Swift
#11
(03-13-2025, 08:12 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(03-12-2025, 10:03 PM)Old Fart Wrote:
(03-12-2025, 09:59 PM)HugeHons Wrote:
(03-12-2025, 09:50 PM)Old Fart Wrote: The point was made on Sky that he pulled the ball back about three yards to give him a better chance of getting it up-over- and down.  Had he taken it from where the foul was committed he probably would not have scored. 



It's a bit like rugby conversions where the kicker can take the ball back as far as he likes to get the best angle providing that the ball is in line with where the try was scored. 

But a great shot nevertheless

Reminds me of a few years ago when football copied Rugby and could move the free kick forward for dissent. However, players disrupted on purpose sometimes so the free kick would be moved too close to achieve anything. They soon abandoned it.

Yes I had forgotten about that.  The law of unintended consequences.
Ah ! I wondered why they dropped it.
If footballers can find a way to cheat, they will. (Apologies - gain advantage, I mean).
I'm one who believes that football refereeing can learn a lot from rugby.
And, hypocritically, I think it was clever of Swift!

I think the respect for the ref thing is the only element of Rugby refereeing that should be applied. Whenever I watch Union I find the games are refereed appallingly. Far too open to interpretation at things like the scrum and the breakdown and impossible for a referee to see both sides of the scrum so he misses most of the cheating.
Reply
#12
I think it's probably true that the only person in rugby who understands the laws is the ref. I guess it's true that they're open to interpretation therefore.
Of course there's cheating in rugby - most sports I suppose. They say that golf is the one where there's none.
But yes I do admire the respect that rugby players give the ref.
A man who's sent off... goes off!
Reply
#13
(03-13-2025, 09:05 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: I think it's probably true that the only person in rugby who understands the laws is the ref. I guess it's true that they're open to interpretation therefore.
Of course there's cheating in rugby - most sports I suppose. They say that golf is the one where there's none.
But yes I do admire the respect that rugby players give the ref.
A man who's sent off... goes off!

Rugby Union is appalling for cheating - which leads to summary "justice" among players if they can get away with it and then it's beers all round after the game. To say nothing of Bloodgate and who knows what else goes on/has gone on. Union is bloody hypocritical.
Reply
#14
Remember, it's only cheating when done to your team, if your team do it, apparently it's the dark arts and is celebrated by seemingly quite a few.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: