Well Done Labour
#71
Here’s an interview with the GMTV this morning…

"I'm asking you about people with extreme disabilities who are unfit to work & they're going to lose money?"

& again

"Will people with extreme disabilities lose?"

& again

"Will people with extreme disabilities who are unfit to work lose money?"

Minister Alex Norris won't say

If this happens and you support it or make excuses for it, you’re a massive cunt end of discussion.
Reply
#72
I see you’ve moved on from the reality of how you go about that (ie outcomes) to ranting about the moral point. No one disagrees with your point Derek. You just haven’t explained how you’d get to it via anything that is grounded in the reality of what you have to do to get there.

No wonder you want to end the debate.
Reply
#73
(03-10-2025, 02:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I see you’ve moved on from the reality of how you go about that (ie outcomes) to ranting about the moral point. No one disagrees with your point Derek. You just haven’t explained how you’d get to it via anything that is grounded in the reality of what you have to do to get there.

No wonder you want to end the debate.

They can if they want to ring fence PIP for the mist disabled and ill. The fact they can alter swathes of the process and ‘support’ in other areas suggests this is a political decision not a practical one. You keep telling yourself it’s not, if it sits more easily with you. 

Morality is also a key point that should not be separated from any political decision and no Labour can’t pick and choose when to follow a moral compass as a party depending upon how difficult it is for them to implement policy. Particularly when they have traded so long as Labour have on being a caring and disabled friendly party. They clearly aren’t if these proposal leaks are true.

I also live in the real works and these abstract spreadsheet decisions that Smarmer, Reeves and Kendall are making will hurt people and will have negative consequences as the austerity cuts you were against when they wore a different coloured rosette.
Reply
#74
Derek - you’ve already seen from another poster that they simply don’t hold that data yet persist with some notion that they do. It’s very odd. If what you are suggesting is that people on higher rate mobility are simplistically segregated from other claimants then just state that. Otherwise all you are doing is repeating yourself with nothing new as to how to meet those outcomes.

You seem obsessed that people that are actually discussing how to get from A to Z with 7 million people in a short time have some sort of agenda. It’s really bizarre. Rant as much as you like, I’ve yet to see you explain how you conjure a stratified approach for which the fundamental data doesn’t yet exist.
Reply
#75
(03-10-2025, 03:51 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Derek - you’ve already seen from another poster that they simply don’t hold that data yet persist with some notion that they do. It’s very odd. If what you are suggesting is that people on higher rate mobility are simplistically segregated from other claimants then just state that. Otherwise all you are doing is repeating yourself with nothing new as to how to meet those outcomes.

You seem obsessed that people that are actually discussing how to get from A to Z with 7 million people in a short time have some sort of agenda. It’s really bizarre. Rant as much as you like, I’ve yet to see you explain how you conjure a stratified approach for which the fundamental data doesn’t yet exist.

The data exists because for every other disability payment and support they receive they will have been assessed to make a claim. They can alter the categories based on existing data that will be held somewhere in the system. 

You’ve gone from Labour aren’t going to do that to the most vulnerable in society to Labour have got to do it because it’s too difficult not too. 

If this was the Tories you and the other Labour supporters in here would be scathing about even the idea of doing this but because your side is doing it is justified because it’s too difficult not to.
Reply
#76
You’ve literally just had someone who worked at the DWP tell you otherwise.

I agree with changing the assessments. I agree with altering UC so some get more and some get less.

I agree that PIP needs reform and am realistic that it will take time due to the reality of how it has to be done.

You can keep trying to make up things that I haven’t said but it won’t change any of the above.

You seem to be suggesting that someone quickly flick through 7 million forms and work out how to reconstitute how they are divided. Do you realise how daft that sounds?

I’m saying the welfare system is broke and no amount of wailing about that on here will be a quick fix
Reply
#77
(03-10-2025, 04:08 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: You’ve literally just had someone who worked at the DWP tell you otherwise.

I agree with changing the assessments. I agree with altering UC so some get more and some get less.

I agree that PIP needs reform and am realistic that it will take time due to the reality of how it has to be done.

You can keep trying to make up things that I haven’t said but it won’t change any of the above.

You seem to be suggesting that someone quickly flick through 7 million forms and work out how to reconstitute how they are divided. Do you realise how daft that sounds?

I’m saying the welfare system is broke and no amount of wailing about that on here will be a quick fix

You don’t use people with severe disabilities or terminal conditions as collateral damage whilst you fix the problems they didn’t create, can’t fix and erm can’t and never will be able to work to solve. That should never be up for discussion in a decent society led by a decent Government. 

Also you suggest that this is the only option open to Labour when it clearly isn’t. They are punching down  because it’s easier to do than the alternatives. Grown up’s wouldn’t pick on the weakest unless they were bullies.
Reply
#78
Still no solutions just rhetoric
Reply
#79
(03-10-2025, 08:47 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’m not sure I agree with that Proth. I’d say that the changes in society have exacerbated the number and nature of those conditions. They are now occurring more broadly, in more depth and sustained for longer. That isn’t to say life was always tough and that this generation has it worse - it doesn’t. It’s just different and as you’ve said yourself, the impact of covid and school closures (amongst other things) has been marked

The widespread medicalisation of sadness and irritability is insane. I hear it everywhere I go, bleeding adults deciding they're suddenly on the spectrum at the age of 50, kids who have "maths anxiety" rather than being not very good at maths, and the drugs being pumped into teenagers to deal with apparent ADHD is a disaster.
Reply
#80
That is a portion of the pie for sure and your last point about medicalisation of ADHD is spot on. It’s a tragedy
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)