Posts: 8,954
Threads: 166
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
77
Just so I can keep up, are the Labour Party selling off the NHS and all of its data now?
Posts: 11,931
Threads: 798
Joined: Oct 2022
Reputation:
50
From the Health Service Journal
A few hours after Sir Jim Mackey told trust CEOs that NHS England was to be abolished, its outgoing chair Richard Meddings held his leaving do in the same room.
It was – as you would imagine – a strange affair in many ways.
However, looking at the assembled leadership of the service, one overarching fact became abundantly clear.
Almost everyone who holds a position of influence and power in the NHS at a national and regional level or within an integrated care board is now either: about to leave; uncertain whether they will have a job in a few months; about to find themselves with new bosses; or in a new job which they did not expect to be doing as late as last month or even last week.
If you wanted to create a more distracting environment ahead of what will be one of the most difficult years in NHS history it is hard to think how you might do a better job.
As one very senior figure with much knowledge of how the centre works commented to HSJ in the wake of the announcement: “Well, that’s financial oversight of 2025-26 shot to shit.” Sir Jim will hope to mitigate it by having rapidly chosen a heavyweight finance director, to be formally announced in coming days.
Others commented that any meaningful progress on the government’s “three shifts” was now likely to be swamped by the focus on re-organisation.
The obvious follow-up question is why the government took such a series of hasty decisions. It is not because they thought it would benefit the NHS, although they have no doubt convinced themselves it will.
The demise of NHSE has been clear from before the election and, as HSJ noted, reached a tipping point at the start of this year. There was little pushback – even from NHSE – although those who were best placed to know, cautioned against moving too quickly.
But these warnings were trumped (pun intended) by the rapidly changing macro-political and economic events. The government suddenly needed to save money and be seen to be taking bold steps on public service reform. What better “two birds with one stone” move than to scrap “the world’s biggest quango”.
NHSE was sacrificed in the cause of defining “Starmer-ism”.
This approach resulted in some truly ridiculous framing of the move and Sir Jim’s accompanying “financial reset”, in which it was suggested to trust CEOs that the governor of the Bank of England had been spooked by the first cut of NHS financial plans for next year.
Winners and losers
Away from the centre, there are clear winners and losers from the events of the last three weeks.
Even the most active and influential champions of integrated care boards are admitting they have “lost”. Whatever “strategic commissioning” may come to mean, it will have to be much less ambitious than was originally planned.
It may well be that neighbourhood or place is where the 10-Year Plan seeks to drive change. However, the organisations in charge of most of that change will be providers not ICBs. Welcome to the age of the Local Care Organisation (nee Accountable Care Organisation).
It is partly because providers feel firmly in the ascendant, that they are now more sanguine about the financial challenge, despite Sir Jim effectively giving them the same message as outgoing NHSE finance director Julian Kelly that “the money is the money”.
What trust CEOs might not like so much is increased political interference. Readers will have their own views on how an effective a buffer between government and the service the Pritchard-era NHSE was, but there is good evidence it did challenge ministerial overreach on occasion.
This will not be the case from now on. That is not because Sir Jim is incapable of speaking truth to power, it is due simply to the fact that it’s not the job he has been asked – and chosen – to do.
Of course, the enthusiasm that Mr Streeting, his ministers and officials might currently feel for taking up the reins of power is likely to soon pall once they come to terms with the accountability that comes with it.
The focus now turns to Penny Dash and Alan Milburn, who have been given the task of stitching NHSE and the Department of Health and Social Care together. Ironically, given the cards they have been dealt, their best approach is to move as quickly as possible to reduce the uncertainty. However, even they cannot change employment law and how it is applied in circumstances such as these – which may well undermine the October target date for cutting staffing by half.
A wise commentator on HSJ.co.uk remarked that the government’s acceleration of NHSE’s end had “political triumph” and “operational car crash” written all over.
But maybe it was Marxist philosopher Antonio Gramsci that best summed up the position the NHS now finds itself in. He wrote in his Prison Notebooks that: “The old world is dying, and the new world struggles to be born: now is the time of monsters.”
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
All that needs to happen is fixing primary and fixing social care. If that happens, the saving will look after themselves.