Molumby - 6
Johnston - 7
Swift - 5
Armstrong - 2

CBA with rating the subs - no one really had an impact positive or negative.
Reply
#3
All I'd say there Josh is that Johnston's twinkly feet but total absence of end product don't get him a 7.
Reply
#4
How is Wildsmith getting those marks ? Is he being blamed for the goal today ? I need to see it back then because it didn’t appear to be his fault at all from my view.

I would have svored him an 8 or 9 & I wanted him dropped.
Reply
#5
Wildsmith 6 - It's a goal scored from a yard out without him being out of position so there is some culpability, a good save at the end after the Holgate fuck up.

Price 6 - He's not a fullback so I'm not going to hammer him, gets his goal but has to do better with the initial cross for the equaliser.
Holgate 5 - He's got an error in him most games, Wildsmith bailed him out.
Bartley 5 - I've took off a point for that 30 yarder. I don't blame him for the goal, the last thing he'd be expecting is Palmer to get that against 2 players and then Wildsmith to bottle the physical challenge of clearing the scorer out.
Heggem 5 - Despite early season he's also not a full back, maybe under a Pulis or as we saw Corberan, but not when he's getting passes zipped into him and his 2nd touch is a tackle.

Molumby 5 - Anonymous, if there is no niggle to the game the lad is invisible, poor on the ball and hardly makes a tackle.
Mowatt 6 - Kept us ticking over but nothing more.
Swift 6.5 - Hit the bar, made some key passes, probably MOTM but it's a low bar.

Armstrong 5 - Missed another half chance (when will we create this lad a tap in?), some good hold-up play, he can't be happy with the service he's getting. Frustrating.
Grant 5 - Full of endeavour but little quality, hammers every crossing opportunity instead of picking a player out, never looked like scoring and hasn't for a few games.
Johnston 6 - Provided an outlet despite being double and triple marked at times. No end product/greedy for the most part.

Fellows 6 - No real impact but did nothing to lose a point. Doesn't get enough crosses in  when Dike is on the pitch.
Diangana 6 - Played very deep, going like for like with Swift, decent headed attempt with Dike blocking his view, some nice passing.

Dike 6 - Again no service, the one time they did find him it was in a dreadful position for a headed attempt on goal.

Lankshear 5 - What does he offer? Miscontrolled the ball twice and that's it in albeit only 9 minutes of football.
Reply
#6
(03-15-2025, 05:26 PM)ericlegrisly Wrote: All I'd say there Josh is that Johnston's twinkly feet but total absence of end product don't get him a 7.

I'll be interested to see what others say. I thought he had a good game! Provided width and creativity. A lot of chances and good periods of play came from our left hand side where MJ was involved.
Reply
#7
Wildsmith did nothing wrong today and saved out bacon at the end. Some of you are pathetic.
Reply
#8
(03-15-2025, 05:35 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Wildsmith did nothing wrong today and saved out bacon at the end. Some of you are pathetic.

Now is the time to label him a spacegoat if anyone’s interested.!
Reply
#9
(03-15-2025, 05:35 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Wildsmith did nothing wrong today and saved out bacon at the end. Some of you are pathetic.

I am glad someone agrees because I thought he had no chance with goal.
Reply
#10
(03-15-2025, 05:35 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Wildsmith did nothing wrong today and saved out bacon at the end. Some of you are pathetic.

He was at fault for the goal.

The double save needn’t have been so if he’d dealt with initial shot properly instead of parrying it out to a striker.

The one on one at the end was down to a poor striker not good goalkeeping.

He’s shit - deal with it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)